8 ms·
Was the aspect of using YouTube's servers so critical to the artistic quality of this project that he couldn't just substitute a shell script that encodes the v
by dangrossman 16y ago
Was the aspect of using YouTube's servers so critical to the artistic quality of this project that he couldn't just substitute a shell script that encodes the video 1000 times over? Would've taken a heck of a lot less time than the year he spent.
- ghurlman 16y agoThe benefit is that all 1000 videos are available on YouTube - you can check out the quality at any step along the way.
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoMaybe I'm overthinking it, but couldn't he have written a shell script that did the uploading and dowloading to Youtube? How would we know if he did?
- maukdaddy 16y agoDespite what you might think, the majority of the planet has no clue what a shell script is.
- dschobel 16y agoSavages.
- eru 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_ignorance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_ignorance
- mscarborough 16y agoGood point, but it's possible that he enjoyed the process somewhat. Recording 'I am sitting in a room' probably became a little tedious for Lucier as well, in all the time he spent from conceptualization until completion. And even if he did not enjoy it at all, patio11 makes another good point about it being a better background story for the piece.
- eru 16y agoYes, you are probably right. My comment was aimed at the snobbery over the unwashed masses.
- jazzychad 16y agoPerhaps, in addition to the artistic aspect of it, he wanted to educate people about what actually happens to video when it is sent to youtube. This is much more relatable than saying, "I wrote this shell script..." Also, having the log of all 1000 versions on youtube is interesting as well. The other thing about art is that time is usually not a large motivating factor...
- jemfinch 16y agoThe thing is, I'm not convinced that it's youtube's fault; apparently he converted it to mp4 on his own computer after the download from youtube, before re-uploading it. I wonder if he'd have had the same effect if he'd uploaded the same format he ripped from youtube.
- megablast 16y agoNobody is blaming youtube, video compression or anything of the such. This is to expected behaviour. And no normal person should be able to expect, or want to upload and download a video 1000 times, or even more than 10.
- jokermatt999 16y agoHe does say "and the mp4 codec" in his speech, so that's acknowledged at least.
- kno 16y agoThere are clear reasons why not everyone is an artist, patience and endurance is are a huge part of it.
- ars 16y agoThat's also the same reason many people look down on (modern) artists. The use patience to do something everyone else would do in a more efficient way.
- deleted 16y ago
- eli 16y agoSometimes the artistic process is just as important as the final product.
- patio11 16y agoA lot of modern art is sold as a story, and for whatever reason the kind of folks who matter think that "did something by hand a thousand times" is a much better story than "wrote a Perl script." Art isn't the only thing that has stories, incidentally. Tomatoes have stories these days. (OK, the kind of tomatoes rich people eat have stories. Only poor people eat tomatoes that have no stories.)
- exit 16y agoi think products targeted at low income demographics are very much sold with a story. a kind of utilitarian "sensibleness" which facilitates contempt for more expensive products. why would advertisers neglect to exploit human psychology at all socioeconomic levels?
- GFischer 16y agoI believe you're right... a hugely successful ad for the Tang powdered drink in South America showed a spoilt rich kid asking his butler for Tang after they were stranded with no oranges in sight. (One of the messages I take from the ad was that the rich kid was missing on what the butler knew all along)
- dschobel 16y agoOf course it is universal; what is advertising but giving products a compelling narrative?
- cdr 16y agoNo, I'm pretty tomatoes are just sold as tomatoes. Produce is produce until you're trying to justify charging a multiplier of the base price.
- 16y ago
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- alexyim 16y agoAre you just making the blind assumption that he's a programmer?
- Tichy 16y agoOne year means he could have spent 364 days learning how to program and do all the 1000 uploads on the final day of the year...
- xenophanes 16y agoI agree, but... One day for 1000 iterations means 86.4 seconds to upload to youtube, wait for encoding to finish, then download it. Youtube is slower than that. :-) Better give it a week. Maybe a month.
- pjscott 16y agoHe could work on something else during that month. Automation!
- xenophanes 16y agoYes of course, but he can't take 364 days to learn to program.
- amalcon 16y agoOr one (maybe a few, I don't know what the going rate for something like this) day working for minimum wage, a few hours to find a freelance programmer, and paying the programmer to write the upload script. Then, spend ~360 days doing whatever. Something tells me this project was not about efficiency.
- mos1b 16y agoI make maple syrup by hand. It requires a huge amount of physical labor, as well as a fairly expensive evaporator and as well as a small building devoted to that single purpose. The product tastes the same as the stuff I can buy from my neighbor's maple stand for a fraction of the cost and effort. It's wholly irrational. And I'll do it again next year. Sometimes the joy comes from doing it the hard way.
- sohooo 16y agoYeah, I immediately thought of this t-shirt when reading your comment :) http://www.thinkgeek.com/tshirts-apparel/unisex/frustrations/374d/ http://www.thinkgeek.com/tshirts-apparel/unisex/frustrations...
- orlandu63 16y agoYes it was. The guy wanted to encode the videos using Youtube's _unknown_ encoding process. Encoding using ffmpeg with its default settings isn't the same. (We can now extrapolate Youtube's encoding logic rather than make blind assumptions, which would be the case if the latter were done instead.)
- FlorinAndrei 16y agoI'm pretty sure they use (perhaps a custom version of) x264 to encode video.
- FlorinAndrei 16y agoBecause "YouTube" has a meaning for regular people, while "x264" doesn't.
- kierank 16y agoA lot of people I speak to associate x264 with pirated film downloads.
- nerme 16y agoThere is a rather large spiritual aspect to mankind's creation of art. If you look at the history of art, in the western world and elsewhere, it is strongly tied to some sort of religion. Religious practice typically implements some sort of repetitive behavior or meditation, where the goal is not necessarily to get something done in the physical world. If you run the process through some sort of reductionist approach, you wouldn't have art to begin with. Why even make a piece of art? What's the point? While it is interesting to view the creation of art through the lens of an engineer, any attempt to criticize the work through only this lens is not going to stand up very well.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]