9 ms·
An Accident No One Talked About
- bitcharmer 10y agoFew years ago I witnessed a traffic accident in which a 16yo boy riding a motorcycle died. I was the first to get to him trying to assess his condition and help. Those were his last moments. There was a lot of blood and I was helpless. I did my best but witnessed him dying anyway. I was 32 years old. I never knew this boy. Nevertheless this was a life changing experience. I'll never forget this neither will I forget having face his poor parents who wanted to hear about their son's final moments from the man who was there. This experience will never stop haunting me. I can easily imagine how devastating it can be for someone who's lost their friend. Especially when you're a kid. If someone from your family experienced this, please don't go the "let's not bring this up" way. That doesn't help.
- codinghorror 10y agoMy heart goes out to you. That is a heavy thing to bear witness to. We don't get a lot of death intruding in our lives when we're young. But it starts to creep in as you get older and it is ... very unsettling.
- spydum 10y agoI find it interesting that for some people it is a truly humbling and transformative event, and others it's a debilitating one. Wish I had explanation for the difference though.
- 3131s 10y agoIt's a pretty common thing to witness unfortunately in poorer countries with bad road conditions and lots of motorbikes. I have seen firsthand a few terrible accidents in which multiple people died in horrific ways. I also saw a thief beaten to death pretty much right in front of me, which haunts me even more. I witnessed it from my balcony and by the time I got downstairs (with the intention of stopping it) it was too late. There was also a suicide in my neighborhood where a young boy jumped off his balcony from about 5 stories up. I was out exercising so fortunately I didn't see it, but when I got back my neighbors all told me and the next day I saw photos in a newspaper taken right near my apartment of a monk blessing the boy's body. My wife as a child also saw a foreign English teacher jump off a tall building. It can be really depressing living in an impoverished place.
- bootload 10y ago"I was the first to get to him trying to assess his condition and help. Those were his last moments. There was a lot of blood and I was helpless." Those first ten seconds are shocking. For me it was understanding ^control^, the lack of control and the fight to get it back. The situation you were presented @bitcharmer is binary and anything other than a win can be seen as failure. For me it took a long time to understand that whatever I did, I had no real ^control^. Understanding control, the complete lack of it, in extreme situations like the one you describe lets you move one step closer to understanding death. To understand what it is like in @bitcharmer shoes, read happened in a similar situation back in 2012 (non fatal) https://www.flickr.com/photos/bootload/7949327460 https://www.flickr.com/photos/bootload/7949327460 After this I'm one for one.
- cyberferret 10y agoThe linked story and yours are both harrowing. But it has spurred me to action. Many years ago, my younger sister, a police officer, was off duty and just driving her car into town when she saw a car plough into another in front of her. She jumped out of her car and raced over to the drivers door, where she saw that the driver had a gaping wound in his neck and was bleeding out. My sister hates the sight of blood, and faints when getting a needle, but to this day I don't know how she did what she did, which was to reach in and clamp her hand around his neck to try and stem the bleeding, while trying to talk to him. His wife was in the passenger seat, relatively uninjured but screaming hysterically at her husband's condition. My sister said that she looked into the guys eyes while she tried to talk to him and reassure him - she said the look he gave her was one of 'pleading sadness', and she watched while in less than a minute the life went out of him right there and then. She only ever told me the story once, and our family has one of those stupid 'don't talk about it' rules, which after reading this, I intend to break. She seems fine to this day and doesn't show any outward signs of it affecting her, but next time I get the chance, I will see if she wants to talk more about it.
- lomnakkus 10y agoBe sure to tell your sister that she's a hero.
- moron4hire 10y agoMost people who have been through such a thing would very much like to avoid having someone call then a hero.
- lomnakkus 10y agoNot having been through the experience, I'm not sure what you mean. Can you elaborate? FTR, my sentiment was really just about reminding people you care about that they are, in fact, appreciated. EDIT: ... and there's hardly enough vomit in the world, is there? I'm sorry, that sounded absurdly cheesy, but it actually does matter.
- M_Grey 10y agoI had a similar experience, and I'm a bit slow to process extreme emotions so in crisis I'm very calm. A few days later though, it hit me while I was in the shower and my guard was down; I started shaking and I didn't know why. I literally dropped the washcloth and realized that I was crying, then I realized why, and it all hit me. As you say, it's one of those things that never quite heals, it just... skins over a little. Sharing does seem to help.
- delerio 10y agoI'm the same way. I recently opened up to a friend of mine about a traumatic experience. They wondered why I seem so calm all the time, I'm the calmest person they know. It helped me alot just to talk to them about it, even though the situation was long gone, it haunted me for years. Yet I never showed any emotion over it on the outside, even though on the inside I was not right.
- M_Grey 10y agoI'm glad that you came to the same conclusion about talking helping, like you it was difficult before that. In my teens and early twenties a lot of people just assumed that I was weirdly calm. It's not easy for people like us to open up and say, "It hits me, it just takes time to process and it all happens inside of my head."
- SEJeff 10y agoThis experience is precisely why you should never ask a war veteran if they've killed someone. Many times they have, but more often than not they've had to watch someone they were close with die. Source: am a veteran
- dpeck 10y agoMaybe if we talked about the horrors of war more we'd have less of them in the future.
- mannykannot 10y agoI wish, but the fact that there was a WWII does not hold out much hope.
- dpatriarche 10y agoWW2 made Europeans and east Asians anti war -- the people in whose countries the wars were fought. It's only Americans and Canadians who view WW2 as the "good" war. Our countries got to play the hero role and beat the super villain, we were largely untouched (relative to what other countries suffered), and at the end there was years of economic prosperity. What's not to like?
