2 ms·
> SpaceX has to supply an awful lot of equipment, and they have to do an awful lot of refurbishment. Right, they've already stated that with the current rocket
by simonh 10y ago
> SpaceX has to supply an awful lot of equipment, and they have to do an awful lot of refurbishment.
Right, they've already stated that with the current rocket there's no economical way to recover the second stage, which aren't cheap, and so far nobody knows how many launches the cores will be good for. Also the infrastructure for supporting the recovery efforts, including the drone ships and their operations, can't be cheap. I expect the SpaceX re-use project will probably be in the red economically for years before it starts paying off it's setup costs.
- mikeash 10y agoThe second stage is about a quarter of the total cost of the rocket, so the best case, if reusing the first stage cost nothing, is a 75% cost savings. I don't think refurbishment is going to cost all that much. They fired their "max damage" core eight times without any refurbishment and it did alright. The upcoming Block 5 version of the rocket is supposed to incorporate lots of changes to help with reusability. Lessons from the Shuttle are commonly brought up, but may not apply very much. Aside from being very different craft (with the Shuttle running on much thinner margins), a huge difference is that SpaceX is able to rapidly and strongly iterate as they learn. The Shuttle that first launched in 1981 was not all that different from the one that last launched in 2011. The design was not entirely set in stone when it started flying, but it was pretty close. That's what happens when your vehicles cost multiple billions of dollars each. SpaceX is continuing to build new rockets and that makes it a lot easier to make changes to react to experiences with older designs. I doubt the ships are all that expensive in the grand scheme of things. I'm sure the cost is more than what you or I could afford, but I don't think it's a particularly large fraction of the booster's multi-dozen-million-dollar cost. In any case, it will be great to see how it works out, rather than just talking about how it might work out!
- simonh 10y agoOh absolutely, it's a revolution in the making. In fact the limiting factor on their launch cadence in a few years might just be how quickly they can manufacture second stages. That would be a great problem to have.