4 ms·
Ok, so I made my comments not about the UK in particular, but at the level of reports from IEA or EIA or Lazard's. At the napkin math level, ignoring baseload (
by epistasis 10y ago
Ok, so I made my comments not about the UK in particular, but at the level of reports from IEA or EIA or Lazard's. At the napkin math level, ignoring baseload (which is nuclear) or dispatchability (which is not really nuclear), PV solar blows away nuclear. But then, so does nearly every energy source. Nobody builds a nuclear plant because its profitable or cost effective.
We need to watch for when solar and wind beat natural gas for electricity generation costs. (And then we need to start watching for power to gas costs....)
- Safety1stClyde 10y ago> Nobody builds a nuclear plant because its profitable or cost effective. This just isn't true. Solar and wind power have failed disastrously in Germany, to the extent that they have to now cut back on wind power and start building coal fired plants, because they were stupid enough to turn off their nuclear facilities.
- epistasis 10y agoWhile I take your point on Germany, it is also true that modern construction of nuclear plants is disastrous financially.
- yungchin 10y agoIf we're to believe https://www.technologyreview.com/s/601514/germany-runs-up-against-the-limits-of-renewables/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/601514/germany-runs-up-ag... then the Germans didn't quite "have to [...] start building coal fired plants", but they have trouble stopping people from building more coal fired plants, because that is still economically lucrative.
- Safety1stClyde 10y agoNo. They have to have fossil plants because electricity cannot be stored effectively, except in very mountainous countries with enough hydroelectric dams, like Norway or Costa Rica. Since electricity cannot be stored, it has to be manufactured when required. People require electricity at night or on calm days when the wind is not blowing, and they often don't require as much electricity as can be produced at the right time. Since the Germans turned off their nuclear plants, to make that electricity, they had to build more fossil plants.
- kwhitefoot 10y agoSo sell the solar generated energy to Norway via the existing DC link and upgrade the link as necessary. Also upgrade the east-west electricity distribution system and sell the energy to neighbours who are in the dark. And lastly, if electric cars are implemented properly they can be used for peak shedding. See, for instance, https://www.techcentral.co.za/how-electric-cars-could-change-everything/71898/ https://www.techcentral.co.za/how-electric-cars-could-change..., https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2015/07/bmws-plan-to-prevent-electric-cars-from-overwhelming-the-grid/399821/ https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2015/07/bmws-plan-to-..., and https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/mar/20/electric-cars-uk-power-grids-charging-peaks-sse-demand-side-response https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/mar/20/electric.... > Since electricity cannot be stored, That should be 'Since electricity cannot currently be cost effectively stored," It is a matter of economics not natural law.
- Safety1stClyde 10y ago> 'Since electricity cannot currently be cost effectively stored," It is a matter of economics not natural law. What I meant should be obvious to someone who read my entire reply. Selectively quoting part of it and then making a counter-claim using the quote as a strawman argument shows that you are not a person to be taken seriously.
- wbl 10y agoNuclear all-in costs (about 10-20 cents per kwh) are lower then most sources, and the operating costs beat everything but wind. Big problem is cost overruns.
- paulryanrogers 10y agoAre there sources for this which include externalities like mining and producing the fuel?
- someguydave 10y agoOkay well on page 164 (https://www.withouthotair.com/c24/page_164.shtml https://www.withouthotair.com/c24/page_164.shtml) MacKay writes: "If fast reactors are 60 times more efficient, the same extraction of ocean uranium could deliver 420 kWh per day per person." Granted, this depends on fast breeder reactors and ocean extraction of uranium, but those are both experimentally proven technologies. Why wouldn't we adopt the only energy source that has been shown to scale to provide the entire world with Western levels of energy for 1,000 years?
- toomuchtodo 10y agoNuclear plants go up in decades, solar and wind generators go up in months.