7 ms·
> Companies want to know that their advertising dollars are actually producing results, and traditional advertising completely sucks at this. If you've never r
by busterarm 10y ago
> Companies want to know that their advertising dollars are actually producing results, and traditional advertising completely sucks at this. If you've never run a traditional ad campaign, I suggest giving it a try and then decide how much value you think you got out of it. You can spend thousands to millions of dollars and have absolutely no idea if your money impacted sales even the smallest amount. Compare that to adtech, where you get real data on outcomes on a regular basis. Even if it's crap data, it's often better than "well we think the brand is stronger now".
They want it this way. My company at its core relies on traditional advertising. Our leads are finally at the point that we're roughly 1:1 between traditional and online.
We've built tools to determine the effectiveness of our traditional ad spend so that we can better target our spend, but we're getting a ton of resistance to us using them. This is from our own internal person who has been running the traditional side of our ad spend for 30 years. Every player in the traditional ads game benefits from keeping the people controlling the spending completely in the dark.
- gregw134 10y agoWhat kind of tool do you have to monitor traditional ad spend? According to op this should be impossible.
- wtvanhest 10y agoMost large companies use a quantitative model with various inputs and outputs. For example, if you know you spend X in market Y, but not market Z you can measure lift within some confidence level between the markets. Imagine a model with every market, and sku, plus the inputs also know where you spent ad dollars and on what product.
- robertlagrant 10y agoThe "some confidence level" is the problem - how do you come close to quantifying and removing all the other effects that are involved? This stuff always just becomes something that can be debated away if the advertising lead is popular, or otherwise used as an excuse to fire him/her.
- wtvanhest 10y agoMultifactor model
- busterarm 10y agoDefinitely quantitative. And just like everything with advertising, you run experiments constantly. We also have this fun problem where nobody's actually been verifying that TV ads actually run when they're supposed to. We have physical offices in all of the locations we advertise for the most part, so we're talking about setting up slingboxes and programmatically verifying that our ads actually run.
- trimbo 10y ago>We also have this fun problem where nobody's actually been verifying that TV ads actually run when they're supposed to Have you considered hiring Kantar to check if the ads are running? They do this.
- busterarm 10y agoThanks for the suggestion. We have a lot of markets that we'd have to check and I imagine it's cost prohibitive. It's actually a very easy thing to build. Moreover, we're kind of the big company in this space. We own many of the billboards we (and our competitors advertise on). We have multiple different platforms that we sell to our "competition". They're 10-20 years behind us in tech and the budget/desire to get there. It makes sense that we build this ourselves and keep it that way.
- EwanToo 10y agoThere's various companies that do this for you as a service, including verifying the reach across market research panels. If you want a fairly raw build-your-own solution you could speak to someone like TVEyes who'll give you an mpeg or mp3 feed from 100s of channels across the USA. If you insert a fingerprint into your advert audio, you can then auto-detect plays across the entire country.
- ithinkinstereo 10y agoTwo ideas: 1) Coupons or discount codes in print and tv/radio ads (or using a unique URL, phone number, etc.) 2) Simply watching to see if leads traffic (however you define it: foot traffic, hits to website, calls, etc.) surges in the period post ad campaign (assuming you stagger your campaigns for better individual campaign tracking)
- busterarm 10y ago#2 is the right way to do it and how we do it. #1 isn't an option for us because we don't take upfront payment, or really any money directly, from our clients. Tons of companies try this and it's expensive and doesn't convert well for everyone. In certain kinds of sales pipelines this works, but many times it's just people searching for a coupon code online and you don't get accurate information about what converted.
- mdorazio 10y agoIs your spend also roughly 1:1 on traditional and online? In my own experience qualified lead gen ROI has been significantly higher with online.
- busterarm 10y agoTraditional dwarfs our online budget. That said, online is still significant. We're bidding on 3 of the top 10 most expensive google keywords.
- thesagan 10y agoI spent a few years working closely at a regional ad/P.R. firm in a smaller metro, and the game was to convince companies to spend because their competitors are spending. Although there might be good tools out there to measure results, it would only create more work for an ad staff that already has received buy-in from traditional advertisers. (Although that's changing now.) Disrupting that non-measurement disrupts the steady stream of, what is IMO, clueless revenue that's been F.U.D'd into an ad spend. I mean, F.U.D. was the business model half the time.