9 ms·
Absolutely. Did this person work more or does he have more merit than 100.000.000s of people? It's absurd.
by andrepd 10y ago
Absolutely. Did this person work more or does he have more merit than 100.000.000s of people? It's absurd.
- _cairn 10y agoNot saying that what you are implying is wrong, but empirically speaking working hard/relative merit do not correlate to proportionate monetary rewards in our current system. The idea of a pure meritocracy is an interesting one, I wonder what some of the outcomes would be.
- tucaz 10y agoThere is also the fact that money (and value) is not a zero sum game. Bezos making billions doesnt mean that the money was taken from someone else in the sense that that person cannot have it anymore. The opposite is also true. If he was poor it doesn't mean that I would have more money. Value creation is a weird but beautiful thing.
- lawnchair_larry 10y agoI don't think that's the entirely the case. True it's not zero sum, but it's not free either. There is absolutely wealth transfer. For example, if he were poor, many middle class Seattle residents would have far more purchasing power in their current real estate market. Amazon have expanded rapidly and transplanted most of the cogs who are building the Bezos empire. The many displaced multi-generational residents of Seattle and San Francisco might not refer to this phenomenon as beautiful.
- derwiki 10y agoBut someone's got to be the hardest working and have the most merit... just like someone has to be the least hardest working and have the least merit.
- 100ideas 10y agoYou're saying net global merit is a zero-sum system?
- perseusprime11 10y agoPerils of capitalism in it's absolute form. We celebrate these people for becoming rich and we will celebrate again for giving back their money like Bill Gates and Warren Buffet.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 10y agoAre you suggesting we shouldn't thank them? Now that's a perilous idea.
- andrepd 10y agoFor accruing wealth for themselves? Why should we?
- paulddraper 10y ago"Merit" could refer to many things, but yes, I think he directly/indirectly added more utility to people's lives than 100,000s of other people.
- manmal 10y agoI don't think money is a good proxy for "adding utility to people's lives". It's a good proxy for "good at playing the money game". A nurse won't be paid $1B if she saves a CEO's life, and he is able to go and make his company billions as a result. A clever business person might, if she saves the CEO in some other aspect, as she can setup a provision first. That being said, I don't think money has much to do with merit, either. It's just the output of a function that you are either good at optimizing or not.
- paulddraper 10y agoYes, supply comes into it too. A nurse will be paid a substantial sum if she is one of very few that can save the CEO's life.
- mcbits 10y agoThe CEO can die and the company will continue functioning 95% as well. Or maybe 105%, or 10%, or 1,000%.
- paulddraper 10y agoIf he's eating the shareholder's money like that, they should fire him.
- gozur88 10y agoNeither. He had money which he risked. Capitalism isn't about working harder, it's about getting a return on risk.
- flyinglizard 10y agoThat's not about what he did do or did not do. In reality there's no concept of "fair pay" or "just earnings". In fact, Bezos doesn't even matter, personally. What matters is that he owns an asset (Amazon) that appreciated in value. Obviously, his "net worth" is tied to this holding. It appreciated because it provided desirable services. Now, preventing it can be done in two ways, and only two ways - either limit Amazon's appreciation in value (curb the company), or limit the person's holding in Amazon, meaning that if you started as a founder of a company having 50% of the total shares, your holdings will decline as the company's worth rises. Does this seem reasonable to you?
- psyc 10y agoThis isn't thinking far enough outside the tiny box of this specific economic order at this specific point in history. For example, we could have co-ops instead of corps.
- thomaskcr 10y agoThe vast majority of businesses fail, and many businesses go through cycles where they make less money than they spend. How can the average person take on the risk of not getting paid for years? One year of non-profitability would be a death sentence for a co-op if people can't get paid and flee. A corporation allows the average person to get paid while someone else takes on a risk with their money.
- pfisch 10y agoHe provided more economic/productive value to the world than 100,000,000s of people. Idk about "working hard" or "merit" because who cares if someone has to work super hard for 2 days to produce the same results another person can produce in 10 minutes.
- psyc 10y agoThat's a fantasy. An analogy taken too literally. People lionize John Galts and imagine that they are their organizations. They aren't. Just because he started it and called the shots doesn't mean he literally is Amazon. That's a fanciful way of thinking and it's disastrous for us mortals to take it literally. Amazon is all the people working there, who, while well-paid compared to all the other serfs, actually get a paltry share of the fortune they generate collectively.
- pfisch 10y agoI never said he "was amazon". I am talking about his contribution to amazon. All those "serfs" are not really risking their own personal wealth. They take home their pay win or lose for amazon. They are not serfs. They are getting paid for their work.
- ploxiln 10y agoVery complicated systems, like computer hardware and software systems, particularly services and distributed systems, do have this un-intuitive property of amplifying competence differences. healthcare.gov is one visible and notable example where thousands of "trained and certified professionals" made a huge mess, and like 10 volunteers from silicon valley cleaned it up. You could hire 100000 or 200000 such contracted professionals and the value produced would be even lower. Sure, most of the blame is with the management structure, which the ~10 volunteers bypassed and overrode. But the results stand. A few people in the right place can produce more value than orders of magnitude more people doing the wrong thing for whatever reason. EDIT to better address your point: very few people could have done as well as Bezos in his position. Take any of the CEOs HP has had in the last decade, put them at the head of Amazon, and it would have done a lot worse. Put them all there, it would have done worse. Bezos gets a huge value multiplier for practical reasons.