3 ms·
>Spending a single moment entertaining it does nothing positive; there's literally no argument that can make that not reprehensible and not deserving of complet
by krapp 10y ago
>Spending a single moment entertaining it does nothing positive; there's literally no argument that can make that not reprehensible and not deserving of complete rejection. It does not and cannot exist. And so, no, it's not something to hear out, it's something to excise.
It can't be excised, though, only sent somewhere else, to gather power where you can no longer see it. Push it far enough into a dark corner and it looks tempting. People will say the "mainstream" is afraid of it, that the "system" is suppressing it, and cynics will find it all the more attractive for being forbidden fruit.
The reason such speech should be permitted in the public sphere is not to entertain it, but to give the community the opportunity to reject it.
- eropple 10y agoTo be clear, I'm not saying that the government should suppress reprehensible speech. But I am saying that elements of the public choosing to protest it and no-platform it should not be criticized by the (maybe-)well-meaning peanut gallery on "free speech" grounds 'cause we're exercising ours. The easy (wrong (dumb)) rhetorical answer trotted out around here becomes "oh, delicate snowflakes!" because of the inexplicable unwillingness to wait until one's head is put to the curb and the boot is raised before resisting.
- krapp 10y ago>But I am saying that elements of the public choosing to protest it and no-platform it should not be criticized by the (maybe-)well-meaning peanut gallery on "free speech" grounds 'cause we're exercising ours. I can't disagree with this, but it still doesn't win the fight. People can't reject a point of view until they're given the opportunity to understand it, and are exposed to the risk of accepting it first.