10 ms·
I actually consider this a Bad Thing. Monosystems are not a desirable thing, and nobody (except GitHub) wants a world where all open source projects are hosted
by mindcrime 10y ago
I actually consider this a Bad Thing. Monosystems are not a desirable thing, and nobody (except GitHub) wants a world where all open source projects are hosted on GitHub. Now, Git itself being a DVCS mitigates the downsides of this a little bit, but still... I think it's better to live in a world where you can use GitHub, Bitbucket, CodePlex, GitLab, SourceForge, etc., instead of narrowing things down to pretty much just GitHub.
Nothing against GH per-se... we're paying customers and fairly happy with their service. But I still don't want to see their competition going away.
- gjtorikian 10y agoI don't disagree with you at all. The competition between GitHub, GitLab, and BitBucket spurs creativity and is a good thing. However, let's not fool ourselves: services like Codeplex, Google Code, or Sourceforge, that are not updated or providing new value, are going to be left behind and abandoned. In other words, their continued service wasn't providing any value, to their users or "competitors", because they weren't evolving. I would rather people put their open source project on a code hosting service that is someone's priority, not just one that exists and is useless.
- edgyswingset 10y agoThis is key, I think. Codeplex feels like abandonware to me. All the important Microsoft projects have migrated to GitHub, where all the active development is happening. Perhaps this also screws over some people who wish to stay on Codeplex, but I can imagine it was just a cost to Microsoft. No use in having something which only costs you money lingering around.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jlarocco 10y agoAgreed. CodePlex and to a lesser extent Google Code both felt less like competing products and more like MS and Google just wanted to have a code hosting presence to advertise that they "do" open source. Neither offered much that couldn't be provided with barebones cheap hosting and a Gitlab install, and my impression as an outsider was thatneither really improved over time. TBH, GitHub and BitBucket may not offer too much over GitLab any more either, but they are at least improving their products all the time and there's a sort of trendy network effect in using them that didn't exist for CodePlex or Google Code.
- andybak 10y agoI'd point out Google Code predated Github and for a while was the cool kid in town. They were late in supporting Git and slow to improve the feature set. Another lead Google threw away.
- manigandham 10y agoGithub is barely at $200M in revenue and requires a lot of moving pieces to make that happen - something that just doesnt make sense for the scale of Google. It's not really a great business opportunity. However, Google Cloud Platform does have private repositories that can also be used in their CI/CD solution. https://cloud.google.com/source-repositories/docs/ https://cloud.google.com/source-repositories/docs/
- andybak 10y agoFair point. Sometimes Google abandons something not because of institutional dysfuntionality - but simply because they are aiming much much bigger. Shame if you happen to live in the path of the juggernaut however...
- sqeaky 10y agoThat is a small revenue considering the impact they have on the world. I wonder how they might better monetize without becoming obnoxious?
- rorosaurus 10y agoTo expand on your point, this CodePlex post mentions there were 350 projects with commits in the last 30 days. I'd venture to guess that number was much larger for GitHub. The people have voted on which service provides the most value.
- 0x6c6f6c 10y agoMight actually look into doing a quick script and checking this out.. It'd be interesting to look at. Plus I may only be able to scrape public projects, where private repositories may account for some large amount of the real number since those are typically paid for (except for Student accounts, afaik).
- gjtorikian 10y agoNo need to script! You can use Google's BigQuery with GitHub's data. Some documentation is here: https://www.githubarchive.org/ https://www.githubarchive.org/ A `PushEvent` is fired for every open source repository that has `master` updated: ``` SELECT COUNT(*) FROM ( TABLE_DATE_RANGE([githubarchive:day.], TIMESTAMP('2017-03-01'), TIMESTAMP('2017-03-31') )) WHERE type = 'PushEvent' ``` It's over 19 million!
- zokier 10y agoDon't you need something like GROUP BY repo.id in there too?
- xfalcox 10y agoYes. By running: SELECT COUNT(DISTINCT repo.id) FROM [githubarchive:month.201701] WHERE type = 'PushEvent' I got 1896676, so almost 2M distinct repos with commits in last January.
- lucaspiller 10y agoJust a heads up that 'last January' would generally refer to January of the previous year, not the current year. http://english.stackexchange.com/a/43000 http://english.stackexchange.com/a/43000
- rwmj 10y agoI quite liked the simplicity of Google Code.
- user5994461 10y agoGoogle code was perfectly fine. Quick, simple, easy to use and reusing your google account. Also, it supported many code source systems, not just git. GitHub only added SVN support recently.
