8 ms·
Gene Regulatory Network resembles (stochastic) recurrent neural network and is sometimes modeled as such. Each cell has it's own GRN and then there is signaling
by nabla9 10y ago
Gene Regulatory Network resembles (stochastic) recurrent neural network and is sometimes modeled as such. Each cell has it's own GRN and then there is signaling between the cells.
Its understandably very hard problem to nudge network states back to the normal or to kill itself once it's gone haywire and causes other networks go haywire too. The "error state" cells are changing and those who survive the last nudge continue to reproduce.
If I understand Kozubek's argument correctly, cancer is ecologic, not systemic because of this evolution of cancer cell populations. If the cancer is ecologic problem, solving cancer means that it's not enough to figure out cell's state and fix it. You must figure out how the cancer cell ecology works and find a way to drive it into extinction without survivals. Just setting more mousetraps is not working solution if the mouse population is evolving hour by hour and branching.
- dwaltrip 10y agoThis doesn't mean the problem can't be solved by "logic". If true, then research groups that are operating within such misguided frameworks will need to update their understanding of how cancer works. I think a common trope is to point out some system that humans are currently unable to model in a robust or effective manner, and then throw up one's hands and declare "science and logic can't be used to solve this problem!" The current lack of an effective model for some system in no way implies that one will not eventually be found. To be fair, this article isn't quite doing that, and makes some very important points. I only bring this up as it is a misleading line of argument to watch out for that I run into from time to time, and a few lines in the article were slightly reminiscent of such reasoning. Ecology is a scientific endeavor, and perhaps it will prove to be a more powerful paradigm for looking at a cancer. I hope we can make the most of any tools at our disposal to significantly reduce the harm caused by cancer.
- nabla9 10y ago>This doesn't mean the problem can't be solved by "logic". That's not what the author was saying. It's useless to judge articles based on their title or headline because they are either selected by editor or there are multiple titles and A/B testing is used to find one that gets most clicks. It seems that most comments are just comments based on the headline.
- dwaltrip 10y agoMy comment was mainly a tangent off of yours. It seems I tend to do that... I should make an effort to make that more clear. I will say, however, that only responding to my first sentence is sort of like only discussing the headline :)