4 ms·
Societies will need to tread carefully here. Brexit, Trump and other national retrenchment movements are looking more like canaries in the coal mine --a bracin
by mc32 10y ago
Societies will need to tread carefully here.
Brexit, Trump and other national retrenchment movements are looking more like canaries in the coal mine --a bracing for the waves of displaced workers looking to displace the ebbing but expensive workforces in mature industrialized countries (EU, US, Japan, SK, CA, AU, etc) for less as the need for cheap labor by mature industrialized economies evaporates due to quickly slacking demand caused by automation. [We don't need factories overseas making things to sell in Wal*mart if we can have robots make them "in-house".]
Question 1 is how will mature economies offer their own population a way to make a living [keep their standard of living]. Question 2. is while globalization enabled billions to emerge from extreme poverty, a pause in demand for labor combined with growing populations in developing countries will result in big messes. If the first world finds it hard to provide for itself, there will be little they do for what were developing economies and even less the governments of those economies will do for their own.
We might see some economies ban automation as a way to stave off untenable unemployment in economies with little tax revenue.
Interesting times.
- manmal 10y agoI haven't thought enough about this, but perhaps cheap automation could lead to self-sufficiency of nations. Apart from rare resources (which could be recycled?) * , goods could be produced where they are needed. If a state is more or less self sufficient, it can create a bubble in which its citizens are provided for even if they don't work. Or am I missing something? * This would probably look like the UDSSR or WW-II Germany, but without the downsides caused by ideology. Workers could concentrate on improving automation ever further. The obvious downside would be that ideology would not die out, and nations would still strive to grow bigger > war.
- jdietrich 10y agoComparative advantage. Self-sufficiency would make us all worse off. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage
- sprafa 10y agoComparative advantage is a capitalism reasoning for Competition. It's actual logic in a post-scarcity world is dubious.
- pizza 10y agoIf self-sufficiency per person is negligible, worse off can still mean blissful. Alternatively, in the deep future, there might be the annihilation of comparative advantage, somehow.
- Jabanga 10y agoA much more important question is whether the Luddite fallacy, which all of your predictions are based on, will prove to not be a fallacy. So far no evidence it's a valid economic theory, and plenty of evidence to suggest it isn't.
- HillaryBriss 10y ago> ...are looking more like canaries in the coal mine interesting. the analogy i've been seeing is more like "closing the barn door after all the horses ran out".