4 ms·
Why would high performing employees with office jobs be "lower class"? As others mentioned once you hit a certain income threshold and job security, then you ca
by dmix 10y ago
Why would high performing employees with office jobs be "lower class"? As others mentioned once you hit a certain income threshold and job security, then you can start prioritizing the parts of the job you enjoy. This is who the article is talking about.
This means keeping a $60k job instead of sacrificing your happiness for $90-100k.
That's hardly quasi-religious phenomena. It's a luxury of skilled people living in a western society.
If anything it's the result of the push back against capitalism, such as the type of comment you just made. We're all told since we're kids to do what we love. And to since the late 1980s this anti-consumerism Fight Club-style mantra has been pushed hard to the point it's basically mainstream now, which is why marketing is so hard these days, even kids see through ads and demand authenticity.
The primary issue of inequality is largely the result of the fact that ~90% of recent job growth since the 2008 recession has been temporary/contract jobs, with little job security. These aren't the type of people who are valuing 'mastery' over money'. Middle class job growth is largely dead. And big incumbents dominate markets and global economic systems push wealth to a few. Entrepreneurship has also declined recently. There's plenty of reasons.
I don't suspect it's some cultural, original sin, type of thing that we should all feel guilty about.
- alphonsegaston 10y ago>Why would high performing employees with office jobs be "lower class"? As others mentioned once you hit a certain income threshold and job security, then you can start prioritizing the parts of the job you enjoy. This is who the article is talking about. Because they're foolish enough to believe that themselves in solidarity with the oligarch class, when really they're only temporarily useful to them. If you think "high-performers" are part of the elite or are going to escape from this neo-feudalism unscathed, well, enjoy this sermon.
- gozur88 10y ago>Because they're foolish enough to believe that themselves in solidarity with the oligarch class, when really they're only temporarily useful to them. Not everyone takes the Marxist view of society in which we're perpetually locked in a class struggle, with enemy classes and those with which we're "in solidarity".
- psyc 10y agoI don't think it makes any sense to call that a 'view' - other than the trite philosophical sense in which everybody's worldview is their own. Not sure what part of Marx's analysis of class struggle would actually depend on personal opinion in any meaningful way.
- gozur88 10y agoBecause it doesn't reflect reality? Do you really feel like you're "struggling" with other classes?
- psyc 10y agoAbsolutely. Every single day of my 40 years (no doubt this experience is strongly connected to having been raised in poverty). Not confrontationally, face-to-face, or with violence. That's the whole point.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoIf your argument is that the world doesn't conform to any kind of Hegelianism, Marxist or otherwise, I guess I'd agree with you. But if it's that there are no such thing as classes of rich and poor people, or that the former has not persecuted and exploited the latter for its own gains, now and in the past, that seems to fundamentally misunderstand history and human behavior.
- rublev 10y ago>Because it doesn't reflect reality? Do you really feel like you're "struggling" with other classes? Do you feel okay in the head?
- gozur88 10y agoAbsolutely. I don't carry the same burden of paranoia that other people seem to have. You?
- astrange 10y ago
- JDiculous 10y agoThey're not lower class, but not truly upper class either because they have to work for a living.
- OJFord 10y ago> They're not lower class, but not truly upper class either Yes, if only there were a word for someone in the middle.
- jly 10y ago> The primary issue of inequality is largely the result of the fact that...global economic systems push wealth to a few. I shortened your statement to draw the conclusion faster. Global economic systems in this case are neoliberal free markets combined with capitalism. This isn't some inevitable "only way it can be done" thing, it's a political choice we have collectively made and allow to continue.