61 ms·
> a car is capable of stopping in a shorter distance Stopping distance has more to do with speed than weight, since reducing weight also reduces the frictional
by falcolas 10y ago
> a car is capable of stopping in a shorter distance
Stopping distance has more to do with speed than weight, since reducing weight also reduces the frictional force against the road at equal proportions to the reduction of potential energy, whereas the impact of velocity on the energy to be dissipated is squared.
Brakes also wear down, steering linkages break, lugnuts are improperly torqued, tires blow out, debris can impact sensors or power packs, roads can be compromised by loose sand or potholes, lightning can strike the vehicle... failure modes are plentiful.
You also still need to account for bugs and sensor failures; both of which will result in crashes in "non optimal" ways. As an example, I had a gyro fail in my multirotor; it was a gradual failure which was not immediately obvious (and completely invisible to the controller), and resulted in a couple of pretty spectacular crash that the multirotor (even with human inputs) had no way to recover from.
Sure, you can add redundant systems (ideally in batches of three), but at some point there will always be a single point of failure.
- nostoc 10y agoStopping distance has mostly to do with two things : reaction time and weight. I expect an autonomous car to have a far better reaction time than a human.
- falcolas 10y agoReaction time, I can kind of get. But weight, especially when compared to velocity and the coefficient of friction - i.e. the road conditions - has negligible impact. Sure, it increases your traction when stopping, but it also increases the amount of energy which has to be dissipated by the vehicle to stop. Something that has a much greater impact than either would be the road conditions. Wet, dry, icy, sandy, gravel, oily... all have much more impact than either weight or reaction speed. Have a look at this review: http://www.caranddriver.com/features/the-power-to-stop http://www.caranddriver.com/features/the-power-to-stop The quality of the brakes had a much greater impact than the weight of the compared vehicles (a SUV had a stopping range of 355 ft, whereas a coupe had a stopping distance of 365).
- adrianN 10y agoFriction is not as linear as high school physics teaches: https://www.wired.com/2014/09/friction-isnt-always-think/ https://www.wired.com/2014/09/friction-isnt-always-think/
- falcolas 10y agoI can't read that article (it thinks I have an ad blocker). Can you summarize the better model they have in mind?