3 ms·
Make code reviews your number one priority. Be the place that people want to put their code in, because they can review code, significantly easier on your site,
by uiri 10y ago
Make code reviews your number one priority. Be the place that people want to put their code in, because they can review code, significantly easier on your site, as opposed to GitHub's.
This isn't really a high bar. Doing more than one iteration of code review with GitHub's tooling is a complete mess. In addition to that, both PR comments and Commit comments exist which can be extremely confusing if you do make one when you meant to make the other.
There is already other tooling which leverage GitHub's APIs to provide a nicer interface for code review.
- yoz-y 10y agoCare to share which one?
- amatix 10y agohttps://reviewable.io https://reviewable.io is a good upgrade from regular GitHub reviews
- uiri 10y agoReviewable.io is the one which I was thinking of. GitHub provides a list: https://github.com/integrations/feature/code-review https://github.com/integrations/feature/code-review I don't think that that is an exhaustive list; for instance GerritHub is missing (although I'm not a fan of it).
- jacekmaterna 10y agoY. Has anyone actually tried running a complex enterprise pipeline via github. What you will find is the almost exclusively everyone ties github to a "project platform" like JIRA, Assembla, Pivotal, etc. Github is a repo hosting tool with just enough to support collaboration. Shipping, testing prod code 100% in github is very rare. I do think the comments and PR similarity is a challenge yeah - where to comment?