4 ms·
To be a bat, or a woman, or man, means to be an agent that exists as part of an environment, learning to select the best actions that maximize rewards. Of cour
by visarga 10y ago
To be a bat, or a woman, or man, means to be an agent that exists as part of an environment, learning to select the best actions that maximize rewards.
Of course for a bat the list of possible sensations, actions and rewards is different than for men or women. But what doesn't change is that they are all agents acting by reinforcement learning, trying to survive.
I'm wondering why philosophy doesn't take this stance. Is it because it sounds too similar to behaviorism? Does it seem reductionist? Instead of using the parsimonious concept of reinforcement learning agent, they use hard to define words such as consciousness and self. Instead of looking at what matters - reward maximization, survival - they analyze qualia and Chinese Rooms.
Philosophers, why are you ignoring recent AI research? Isn't it a waste of time to use such intuitive concepts as consciousness, free will and self? If only you could have come to a definition of consciousness you agree upon, but you can't, because it's a reification, a suitcase concept.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoLots of cognitive science literature models human beings as reinforcement learners, with plenty of good evidence for the hypothesis. The interesting question is: what kind of reinforcement learning?