6 ms·
Correction: this proposal would not have simplified taxes (i.e., the California tax code). It would merely have simplified the filing of tax returns for the mos
by gamblor956 10y ago
Correction: this proposal would not have simplified taxes (i.e., the California tax code). It would merely have simplified the filing of tax returns for the most common case, salaried workers receiving all of their income from a single source.
Very big difference. HRBlock and Intuit are heavily vested in maintaining the current tax filing system. They are not, however, meaningful players in the attempts to rewrite the tax code.
- thebrettd 10y agoThis is a good point. I think a real solution to the 'tax problem' requires both a) having the gubment send us an itemized invoice instead of making us file and b) having a transparent, simple to grok code so that we can validate the bill. edit: this is obviously a huge huge problem to tackle, but dont we all feel a lot of energy around this during tax season? :)
- cestith 10y agoI disagree on one point. Block and Intuit are also lobbyists against all sorts of code simplification programs. Anything that makes the filing process easier, and having fewer deductions and penalties available makes it easer, they are against.
- ams6110 10y agoThe business of H&R Block and Intuit came about in response to tax code complexity, they did not create it.
- llukas 10y agoIn other words they rely on tax code being complex or their reason to exist ceases.
- pmorici 10y agoThey didn't need to create it too perpetuate it for their own self interest.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- WalterSear 10y agoAnd the prison lobby came about because we have prisons.
- cestith 10y agoBoeing didn't create the Air Force, either. Comcast didn't invent TV, cable TV, or the Internet. MADD didn't invent cars, alcohol, or DUIs. The DEA didn't invent drugs. Ruger didn't invent firearms. GM didn't invent the automobile. The UAW didn't invent factories or employment agreements. I fail to see what being interested in the state of continued being of something has to do with having been the inventor.
- ams6110 10y agoThe point is that they are a symptom. The problem is the government and their inability to keep anything simple. And in reference to the original topic, taxes for people with one W2 and no other income are not complicated. You can complete a 1040EZ on paper in 5 or 10 minutes.
- ghouse 10y agoThey were created to treat a symptom, not address the cause. Now that a viable way to eliminate the cause exists, they advocate the keep the root problem.
- cestith 10y agoThe 1040EZ doesn't allow one to deduct home mortgage interest. You need a 1098 and a Schedule A and the long-form 1040. That has nothing to do with whether you're filing from a single W2 or multiple 1099 forms. IIRC you can't deduct relocation expenses, wardrobe for work, books and training materials, or a whole bunch of other stuff on a 1040 EZ. So sure, as long as you want to overpay your taxes you can file in about 45 seconds.
- ams6110 10y agoThe original article was talking about simple tax returns. In fact, the 1040EZ is relatively new. Much newer than the existence of H&R Block. So evidently their efforts to keep taxes complicated aren't entirely successful. Even a 1040 "long form" (2 pages) with itemized deductions for mortgage interest isn't that complicated. I file about a 10 page return, 1040 with schedule A, schedule C, self-employment and various others and I always do it myself on paper. If you are at the point where you think you need TurboTax, you're probably better off just hiring a local CPA firm to do your taxes.
- keithnz 10y agoIn new zealand, we got rid of having to do tax returns for salaried/wage earners a number of years ago. Makes life easy for a vast majority of people. You can still do a return if you want to though. For the tax department it cuts down on how much infrastructure they need.
- hnal943 10y agoI think that's optimizing the wrong thing; people should be aware of the amount they are paying in taxes.
- dingaling 10y agoIn the UK each pay-as-you-earn taxpayer ( I.e. tax calculated automatically and deducted from net income ) receives an annual statement of their tax and figuratively how it was spent e.g. £800 on health, £105 on defence etc
- thomastjeffery 10y agoWhereas in the US most people don't pay any attention to where their tax dollars go. Meanwhile, President Trump raised our already ludicrous defense budget another $50 billion.
