4 ms·
Your factorization of 2 is wrong. (1 + i)² = 2i 2 = (1 + i)(1 - i) I don't think that invalidates anything else you have here, much of which is interesting.
by jessaustin 10y ago
Your factorization of 2 is wrong.
(1 + i)² = 2i
2 = (1 + i)(1 - i)
I don't think that invalidates anything else you have here, much of which is interesting.
- mrkgnao 10y agoApologies. I was remembering more than I was thinking: you are right in that the relation doesn't hold at the level of elements[0]. The correct statement is (2) = (1+i)^2 where (2) and (1+i) represent the ideals generated by 2 and 1+i respectively. Officially, an ideal of a ring R is a subset I of R which is closed under addition and under and multiplication by elements of R: i, j ∈ I implies i + j ∈ I i ∈ I implies ri ∈ I for all r ∈ R For our purposes, a simpler case -- that of principal ideals -- suffices, and that's what I'll discuss in the rest of this comment. The ideal generated by an element a of a ring R, usually denoted (a) or aR, is essentially the subset of all multiples of a in R. For instance, over the integers, we have ideals like (2) = {..., -4, -2, 0, 2, 4, ...} (3) = {..., -6, -3, 0, 3, 6, ...} (4) = {..., -8, -4, 0, 4, 8, ...} (6) = {..., -12, -6, 0, 6, 12, ...} One can also define the ideal generated by the elements a,b,c,... of R: (a,b,c,...) = {aa' + bb' + cc' + ... : a',b',c' ∈ R} i.e. the "linear combinations" of a, b, c, and so on. Here are a few things you might like to verify (i.e. just nod along) about some ideals of Z, to get familiar with the notation: (1) = Z (i.e. all the integers) (2) = (-2) (6) = (2) ∩ (3) 15Z = 3Z ∩ 5Z where ∩ is the intersection of the two sets, or the set of common elements. ("Fact": The intersection of two ideals is also an ideal.) In general, if you have an ideal of the form (a), then we always have (a) = (ua) for all units u Write G (for Gauss?) for Z[i]. In G, the previous statement means that (2) = (2i). To check this, note that we have x ∈ (2) iff x = 2y for some y iff x = (2i)(-yi) iff x ∈ (2i) so all elements of (2) are in (2i), and vice versa. Now one defines the product of ideals: given ideals I and J in some ring R, IJ = ideal generated by the elements {ij : i ∈ I, j ∈ J} In our case, if I = (a) and J = (b), IJ is just (ab). Question: what's the relation between (ab) and (a) ∩ (b)? For instance, you can verify that (2)(3) = (6) and, to bring us back to our original point, (1+i)(1-i) = (2i) = (2) = (1+i)^2 where all the products are ideal products. -- There is a very incomplete treatment at [1] (with a bit of the LaTeX broken) that is meant to provide background for a sequence of posts on algebraic geometry -- it's been suspended for a while, but I'm going to look over a couple of drafts this week! [1]: https://mrkgnao.github.io/prime-ideals/ https://mrkgnao.github.io/prime-ideals/ [0]: As always in math: if you can't prove it, just add a few adjectives or simply change the language. Facts arrived at by alternative definitions, if you will. :)
- yaks_hairbrush 10y agoThe factorization of 2 is fine -- factorizations are equivalent if they're off by a unit, and i is a unit. By the same token, 1+i and 1-i are essentially the same prime, since you can multiply one by a unit to get the other. That's how we can get away with saying 2 is a power. edit: Just noticed the sibling comment by mrkgnao, which is a very good overview of some of the technical nitty-gritty that goes into this.