6 ms·
Meat has all essential amino acids, has Vitamin B12, can be minimally processed, is the only food source of creatine. Plus, we've been omnivores for millions of
by paulddraper 10y ago
Meat has all essential amino acids, has Vitamin B12, can be minimally processed, is the only food source of creatine. Plus, we've been omnivores for millions of years.
The empirical health benefits of vegetarianism vanish once you control for health-consciousness.
Trying to paint some bleak health picture on all meats is plain FUD.
- mrob 10y agoAll the health benefits of meat can be obtained from eating salt-water mussels. Their sensory and motor abilities are extremely similar to that of plants, and they can be farmed on ropes with no environmental damage. This isn't true of bivalves in general (eg. scallops have primitive eyes and can swim). https://sentientist.org/2013/05/20/the-ethical-case-for-eating-oysters-and-mussels/ https://sentientist.org/2013/05/20/the-ethical-case-for-eati...
- paulddraper 10y agoInteresting. And to clarity my earlier statement, there are plausible reasons to not eat meat: animal suffering, cost, environmental impact. Avoiding absolutely all meat on the basis of health reasons (the original context of the discussion) is bogus.
- fredsir 10y agoWhy do you figure that since it's established that it's less healthy than the alternatives?
- matt4077 10y agoIt's really not that clear. Vegetarians live longer, but that probably means we should all live like them, not eat like them: they tend to smoke less, get more exercise, and (because they tend to be better educated and wealthier) have better healthcare and even social lives. Smoking is pretty easy to correct for, but then these vegetarians all run off, work in soup kitchens, and get flooded with endorphins from the joy of altruism, and physical exertion. Try measuring that! If I had to summarise what I remember from when I studied something related, I'd say your best bet is to eat (a) small amounts of (b) mostly white meat. (a) is pretty obvious: a bit of meat on occasion is enough to ward off any possible malnutrition. If you don't go fully vegan the risk isn't high, but neither is any negative effect the meat may have. (b) is probably more controversial, but contrary to what a certain crowd has been hyping, it seems like the evidence against red meat is still ahead. More in regards to cancer, a little less for cardiovascular diseases. The mechanisms aren't clear: Harald zur Hausen (Nobel for HPV) thinks it's viruses from undercooked red meat and only eats it well-done. Cholesterol is more of a symptom than a cause...etc.
- fredsir 10y ago> (a) is pretty obvious: a bit of meat on occasion is enough to ward off any possible malnutrition. If you don't go fully vegan the risk isn't high, but neither is any negative effect the meat may have. You can also ward off any possible malnutrition by eating completely plant-based. It's not hard. You gotta eat more varied than when you eat animal products, but that comes with a bunch of added benefits, so it's really a win-win, and even a small portion of white meat on occasion is a huge tax on the environment compared to plants, and it still comes with all the ethical drawbacks, if you are concerned about that at all. > (b) is probably more controversial, but contrary to what a certain crowd has been hyping, it seems like the evidence against red meat is still ahead. More in regards to cancer, a little less for cardiovascular diseases. The mechanisms aren't clear: Harald zur Hausen (Nobel for HPV) thinks it's viruses from undercooked red meat and only eats it well-done. Cholesterol is more of a symptom than a cause...etc. In any case, science is clear that it's a lot more unhealthy than eating a plant-based diet. It baffles me that people focus on the "it's possible it's not as bad as they say, even though science agrees it's bad, so lets eat it", instead of the "well, there is a lot of controversy about how quickly eating animal products is gonna kill me, so lets just eat the things that don't and that also doesn't unnecessarily destroy our planet and is ethically corrupt".
- milesrout 10y agoThe problem is that it's a bad comparison to compare people that eat red meat with people that don't. Lots of people that eat red meat eat it in the form of highly processed low quality meat that's cooked in too much fat and oil, for a start. Lots of them eat far too much of it as well. Nobody is saying 'a steak a day keeps the doctor away'. But red meat is good for you: it's full of all sorts of essential nutrients that you need. It's tasty, and if it were in any serious way harmful then we wouldn't be eating it.
- fredsir 10y agoIndeed, unprocessed meat is better than processed meat. That the story with just about anything, also plants. The unhealthy aspect of red meat is 1) it contains a lot of stuff you don't want to consume, like cholesterol, hormones, too much saturated fat, recycled drugs and shit and 2) you can get all these good and important nutrients from other food sources that does not contain the bad stuff, and since there is no benefit to consuming these things via red meat compared to say plants, red meat turns out to be a negative to your health instead of a positive.
- pvaldes 10y ago> they can be farmed on ropes with no environmental damage Some activities are worst than other; but all have some effect on the environment. Mussel farms release sediments to the sea floor below, modifying its granular structure. This changes the communities of organisms living in the area.
