18 ms·
The Weirdness of CRISPR
- stepik777 10y agoBTW there is a patent pool being formed by MPEG LA to license CRISPR. It seems to be similar to patent pools for video codecs. * http://www.mpegla.com/main/pid/CRISPR/default.aspx http://www.mpegla.com/main/pid/CRISPR/default.aspx * http://www.mpegla.com/Lists/MPEG%20LA%20News%20List/Attachments/102/CRISPR%20PrsRls%202016-12-06.pdf http://www.mpegla.com/Lists/MPEG%20LA%20News%20List/Attachme...
- mmastrac 10y agoThis feels like the MPEG-LA is realizing that patent pools for video codecs are a short-lived industry and trying to figure out how they can extend their tendrils into something for another 20 years.
- jfarlow 10y agoYou have got to be kidding me... ...you are not. What is this insanity?
- wuschel 10y agoIt's just about vampires.
- IncRnd 10y agoFrom the about page of mpegla.com: "We are the world’s leading packager of patent pools for standards and other technology platforms used in consumer electronics, as well as chemical, eCommerce, education, energy, environment, healthcare and biotechnology, manufacturing and materials, transportation and wireless technology. We developed the pool market space. (view link) Our business model supports a large number of patent users – creating reasonable access and profitable opportunities for all parties."
- SCHiM 10y agoCan somebody explain what exactly the problem is with this? Did they not have a hand in any of the research? Do they provide a genuinely useful service yes/no?
- quakeguy 10y agoThey want to earn money, nothing more. No knowledge is gained, no wisdom is earned here. Just plain old money interests at work. Some call it capitalism, i call it greed.
- SolarNet 10y agoActually it's called rent-seeking and many capitalists would also call it bad (namely stemming from the failures of the patent system).
- monochromatic 10y agoIf they're buying up patents, they're enriching the people who are making these inventions.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoSuch organizations free up people like Jennifer Doudna to spend time in their labs (i.e., their area of expertise) rather than spending time sitting in meetings with lawyers and similar krill from companies that want to license the technology. How is that not a valuable service?
- jfarlow 10y agoMPEG LA is a for profit firm that has historically specialized in getting huge corporations in a room, the patents surrounding a technology all of them need, and getting them to agree on a standard code to be licensed to everyone: Apple, Cisco, Dolby, Fujitsu, HP, Hitachi, MS, NTT, Panasonic, Samsung, Sony, etc. They have no biomedical or biochemical expertise. They have no hand whatsoever in discovering or understanding any science at all. It now appears as though they would like to try to get another group of mega-companies in a room to cross license their patents on Cas9 variants - there are as many (natural) variants as there are bacteria out there, and there are a combinatorially large number of synthetic variants on top of those. The Berkeley/MIT faceoff you've likely heard about in the news is over a very broad patent on using Cas9 therapeutically, but the space of natural Cas9 variants is actually broader still than even that patent could cover. We as a country need to have a conversation about patents and how the policies that work for computer code may not be the same policies that work for small molecules, which may not be the same processes that work for genetically encoded materials. Each of those technologies are all extreme in terms of the cost of R&D, verifiability, producibility, reproducibilty, and longevity. It is difficult to shoehorn each of these technologies into the same patent framework.
- edge17 10y agoSorry, I'm a bit lost. Am I missing something? According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MPEG_LA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MPEG_LA MPEG LA, LLC is a firm based in Denver, Colorado that licenses patent pools covering essential patents required[1][2] for use of the MPEG-2,[3] MPEG-4 Visual (Part 2), IEEE 1394, VC-1, ATSC, MVC, MPEG-2 Systems, AVC/H.264 and HEVC standards. MPEG LA is not affiliated with MPEG, the Moving Picture Experts Group. Doesn't that mean MPEG LA is affiliated with MPEG?
- ajdlinux 10y agoMPEG creates the MPEG codec standards, MPEG LA is a separate organisation that exists to sell patent licences required to actually implement the MPEG standards. They don't particularly need to be affiliated.
- ckastner 10y ago> They don't particularly need to be affiliated. MPEG LA, however, would like you to believe that, seeing as LA is (or at least, was) an abbreviation of Licensing Authority -- something they clearly aren't.
- deeth_starr_v 10y agoYep, patent trolls
- Para2016 10y agoCRISPR, Gene Drive, and IPSC biotech is incredible. Right now I'm killing time until my residency starts and I've been reading recent journal articles relating to each of these. One of the weirder journal articles I read was about this one group taking fibroblasts from XX and XO (Turner's syndrome) females and XY cells from a male and de-differntiating them into induced pluripotent stem cells. They then re-differentiated the cells into germ cells. Sure, that's not controversial just yet, but then they decided to put the XX female germ cells into a teste. The female germ cells (XX and XO) and the male XY cells all differentiated into cells that could succesfully undergo meiosis. And these cells, could terminally become sperm. That means an XX skin cell could be induced to become a sperm and possibly fertilize an egg from another woman. Of course all offspring would be XX female. This process totally bypasses males. Anyways, very interesting to me, maybe it will be to others. Here's the journal article. http://www.nature.com/articles/srep06432 http://www.nature.com/articles/srep06432 I know this article I'm posting under is about CRISPR, but I feel like new/controversial biology research could be posted here too. Hopefully anyone reading gets the same feeling of discovery/wonder/incredulity that I had when reading about it.