- simonw 10y agoOnly if by "recently" you mean "seven years ago today" https://github.com/blog/626-announcing-svn-support https://github.com/blog/626-announcing-svn-support
- camus2 10y ago> I actually consider this a Bad Thing This.Competition is good. The less competition, the less insentive Github will have to improve their product. But Microsoft didn't put a lot of effort into making CodePlex user friendly either (just like google code back then). What makes Github great is that it is fairly easy to get started with, fairly easy to use and to navigate.
- SwellJoe 10y agoI agree wholeheartedly, but I think there's a healthy competition going on, for now. I just setup automatic replication of all of our repositories from Github to Gitlab (gitlab makes this super easy, I did dozens of repos in one leisurely evening while watching TV...probably could have scripted it, but learning the API would have likely taken longer), for the potential risk that Github may one day pull a SourceForge (though, SF.net turned evil for a while because they couldn't figure out how to ring the cash register without being evil...I think Github is already making money without being evil). I only ever looked briefly at CodePlex (I'm not involved in any MS developer communities, so it wasn't really my scene), but it didn't seem competitive with Github in terms of how much you can do with very low friction. Likewise, I don't miss Google Code. It just wasn't good enough for me to want to use it...even Googlers didn't want to use it, and used Github more often. And, there's some high quality open source options, as well, for self-hosted. I've tinkered with Gogs, and it's really very solid (if light on features compared to Github or Gitlab). And, of course, Gitlab has a very competent OSS offering. Things seem pretty good right now. Not a lot of risk of ending up locked into one vendor that goes rogue. I mean, I worry about some projects really going all-in on github, like their dependencies and such are based on github URLS (that seems crazy on numerous fronts!). But, there are escape routes to many good competitors in the space.
- Nexxxeh 10y agoSourceForge are still going, they were bought up (along with Slashdot) by BizX last year. SF President, Logan Abbot, does a fair bit of outreach on Reddit.[1] They do seem to actually care about the two properties. Supposedly there's a big redesign of SF in the pipeline, and more importantly, the first thing they did when they took over was cancel that malware hijack monetization bullshit which the previous owners had embarked upon. They scan for malware now too apparently, added 2FA and are offering HTTPS downloads. Regaining trust is an uphill battle, but they're giving it a damn good go. Searching HN to see if he'd done similar to his AMA-type thing on /r/sysadmin[2], it's sad to see their blogposts have been posted and got no love. I didn't even know SF had a blog, and it seems to have some cool content. (He didn't do an AMA-style post here, probably wise, but the Reddit post was submitted here and he showed up in the comments [3]). [1] https://www.reddit.com/user/loganabbott https://www.reddit.com/user/loganabbott [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/4n3e1s/the_state_of_sourceforge_since_its_acquisition_in/ https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/4n3e1s/the_state_... [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11860752 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11860752
- josh64 10y agoSourceForge still provide the best project web hosting service that I know of. They recently enabled https on project sites too. It will be interesting to see what their big redesign is.
- anon12345690 10y agoLogan and his dad Roger Abbott are behind Wirefly along with Bizx and lots of other shady companies with plenty of criminal history. > ...Mr. Abbott, has a track record of entrepreneurial flair and illegal hustle. He spent three years in prison after conviction on cocaine trafficking in 1983. After his release, he set up a telemarketing company that attracted regulatory scrutiny for its tactics in selling precious metals investments. In 1991, Mr. Abbott founded Communications Telesystems, which became known for slamming, the practice of switching customers from one long-distance service to another without their permission. After tens of thousands of complaints, the California Public Utilities Commission revoked the company's permission to operate most services in the state. 1. http://www.nytimes.com/2002/03/27/business/technology-a-suit-says-worldcom-deals-obscured-millions-in-bad-debt.html http://www.nytimes.com/2002/03/27/business/technology-a-suit... 2. http://articles.latimes.com/1997-05-21/business/fi-60971_1_state-regulators http://articles.latimes.com/1997-05-21/business/fi-60971_1_s... 3. http://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/162/635.html http://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/16... 4. http://www.droid-life.com/2014/03/13/wirefly-abruptly-closes-up-shop-shady-penny-phone-deals-and-all/ http://www.droid-life.com/2014/03/13/wirefly-abruptly-closes...
- ksec 10y agoNot only GitHub, but Git being "the" DVCS, I would have wanted to Mercurial to give some more competition.
- mdpopescu 10y agoPersonally I loved Bazaar before I "had to" switch to Git.
- Jdam 10y agoTrue, but would you put your project on Sourceforge or Codeplex nowadays??
- thiht 10y agoI don't think it's a bad thing. As you say, there are alternatives to Github: Gitlab and Bitbucket being the most well known. If Gitlab and/or Bitbucket were to shut down I would consider it a bad thing because it would give Github a monopoly. Codeplex shutting down doesn't, because it was not particularly used (350 active project on the last month as they say).