2 ms·
I think that was a rather confusingly written article. It uses the word evolution in several different senses which means that it is hard to see if the writer
by kwhitefoot 10y ago
I think that was a rather confusingly written article. It uses the word evolution in several different senses which means that it is hard to see if the writer really understands the subject. Yet, he is a professor at Harvard so I think it is safe to assume that he really does understand it.
The problem is that a careless reader could quite easily skim the article and conclude that the moths, for instance, had undergone genetic changes as a result of the environmental changes when all that had happened was that the proportion of the population that was darkly pigmented had increased, presumably because predators were able to see the lighter variants more easily. If it had continued long enough it is quite possible that this variation in frequency could have become fixed by driving the light coloured variants out entirely.
But evolution, as I understand it anyway, is the combination of mutation plus the fixation of that mutation through differential survival; that is we have to include the origin of the light and dark varieties as well as the differential survival of them.
Lastly this:
> The moths evolved to become dark in order to match the background of these trees.
That's backwards. The dark variants already matched the trees, selection pressure (differential predation) caused that variant to become more frequent in the population when the environment changed.
It would make sense to say:
The moth population evolved to become dark because they matched the background of these trees thus resulting in fewer of them being eaten by birds.
But even that is open to misinterpretation because not everyone will distinguish between the moths and the population.
There is no shortage of well written works on this subject so it is a pity to see a confusing one mentioned on HN.
I personally recommend Almost Like a Whale: The 'Origin of Species' Updated by Steve Jones for a popular rendering and The Blind Watchmaker and The Extended Phenotype by Richard Dawkins for those wanting a more technical explanation.
A disclaimer: unlike itchyjunk I really am not an expert, just a moderately well read engineer with physics degree.