- miles 10y agoAfter watching "What the Health"[1], it seems like there is no small amount of FUD coming from the meat industry. And the long-term health benefits of plant-based diets are well-established[2,3,4,5]. [1] https://vimeo.com/ondemand/whatthehealth/203617202 https://vimeo.com/ondemand/whatthehealth/203617202 [2] Vegetarians less likely to develop cancer than meat eaters, says study https://www.theguardian.com/science/2009/jul/01/vegetarians-blood-cancer-diet-risk https://www.theguardian.com/science/2009/jul/01/vegetarians-... [3] Vegans live longer than those who eat meat or eggs, research finds - Every three per cent increase in calories from plant protein was found to reduce risk of death by 10 per cent http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/health-news/vegan-meat-life-expectancy-eggs-dairy-research-a7168036.html http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/... [4] 16 Studies on Vegan Diets – Do They Really Work? https://authoritynutrition.com/vegan-diet-studies/ https://authoritynutrition.com/vegan-diet-studies/ [5] How Not To Die: The Role of Diet in Preventing, Arresting, and Reversing Our Top 15 Killers https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lXXXygDRyBU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lXXXygDRyBU
- krastanov 10y agoI do not necessarily disagree with your claims, but few people will take you seriously if your sources are a sensationalist newspaper and youtube. Even the nutritionist's blog in not particularly reliable, given how poor replication is in this discipline. Also, OP made a specific claim about controlling for health-conscious behavior that is not countered here.
- matt4077 10y agoThe Guardian article links to the paper, which has this in the introduction: Relative risks (RRs) were estimated by Cox regression, stratified by sex and recruitment protocol and adjusted for age, smoking, alcohol, body mass index, physical activity level and, for women only, parity and oral contraceptive use. I wouldn't disagree that there's still a lot of uncertainty, but at least for cancer, I'd bet on a small but significant effect. Anyway: what is pretty much proven is that living like a vegetarian is quite beneficial. You can probably even continue eating meat. (One possibly life-prolonging behaviour observed more in vegetarians: not considering the Guardian to be a 'sensationalist' newspaper)
- lprubin 10y agoHumans produce our own creatine if we eat enough of certain common amino acids that are found in plants. So it's not actually necessary to eat creatine.
- fredsir 10y agoYou can't ignore the health concerns with meat and only focus on the good stuff. Especially when health is the focus, and you can get all those things from plants without the health concerns. Less unhealthy does not mean something is healthy, and since meat is basically saturated fat, hormones, cholesterol, not to mention all the drugs fed to the animals that are recycled through it and shows up in the meat too. And about B12: that is recycled too. Livestock are fed B12 (and other stuff) which is why it's prevelant in meat as it is. If you worry about B12, it would seem to me that you worry about health, so getting B12 through meat where you also get all kinds of bad stuff sounds illogical instead of just taking a vitamin pill.
- paulddraper 10y ago> saturated fat American Heart Association made some recommendations like this in the 90s that caused everybody binge on carbs and weigh 300lbs. Recent studies (http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/early/2010/01/13/ajcn.2009.27725.abstract http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/early/2010/01/13/ajcn.2009... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9635993 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9635993 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19364995 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19364995) failed to find ill effects from saturated fats. (Trans fats are another story.) > hormones It's been years, and we're still waiting for any actual evidence on this one. If it concerns you, there is hormone-free meat, just there there are pesticide-free veggies. > cholesterol Scientific consensus is that eating cholesterol has zero effect on cholesterol levels, since the body regulates production of it anyway. > Livestock are fed B12 (and other stuff) which is why it's prevelant in meat as it is. True, though cows, sheep, goats, deer, etc. naturally produce B12 themselves (or more accurately, their bacteria do). > getting B12 through meat where you also get all kinds of bad stuff sounds illogical instead of just taking a vitamin pill. It seems a little bit of red flag if a diet is deficient enough that you need pills to compensate, but I have no opposition to them per se. I take multi-vitamins now and then. I didn't make a comprehensive list of meat's better-than-average nutrients (e.g. iron comes to mind). Can you get the same nutrients without meat? Yes, it's possible. On the other hand, there's a reason humans are omnivores, even if we like to pretend they're not.
- 10y ago
- asciimo 10y agoYou can get all those things from plants and supplements. As there are strong environmental arguments against raising meat, as well as strong ethical arguments against raising meat, "avoid meat" is sound advice.
- a_imho 10y agoTrying to paint some bleak health picture on all meats is plain FUD For one, the WHO beg to differ http://www.iarc.fr/en/media-centre/pr/2015/pdfs/pr240_E.pdf http://www.iarc.fr/en/media-centre/pr/2015/pdfs/pr240_E.pdf tldr Red meat is group 2a, probably carcinogenic to humans, processed meat is group 1, carcinogenic to humans.