2 ms·
My counter would be: what are the reasons to fight against automobile oriented infrastructure and urban sprawl? If it's pollution, the move towards electric ve
by mikeash 10y ago
My counter would be: what are the reasons to fight against automobile oriented infrastructure and urban sprawl?
If it's pollution, the move towards electric vehicles and clean energy will hopefully put that to rest before too long.
If it's cost or fairness, if autonomous cars really do enable lots of ride sharing services, that should come way down.
If it's accessibility, all those people who can't drive will be able to use autonomous cars.
I'm sympathetic to the desire for walkable areas. I love a good walkable area myself. But cars are great too. People want them, because they want the things they enable. Even countries that are big on walking and biking and public transport still have a ton of cars.
A future with sprawling cities where people have lots of space, things are far apart, and people get around in cheap, efficient autonomous cars sounds pretty good to me.
- stouset 10y agoRegarding pollution, Jevon's paradox comes to mind. Electric cars still pollute — just less. But the increased efficiency and decreased cost will drive up use: more people will be willing to live further away from jobs, more people take long car trips knowing they don't need to be awake behind the wheel the whole way, and more people (the young and elderly) will be able to use cars. Is it totally unrealistic to expect that the net of these two advancements is an increase, or at least not a decrease, in carbon emissions? This is a genuine question — I haven't done the math. I'm also conveniently ignoring the inevitable existence of automated gasoline-powered cars, which I'm not convinced will be an insignificant fraction of the market. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- mikeash 10y agoEVs still pollute, for now. How long will that remain true? One way or another, we need to greatly reduce emissions from electrical generation. EVs should help a lot with this, both by being a relatively flexible load and by helping to push energy storage technology. It seems like it comes down to this: if we can get transportation cleaned up, then having more of it is good. If we can't, we're screwed regardless. Either way, autonomy doesn't change the larger outcome much.
- Tiktaalik 10y ago> My counter would be: what are the reasons to fight against automobile oriented infrastructure and urban sprawl? Well for one thing there was a study that found that divorce rates spike 40% when commutes exceed 45 minutes! There’s a wealth of data out there that indicates that compact communities are better for people’s health, well-being, and they’re cheaper on municipalities too. I don’t really know how to answer because questioning whether sprawl is bad is a bit akin to asking a climate scientist if CO2 emissions are bad. There’s a broad consensus amongst urban planners on the overwhelming benefits in all sorts of categories of compact communities. I haven’t seen anyone promoting suburban sprawl as a superior alternative. You’re right that autonomous vehicles could mitigate some of the downsides of sprawl. For example many communities are “car captive” in that they have no amenities and to escape this amenity desert and do any errand a car is required. This obviously becomes a big problem when one becomes elderly and is no longer legally able to drive. Autonomous cars are a solution to this problem. Another solution however, is to design communities such that common errands can all be easily accomplished within a 20 minute walk. This solution has the added benefit of allowing people to be active, which improves health and mobility as one ages. One negative point about sprawl I will specifically point out is that it’s simply a waste of land. In certain areas this may not matter so much, but in some places the land has real value beyond urban uses. Vancouver for example is surrounded by an agricultural land reserve. The area of prime agricultural land produces 7% of North America’s cranberry crop. Real estate is incredibly expensive in Vancouver and I’m sure there are a lot of real estate developers that would love to pave over that land and build more suburbs. If this occurred however that export crop would be lost forever and there would be a real reduction in the economic potential of the region.
- mikeash 10y agoA climate scientist should be able to pretty simply explain why CO2 emissions are bad. They trap heat, which warms the planet. Unlike climate science, urban planning doesn't get much attention, so you'll have to forgive me for being ignorant of things which experts consider obvious. For your divorce rate statistic, is that for any commute over 45 minutes, or is it specifically for car commutes? Because lots of dense cities with good public transportation still have long commutes. This is why I asked what the reasons were. If they're things that don't apply to an autonomous car future, then we should welcome them. If they still apply, then autonomous cars won't solve the problem. When I see people complaining about sprawl, it's usually because of things that will go away in an autonomous car future. But that's not necessarily a comprehensive listing of the problems.