2 ms·
> There's a choice to be made, either Pluto, Eris, Haumea, Makemake and Ceres are all planets or none of them are. This is half true. We don't strictly need a
by runarberg 10y ago
> There's a choice to be made, either Pluto, Eris, Haumea, Makemake and Ceres are all planets or none of them are.
This is half true. We don't strictly need a clear definition of a natural phenomena. Just look at the trouble we are having defining life. In fact, it might prove to be impossible to derive a solid definition. Yet most of us agree that all animals are living organisms, but fire isn't.
In my view Pluto, Eris, Haumea, Makemake, etc. are all planets. Just because they fit my idea of what a planet is. I am less keen on grouping Ceres with them (but the reason is that I was raised knowing that it was an asteroid, so I am willing to reconsider). If voyager 1 stumbles upon an earth size spherical body in (say) 50 years, I will want to consider it a (rouge) planet, even though it is missing some criteria for the current definition. We can indeed call Pluto a planet and Ceres an asteroid. That is only consistent with how we treat most other categories of natural phenomena.