5 ms·
Fluid dynamics is local, and so are the dynamics of human-driven car traffic to a first approximation. Computer-driven cars can react non-locally by communicati
by Sharlin 10y ago
Fluid dynamics is local, and so are the dynamics of human-driven car traffic to a first approximation. Computer-driven cars can react non-locally by communicating with each other via radio even if they don't see each other.
- andrewflnr 10y agoAt the very least, waves could be damped by a vehicle that sees it coming from a long way away. But if everyone knows the average speed of the roadway, and doesn't suffer from the moronic impulse to push up against the car in front of them, waves will form less often, if at all.
- saosebastiao 10y ago> and doesn't suffer from the moronic impulse to push up against the car in front of them But see that's the problem. In this piece, we see direct advocacy of that exact moronic impulse under the misguided assumption that computers can will away the laws of physics.
- saosebastiao 10y agoLet's say you've got 50 miles of freeway where it is completely full of cars driving 80mph two feet apart. A dog runs into the road. Locally, the traffic jam is inevitable and bad. But they transmit this condition via radio such that cars downstream can start braking early. What happens when one car doesn't get the message on time? The car in front of it brakes, and this car brakes much harder in reaction to visual cues in lieu of the radio cues, forcing the car behind it to react to visual cues and so on, causing another shock wave. Don't even get me started on the idea that we can rely on wireless communication in order to make reaction times fast enough that we can drive closer than we can adequately stop. Even locally that level of reliability is decades beyond current capabilities...non visible distances are a non-starter.
- cr0sh 10y agoThere seems to be a confusion among people that self-driving cars are going to fully self-contained, with no interaction or communication between them. At first they probably will - but the greater gains in safety, efficiency, speed, and utility will only happen when they all can communicate with each other - to inform each other about traffic pattern changes, as well as to coordinate on local issues.
- saosebastiao 10y agoThere's no confusion here. It will be possible, but relying on it to stop traffic waves is an untenable fantasy. Even directly connected fiber optic communication has levels of unreliability that would make it untenable to drive closer than you can stop from visual sensory alone...and you want to rely on wireless communication? At it's best, wireless communication may help traffic miles from an incident, by communicating problems (most likely with some central management system) and routing traffic around it. Visual range sensors will dominate all local interactions, just like they do with swarm coordination systems in both nature and robotics.
- marssaxman 10y agoSure, but now we've gone from a discussion of changes we could reasonably expect to see over a couple of decades to much more ambitious structural systematic changes which would take most of a century to accomplish.