11 ms·
The term got terribly misappropriated like that, which was probably unavoidable. But no, stop it. There is always going to be potential bias in reporting focu
by ajross 10y ago
The term got terribly misappropriated like that, which was probably unavoidable. But no, stop it. There is always going to be potential bias in reporting focus, there will always be arguments to be had over journalism. But junk like Pizzagate is just plain wrong, full stop. It's fake. Everyone should agree that it's fake.
And yet in the social media world (Facebook was the big offender) links like this are just treated as "news" and presented to their users alongside other stuff. There is a gatekeeper role for these companies that used to be provided by the traditional media. And Facebook wasn't even trying. So we got Pizzagate.
- aqsheehy 10y agoIs the problem not then that they should have represented it as "things people are interested in right now" and not as news?
- olivermarks 10y agoThe term 'fake news' took off at exactly the same time as 'pizzagate'. https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?q=fake%20news,pizzagate https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?q=fake%20news,pizza... The rumors and allegations against the Podesta brothers, the various associated instagram accounts and all the other information you can find in various youtube exposés (example: https://youtu.be/beqdw19Uj6E https://youtu.be/beqdw19Uj6E) were quickly trashed and ridiculed. Ben Swann's career got destroyed. The concept of 'news', as torturously discussed in the Danah Boyd piece, is entirely dependent on what information is allowed to be discussed and in what context. Most news outlets are extremely biased for political and advertising demographic reasons. The internet has been a wonderful medium for allowing people to discover and explore, and the only 'fake news' I see is created by Outbrain, Taboola and other click bait insurgents into the news media.
- Sunset 10y ago>Pizzagate is just plain wrong Is it? Have you seen the "art" "photos" hanging around on the walls in that pizzeria? The owner is definitely some kind of messed up.
- rmc 10y agoAnd Facebook would track "viral", "engaging" content and promote it more to your friends. So a link to a website that looks like a newspaper with the headline "Hillary Clinton is running a child sex ring" would be "liked" and shared lots and FB would promote it to many people.
- mythrwy 10y agoThe "conclusion" of Pizzagate was almost certainly fake yes, but there were actual events/personalities that did occur which were real. Enough so that some people at least could be led to the conclusion. Which is (in a less dramatic way) pretty much how standard media operates when they want to promote a position. Point being, effective fake news isn't all fake. It's 90%+ real making the critical 10% palatable.
- ajross 10y agoUm... what were the actual events in Pizzagate? It was all about interpreting "codes" in Podesta emails. There was literally no allegation anywhere of an actual concrete event; certainly nothing close to "90% real". Are you being serious?
- mythrwy 10y agoApparently you didn't read the sources of Pizzagate if you think it was all about the Podesta emails. That was only a small part of it. I'm not really interested in arguing about details nor starting any kind of flame war and I certainly don't believe in an international pedophilia Democrat child sex ring run out of a Pizza joint. You can look into if you care to. But suffice it to say, there were real people and events that provided enough for the narrative to be built on. Well beyond the Podesta emails. <edit>The other reason I'm not interested in discussing details is because I don't believe in the existence of a pedophilia Democrat sex ring and the details I'm talking about were largely innocent behaviors in my opinion and thus aren't worth trotting out in public where more people can go "humm... maybe there was something going on". Like I say, you can look into more if curious. But there was more going on than the mainstream news "fake news" accounts portrayed. Enough to build the narrative on.
- michaelbuddy 10y agoI saw the Pizza gate content rise up from seemingly out of nowhere. Thing is though, the core of it, without making any specific accusations is there is really weird stuff going on in those emails from wikileaks dump. Strange coded language when they are talking about kids and pizza. And that pizza restaurant had some really strange things posted on their social media too. (Strange enough that they would later delete it.) After looking long enough at it, basically PizzaGate warrants just as much suspicion for me as any JFK theory at this point. I believe there's something to it. There is a mountain of little details that make it impossible to flat out deny it, I just don't go as far as levying accusations at people withouth knowing facts. Others have accused people w/o evidence beyond a reasonable doubt and I think that's wrong. I think the police should be interested in Pizza Gate, and I think a few of them are. But again I don't go further than that. What people think bubbled over Pizza Gate was that guy with the gun who went in the restaurant. But actually that smelled like a hoax to me. It just seemed wildly incomplete and a convenient way to say "See what fake news does!" And that guy had a strange background with him, and the media chose NOT to go too deep into his story either. It was like they just needed that for their narative.
- olivermarks 10y agoIt's interesting that the concept of'fake news' rose up out of seemingly nowhere at the same time...
- krapp 10y agoThe concept didn't, only the term, and the subsequent retroactive continuity applied to it.
- olivermarks 10y agoIf you were paranoid, you might think that the 'fake news' push served two objectives: 1. As a psyops to stop the potentially very damaging allegations against powerful senior Washington DC political operatives on the eve of an important election. 2. To repair the damage to the mainstream press, who were steadily losing paid readership. Both of these objectives have been successfully achieved however you perceive it. Meanwhile the mainstream press is flooded with click bait advertising while at the same time pushing 'we are the only credible, trusted news source' messaging to readers, along with begging requests for funding so they can continue with their work. The reality is that investigative 'reporters' were either let go or resigned in disgust from the MSM around the time blogging became a viable means of disseminating writing and making money. We are now in an era of crack downs on free speech and debate: it will be interesting to se whether the mainstream mastheads can regain their 'trusted voice' relationship with large numbers of readers, or whether there will be an increase in cynicism and mistrust. Pravda, the old Soviet newspaper/mouthpiece comes to mind. An example of that https://larussophobe.wordpress.com/2006/06/22/there-is-truth-in-pravda-if-you-read-between-the-lines/ https://larussophobe.wordpress.com/2006/06/22/there-is-truth...