- mannykannot 10y agoSorry if I did not make it clear - the much-discussed horrors of WWI did not stop WWII.
- mobiplayer 10y agoWWII was more like a second act of the same war really. Wounds were not closed.
- mannykannot 10y ago
- 13of40 10y agoSorry - nerd in me but: He could have either gone straight or swerved right. He couldn't have swerved left?
- rincebrain 10y agoIt was a long truck - a landscaping trailer hitched to its back. I would guess that sharp enough movements would not have done something constructive, so if the vehicle was already coming right around a curve, or going fast enough, they could have let off a little to go "straight" or continued to go "right", but going left would have done nothing reasonable. In the article, though, the driver phrases it as them being too close, and turning just meaning hitting one or the other, so perhaps they came out into the street and he was just going too fast.
- mackal 10y agoIt also said they were just fishing, so it's possible there wasn't really room to go the other direction without killing himself.
- kodfodrasz 10y agoThere was an investigation and court case about the accident, as the article mentions. If the driver would have been guilty, probably he would have been punished. I think some pretty unfortunate situation arose, maybe the children were also not careful enough, it doesn't really matter anymore. The driver had to make a decision in a split second. Probably he already instinctively did some action by the time he got to think about the situation, and the "decision" is a rationalization of a situation he was just as well victim of, where he also didn't have any control.
- jessaustin 10y agoIf the driver would have been guilty, probably he would have been punished. In USA, this assumption is usually wrong. Drivers who kill pedestrians are rarely punished, no matter what the circumstances. The only vehicular deaths that less often result in punishment are those of cyclists. Not coincidentally, we learn right at the beginning of TFA that the police report claimed the "boy was crossing the street on his bicycle" even though that was entirely a lie. This is a sort of code, written by a "normal" adult who empathizes with drivers and not with pedestrians, which other such "normal" adults can read and understand without having to think. Only extraordinary acts of driving cruelty, like killing a child in a suburban cul-de-sac or mowing down a parade, can break through the stupor of official carelessness and lead to consequences. When multiple automobiles are involved, LEOs and prosecutors can empathize with both parties, so justice isn't so uncommon.
- danso 10y agoI've never had a personal tragedy like the scope of the author's, but her essay hit me nonetheless in reminding me of all the times I've avoided "tricky" topics with friends and family, and how in retrospect, this avoidance contributed to relationships drifting apart over the years. I was both happy how the author's bravery led to an eventual reconciliation, and sad thinking about relationships that I didn't prioritize enough.
- bootload 10y ago“Could you just start at the beginning and tell me everything?” Nobody talks about death, especially violent death. This quote stands out the most. Do you want to know why people who have been there don't talk? It's the interruptions, the funny looks and having to answer stupid questions. So if you are in the company of someone and they talk about it, it's probably because they trust you. Let them talk it out to the end, interruption free. When I do talk, it's quietly to mates who were there and those who have been in similar situations. There is no great divide in understanding, no interruptions and plenty of trust.
- tajen 10y agoI wonder if it's the same talking to a psy as to a relative. It's much less grave, but years talking to various psychologists didn't damp by emotions about my first break-up, especially because they don't want to talk about the past, they only want to talk about the future.
- BrandoElFollito 10y agoIncidentally this article made me think about people who save other's life, sometimes at personal risk. I am not thinking about big hero - like actions (which are of course fantastic) but rather Joe passing by and somehow saving Bob's life. I had two cases like this in my life. In one of them I saw a car rolling over on a highway and stopped to see if the driver was fine (alive, actually). He was there, breathing, and there was petrol all over the place. I got him out before the car shared to burn (quite slowly, nothing like in movies). I did not even think once about my safety, I did not think about anything, actually. There was strictly nothing heroic in what I did because brain was not involved at all. I wonder if others have this as well - for me a hero is someone who realizes what he or she can loose and despite this take the risk to help someone. This was not my case at all and would not be either if my children were at stake, for instance.
- ElDji 10y agoThanks for this post. It was mind opening for me. I witnesses the death of my dad two years ago, and experienced overleming emotions since then and depression like symptoms. I choose to stick to "Won't never talk about what I saw", but this seems really not the good path.
- kwhitefoot 10y agoThat was hard to read. Must have been harder to write, and even harder to do. I hope I can make use of it.
- mcguire 10y agoI hope you don't have the opportunity.
- kwhitefoot 10y agoMe too! But what my clumsy choice of words was supposed to convey was a desire to be able to act as well if such circumstances ever arise.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoWell this thread did a good job at making all the people with an irrational hate for cars come out of the woodwork.
- nomadic_09 10y agoThat was real hard to read. I can kind of relate to how Alex felt.
- markc 10y agoI have a horrific road accident from 10 years ago seared into my memory. Shared it on this reddit thread along with 100's of other stories of witness to trauma: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/9jsz6/tonight_i_gave_cpr_to_a_dead_girl_it_was_pretty/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/9jsz6/tonight_i_...
- dead10ck 10y agoAm I the only one who was extremely confused by the writing? I think the whole effect was just lost on me, because I went from thinking her brother was the one who died, to thinking he was the driver, to finally getting to the part where she actually says explicitly that he was the other boy in the road.
- longtimegone 10y agoMany many years ago, when I was one and a half years old, I had a brother who was three. He had red hair and a bright smile (I've seen the pictures) and a curious nature. Inexplicably, he slipped from everyone's sight one day and fell into the river and drowned. The resulting silent implosion in my family led to generations of pain and guilt and alcoholism and silence. Each parent, each sibling, suffering in guilty silence, and locking away their emotional selves from those that need it. The silence solves nothing folks, take it from me, it solves nothing.