4 ms·
The problem I have with the popular "simplify" US tax proposals is that they mostly do it by repealing whole sections of the tax code, ending up super regressiv
by ryandrake 10y ago
The problem I have with the popular "simplify" US tax proposals is that they mostly do it by repealing whole sections of the tax code, ending up super regressive and/or hurting the poor and middle class and helping the already rich.
Flat tax @ a high rate: Neutral or slightly helpful to the rich, crushing to the poor and middle class
Flat tax @ a low rate: Windfall to the rich, the resulting gutting of government programs hurt the poor and middle class
Eliminate taxes on dividends: Windfall to the rich, neutral to the poor and middle class who don't benefit from dividends
Eliminate many deductions and loopholes and reduce top tax rate (one of Trump's proposals): Rich are likely better off, no help to the poor and middle class
Reform AMT: Helpful to the rich and people with stock options, no effect for the poor and middle class
Eliminate income phaseouts: Helpful to the rich, no help to the poor and middle class
Eliminate estate or gift taxes: Helpful to the rich, no help to the poor and middle class
Eliminate income tax in favor of sales tax or VAT: Windfall to the rich, crushing to the poor, probably negative for the middle class
The ability to file your taxes on a postcard isn't worth it if it means advantaging the already advantaged.
- ghouse 10y agoBut this isn't that. The government already has enough information for the majority of US taxpayers to complete their tax return. W-2 income only? Or other income that's already reported to the government? Government sends you a tax return to sign. If you have more complicated taxes or don't fall into the 1040EZ, then do continue to do as you do today.
- Aloha 10y agoHave you considered that the tax system shouldnt /help/ anyone? Trying to further social policy via taxation is about the least efficient way to do it. Treat all income the same, do not allow deductions, charge a medium rate (10-25%), exempt the first 35-50k a year - no special rates for married filers (everyone files single), no deductions for dependents. Eliminate corporate income tax entirely, replace with a VAT and a financial transactions tax (.25% of any transaction).
- ryandrake 10y agoAny tax system will have winners and losers, including no tax system at all, including one where the treasury burned the collected money rather than used it to pay for social programs. Who ever designs the tax system directly chooses the winners and losers--it cannot be avoided.
- mullen 10y ago> Trying to further social policy via taxation is about the least efficient way to do it. Works well for controlling a populations smoking and drinking.
- fattire 10y agoListen to the podcast. THis has nothing to do with changing what taxes are paid. It's about simplifying the tax-paying process, which is unnecessarily a pain in the ass for the benefit of a few software companies.