- jwilliams 10y agoGene drive is particularly interesting and novel approach... And seems like a huge tarpit for ethics of Gene tech.
- Edmond 10y agothe end of men indeed :) as if being automated out of relevance was not enough soon you can take your sperm with you as you retire to the "manly hills"...interesting times ahead.
- m_mueller 10y agoDid you know that fetal viability outside of the womb now starts right after 21 weeks (although with a currently still low chance of survival)? At some point science will probably start figuring out the mechanics of gestation and - eventually - synthesise the whole process, at which point you could call it 'the end of woman' as well. What's left then? Maybe "The Matrix" was quite realistic, only, we're building it ourselves.
- phkahler 10y agoDo humans have the same low level immune system bacteria have? It seems like passing immunity between generations would be extremely unlikely, but it could still be useful for offering some immunity to viruses that one has already had. Would it be possible to introduce a genetic template from a viral disease into an embryo to produce a human essentially immune to that virus?
- Para2016 10y agoThere is something in humans called Dicer - which is an enzyme that uses RNA to cause RNA interference. It has a role in destruction of viruses that use RNA. Here's a short wiki about it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dicer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dicer
- pazimzadeh 10y agoThis paper claims to have found RNA interference in mammals (https://cl.ly/jq5X https://cl.ly/jq5X). This paper is an attempt to refute the first paper (https://cl.ly/jq5T https://cl.ly/jq5T). The crux of the debate is that mammals have the interferon system to respond to viruses, so why would they have kept around a system like CRISPR?
- Ultimatt 10y agoCRISPR is a solution to just retroviruses. Bacteria through phages actually come under more attack than humans in this way. If you've got a single cell for the next generation you care a lot about this. Humans any old crap can happen to litterally trillions of cells without affecting the germ line. CRISPR itself has capacity to introduce damage to the genome. So its a balance between error correction and error introduction. In Bacteria its worth it, in humans not so much, especially as we have a bunch of other subtler more complex ways of handling viruses before they get all the way to the nucleus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RNA_interference https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RNA_interference Bacteria dont have this luxury as their DNA lacks this extra barrier. The biggest difference is simply cells dont matter in a human and can just kill themselves if all else fails. The rest of the "innate" immune system has similar proteins involved nearly everywhere e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toll-like_receptor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toll-like_receptor These are the components involved in cell surface recognition of sugars. But much more similar between all animals than animals and bacteria. Answer to your second question is yes you could add a CRISPR construct with templates for known disease and add artificial immunity. However, finessing this so that CRISPR doesnt cause lots of damage from randomly cutting your DNA throught your life leading to a higher risk of systemic cancers... is a big hurdle.
- jfarlow 10y agoNow that we've made economical the tools to sequence, search, and have some understanding of an organism's genome, we're reaping fast rewards in learning what the natural world is actually capable of in terms of astounding feats of nano-engineering. There's a massive nanotechnology textbook in our ecosystem's genomes that's a few orders of magnitude more impressive than our best semiconductor patents. The CRISPR system here was discovered in a single-celled organism that likes brine water - a tool it used to intercept hijackers. The 'standard' Cas9 that is being used extensively in the rest of the CRIPSR stories comes from the bacteria that causes strep throat. Studies are now mining the genomes of organisms found in 'mud pits' and 'pond scum' to find all sorts of smaller, faster, more efficient variants of Cas9. And that's just for the single purpose of editing a genome. The capabilities of proteins found (off the top of my head) in jellyfish, in sulfur springs, in colored algae, in electric eels, in little pond creatures, in HIV, in waterbears, etc. are all depositing huge amounts of technology into our collective knowledgebank. We have been given a store of 'alien' technologies to sift through that are applicable in every condition to be found on Earth, literally. The cures to many of our ills will not be engineered from scratch, but rather will be adapted from existing technologies found in extant organisms literally scattered across the globe. This is how 'basic science' works. A magnanimous scientist is curious how a little cell can survive in really salty water, and owing to his curiosity we discover a nanotechnology that can edit an organism's genome. We humans are smart - but not yet that smart. (some of those protein technologies we like to talk about here on HN: https://serotiny.bio/notes/proteins/ https://serotiny.bio/notes/proteins/ )
- graycat 10y agoUnderstand, just understand, understand how something works, what makes it tick, in biology, chemistry, physics, mathematics, the economy, etc., just, darn it, UNDERSTAND .... As we know well from experience and might expect, just understand is nearly necessary for a huge fraction of fantastic progress and often sufficient or nearly so. The track record is the best of any allocation of resources. Or toss some rocks into the camp fire and in the morning find some clump at the bottom. Then, try to UNDERSTAND that? That clump is different; what the heck is it? This was the first time saw this; what caused it? Can do that again? Okay, just used the carbon in the fire to remove the oxygen from copper oxide and leave some copper metal. Start of exploitation of metals for humans ....
- somberi 10y agoI learnt a bit from listening to this Podcast from Radiolab. http://www.radiolab.org/story/update-crispr/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/update-crispr/
- archon810 10y agoThat's what I immediately thought of as well. Fascinating episode, I highly recommend listening to it.
- carapace 10y agoSmall sans-serif body text means you hate your readers.