2 ms·
Very good point on the need for a repetitive study system to be always available. The bit about iPad being too small comes from asking something like "why aren
by nooneelse 16y ago
Very good point on the need for a repetitive study system to be always available.
The bit about iPad being too small comes from asking something like "why aren't textbooks the size of fictional paperbacks?" I suppose it could be just historical accident or the need for enough page mass that the book lays flat and open. But seems to me that the answer also includes something along the lines of different types of information being better shown at different sizes, with richer learning material needing more room. When the target users already carry a bag all the time, should portability of a textbook replacement be so overriding a concern that the area for showing and writing information is slashed by something like half (iPad screen to college notebook ratio) up front? Shouldn't form follow function a little more than that?
The really old college textbooks (1950's and earlier) I have are actually smaller than modern versions, with text areas comparable or smaller than an iPad screen. So perhaps the question can be reformulated as "why did textbooks get bigger over the past century?" Or maybe there is just a lot less reasoning behind their sizes than I'm presupposing.
- donw 16y agoMy guess has more to do with sales and marketing than anything else. I've got more than a few textbooks from the 50's and 60's on a variety of subjects, and for the most part, they are a joy to read, because they assume the reader is intelligent enough to not try and eat the chalkboard erasers. Big textbooks, with lots of diagrams, pictures, and colors, look impressive. They give the impression of a tome filled with knowledge and wisdom, whether or not they actually are. Which is why school districts and professors in charge of lower-division courses buy the damn things -- they get impressive-looking textbooks to wow the students and parents, and they don't have to think much about the choice. It's just good marketing.