3 ms·
Every now and then I come across someone who thinks data is like water and we should have standardised 'pipes' and components for processing and transporting da
by simonh 10y ago
Every now and then I come across someone who thinks data is like water and we should have standardised 'pipes' and components for processing and transporting data and converting it between formats like we have pipes and valves for transporting and purifying water.
But data isn't like water, it's like 'chemicals'. You can't have a standard component for processing data the same way you can't have a single components that knows how to process sulphuric acid, crude oil, hydrazine, mercury and molten salt.
Data can be binary, delimited, fixed field, lossy, ASCII, Many variations of Unicode, executable, contain attack such as SQL injection, encrypted, have time sensitive delivery requirements, include checksums, require checksums to be applied in the protocol, be meaningless without metadata or other data, and have who knows what other constraints, limitations and requirements.
Building a data processing system is not at all like building a water works. It's more like building a chemicals processing plant.
- erikb 10y agoAll valid. But if you want to avoid a shock, please don't talk to people who transport actual water in actual pipes. I bet you'd be surprised how many different standards of pipes there are and the long list of features that separate one kind of water from the other. ;-)
- simonh 10y agoAn excellent point, thank you.
- kordless 10y agoI think the point may include the fact a chemical plant and a water plant are not that much different in comparison to something which is would appear to be a radical shift in approach. It is my opinion that this will be the function AI serves in reality.
- elcritch 10y agoSame thoughts on AI + data. Well, as a dream. In reality programming seems to be one of the last areas AI is applied to despite the potential benefits.
- kordless 10y agoA "protocol" is just a good excuse to create a consciousness entity, which itself is designed to interpret the communication between two other entities.
- SolarNet 10y agoHonestly that enhances the narrative. Just be like "data isn't like our idealized view of water" and "even water requires different pipes in different circumstances".
- erikb 10y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAuEoo3lgKM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAuEoo3lgKM
- zeeZ 10y agoIf you want to offend both groups: Germany has a joke item called a "Gardena RJ45 Adapter"[0] which allows you to connect your garden hose to your network... [0] https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-QkYNnuYZs8Y/Uf0y_mV-1uI/AAAAAAAAb7E/0hD1JEcIoxk/s1600/photo.jpg https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-QkYNnuYZs8Y/Uf0y_mV-1uI/A...