3 ms·
The Economist is largely in support of regulation to fight climate change, attributes some countries' economic woes to their governments being too weak (rather
by closeparen 10y ago
The Economist is largely in support of regulation to fight climate change, attributes some countries' economic woes to their governments being too weak (rather than too strong), supports a social safety net including retraining for workers affected by trade, thinks austerity in parts of Europe has gone too far, etc. They're also frequent critics of central banking policy, from the viewpoint that central banks should take certain actions in certain circumstances. They've written approvingly of QE, for example.
Their viewpoint reminds me of my economics professor. What is good is what leads to the most economic growth, which is a question the science of economics can address. Welfare has a role. Regulation has a role. Monetary policy has a role. Education has a role. Healthcare has a role (people may remain in situations of suboptimal productivity to maintain health coverage). All can be done poorly, but all must be done well to have optimal productivity. Principles like comparative advantage and supply and demand are largely reliable, and should guide policy. The market will get most things right, and for the rest, government should manage the externalities. Government can have good reasons to impede business, but the benefits should be in line with the costs.
It is the Economist, after all. Free trade being a good idea is uncontroversial among academic economists. So yeah, you aren't going to see them in favor of protectionism. You will see them represent a wider diversity of opinions on monetary policy, in accordance with its not being so much of a settled question.
They support a much larger role for the state than the "personal responsibility"-thumping, climate-change-denying Republicans in Congress, and are certainly far left of the you're-not-the-boss-of-me Bitcoin-thumping internet libertarians.
- jonnathanson 10y ago"thinks austerity in parts of Europe has gone too far, etc." This is significant editorial change of heart. The Economist was a loud, regular voice in favor of austerity policies for many years. That it has written critically of austerity programs in 2016-17 is great, but it's something of a Damascene conversion for the paper.
- zigzigzag 10y agoThey changed editor. Micklethwaite stepped down and he was replaced by Zanny Minton Beddoes, who apparently has rather different political views ...
- FabHK 10y agoMaybe, though a more charitable interpretation is that more and more evidence came through for more Keynesian view points. There was the discrediting of the R-R paper, there was more and more papers critical of austerity coming out of the IMF of all places, etc. As Keynes is reputed to have said, "When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?"
- spangry 10y agoThere really ought to be a pithy expression that simultaneously conveys the ideas of 'a breath of fresh air' and 'sanity'. This is a pretty good summary of how most economists working in the public service tend to view the world too (at least in my experience). It's unfortunate that public discussion of economic issues has become so politicised and disconnected from reality. We seem to have reached the point where many believe the word 'economist' is a synonym for 'libertarian demagogue'. Either that or economists are thought to be 'those guys that trade shares for a living'. However, it does seem like there's an awful lot of these libertarian 'economists' running around the internet nowadays...
- JCzynski 10y ago"A breath of fresh sanity" When in doubt, portmanteau the idiom.
- FabHK 10y ago> Free trade being a good idea is uncontroversial among academic economists. Yes, with the caveat that the theoretical argument in favour of free trade (say, in a Heckscher-Olin 2 countries, 2 goods, 2 factors model) depends on compensation to the losers of trade, i.e. redistribution, transfer payments. That's what turns it (theoretically) into a Pareto improvement: you go from no trade to free trade, then compensate the losers in both countries, and then still have cloth and wine left to distribute at will. Also, less naive and more realistic models make it all much more ambiguous and complicated. At any rate, even the simple Econ 101 model says: free trade is unambiguously good, if you tax the winners and give to the losers... and that second part is often conveniently forgotten by some, because "free markets" and all.
- eru 10y agoThe Economist is not named for the profession, though.