- Twirrim 10y agoThe UK does the same thing as NZ, no tax returns. At the end of the tax year you get a P60 form that tells you how much tax you paid over the last year. Instead of opting for the deductibles route, goods are subsidised at point of sale, so e.g. if you're buying solar panels, you don't need to cover the whole thing up front, or whatever financing deal you get, then claim money back in your tax return; instead the price you buy the panel at already has the subsidy baked in. There is a slight difference between the UK and US, though, in that there is no per-state/county income taxes. Only UK wide. Individual counties use property tax to raise what revenues they need (counties are also responsible for a lot less things than States)
- djb_hackernews 10y agoInteresting objection. To me simplify taxes == simplify filing taxes. "I'm doing my taxes" does not mean I'm doing my tax code, but I am preparing and filing my taxes. As a lawyer and tax accountant, do you see a flaw in the professor's approach? Any domain expert insight here?
- lmkg 10y agoDepends on what you mean by "preparing." If the tax code is simpler, that means that there are less lines to fill out and fewer pieces of supporting documentation to find and attach. When people talk about making filing simpler, they mean that the lines are pre-filled, and the supporting documentation is either easier to obtain or somehow not necessary.
- rayiner 10y agoThe entire tax-prep industry generates about the same revenues as Dunkin Donuts. The idea that it is a significant causal factor in keeping taxes complicated is preposterous.
- anigbrowl 10y agoWhat's preposterous about it? You can buy a lot of influence for a couple million a year. Are you saying they're wasting their money and might as well just redistribute it to shareholders? If not, then presumably they think it a worthwhile expense or they wouldn't spend it.
- rayiner 10y agoThe Chamber of Commerce has been lobbying for a simpler tax code (including flat taxes) for decades. They can direct vastly more lobbying dollars to the problem than can Intuit or H&R Block. If it was just a matter of lobbying dollars, the 0.5% of the economy that benefits from more complicated taxes could not possibly out-lobby the 99.5% of the economy that benefits from simpler taxes (all else being equal).
- MaysonL 10y agoThe thing is, there are a lot of people and industries lobbying to keep the tax system complicated: real eatate agents and home builders want the mortgage deduction, oil and gas industries want the depletion allowance, hedge funds want carried interest, et cetera ad libitum. It's nowhere near 0.5% of the influential people in the economy, plus the people it benefits, it benefits a lot, while everybody else, it grinds away a few percent of their welfare. EDIT to add: plus the incentives for lawmakers are to keep the system complicated, so all the contributions keep rolling in.
- cookiecaper 10y agoTurns out that people want to pay less tax. You say this like it's unexpected. Most people are not going to have personal concerns over a pre-filled return as long as they are confident that they can modify it without repercussions. They may oppose it ideologically, on the basis that the government should experience as much friction as possible in its efforts to fleece the populace. Such an ideological position is a valid reason to oppose this change.
- ThomPete 10y agoI am not sure I see what you mean with "merely" it's quite a big thing not to have to deal with it every year. In Denmark and many other countries this is a non-issue. The US should be too but too many interest from the lobbying of people like Intuit.
- ccvannorman 10y agoThis is the correct answer to American's "That won't work because ..." on this thread. Turn your head to the right and take a look at Europe where it is plainly working just fine. Turn your head back left and look at how F'd up taxes are in the U.S. and it's pretty clear that objectively we have no excuse other than "some small minority of people are profiting from a broken system and are going to keep it that way."
- cookiecaper 10y agoFirst, what works in Europe is not necessarily portable. We could just as easily pick things that are better about the U.S. and badger Europeans about why they're not doing it that way when "it is plainly working fine". Second, everyone attempts to cast every policy decision they dislike as evidence of corruption, chicanery, etc., but I don't think that's typically the case. The fact that a corporation and an elected representative agree regarding some policies does not immediately invalidate the position, nor should it immediately implicate the representative in accusations of malfeasance. People have spent significant time in this thread discussing the pros and cons of such a policy, yet you insist that the only possible reason it would fail with the people's representatives is that "a small minority are profiting from a broken system". I guess since an advocate carried around a binder full of positive reviews, we assume that must be the universal sentiment of the people? Is it not plausible that, as seen throughout this thread, many people simply don't agree that this would be a positive change?
- ThomPete 10y agoIm not badgering anyone i just know as a european luving in the us that it doesent have to be that difficult.
- sgustard 10y agoHow is the proposal different than California's current online filing? https://www.ftb.ca.gov/online/calfile/index.asp https://www.ftb.ca.gov/online/calfile/index.asp
- mullen 10y agoCalFile morphed from Ready Return. The Tax Franchise Board created CalFile since they did not need permission to do it.