4 ms·
Completely agree. Monopolies are the problem. Capitalism is a delicate system and, unregulated, it leads to monopolies. That's why capitalism needs regulation -
by dreamcompiler 10y ago
Completely agree. Monopolies are the problem. Capitalism is a delicate system and, unregulated, it leads to monopolies. That's why capitalism needs regulation -- not to pick winners, but to ensure healthy competition. This is something Republicans seem to be willfully obtuse about. Capitalism without regulation is like a football game without referees.
- skylan_q 10y agoBut we live in a world with regulatory capture. Regulations make it easier/better for corporations, not the employees or consumers.
- platz 10y agoThe counterpoint is, if The monopoly power of ISPs are the real problem, VPNs don't do anything to stop the monopoly power of ISPs. VPNs are a strategy for mitigating an individual's exposure—leaving the monopoly of the ISP intact.
- dreamcompiler 10y agoYes, ISP monopolies are still a problem w.r.t. price and quality of service. But VPNs stop the ability of ISPs to snoop on and sell your data, which -- in a perfect world with ISP competition -- market forces would prevent. So VPNs can take the place of market forces for one of the bad things that arise with ISP monopolies, namely the one that the House just enabled yesterday.
- dragonwriter 10y agoVPNs do that so long as ISPs don't inhibit, block, deprioritize, or charge extra for traffic that isn't over known protocols that they can mine for salable data; which, given that the same political actors that oppose the FCCs Privacy Report and Order also oppose the Open Internet Report and Order that prohibits that action means that VPNs may not long be an effective mitigation of the policy problem, because of an intimately linked policy problem.
- narrowrail 10y agoAll corporate mobile work forces rely on VPNs, so it may be a solution to get a business account?
- platz 10y agoyou can achieve anything if you're willing to pay for it; still doesn't solve the broader issue here.
- yock 10y agoThere are a lot of factors leading to the current lack of competition in most markets, but I'm not convinced that a monopoly is an entirely natural market condition in this instance. If it were, providers wouldn't demand franchise agreements before entering markets. https://arstechnica.com/business/2014/04/one-big-reason-we-lack-internet-competition-starting-an-isp-is-really-hard/ https://arstechnica.com/business/2014/04/one-big-reason-we-l... https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/the-fcc-cant-help-cities-trapped-by-predatory-internet-deals-with-big-telecom https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/the-fcc-cant-help... https://consumerist.com/2015/05/26/why-your-cable-company-doesnt-always-know-if-your-new-address-gets-service/ https://consumerist.com/2015/05/26/why-your-cable-company-do... Government regulation contributes much to the cost of investing in infrastructure and starting an ISP business in most areas. I think it would be interesting to see what would happen if that cost could be brought down.
- dkhenry 10y agoThis is I think where the voting public gets played by both sides. On the "free market" side people are told all regulation is bad, just let the market operate. Which ignores that some regulation is needed to keep a level playing field. Then on the other side we are told we need to strictly regulate to control for safety and shared resources, but both sides just impose regulation that benefit established firms and sell out consumers.
- theseatoms 10y ago> ... but both sides just impose regulation that benefit established firms and sell out consumers. Can't agree more. Corporatist rent-seeking is the fundamental problem with our political economy and/or society. But both sides keep talking past each other (as they are incentivized to do).
- iamdave 10y agorent-seeking Tangent, thanks. This is the phrase I was trying to conjure to mind earlier today in a discussion about the very topic of this thread. Ended up taking a long, exhaustive and context-laden road to get to my point; after which I had already lost an audience but so it goes. For the interested: https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Rent-seeking https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Rent-seeking
- amluto 10y ago> Which ignores that some regulation is needed to keep a level playing field. Think about the original purpose of the FCC. Some regulation is required to make the services work at all. With a completely deregulated system, your microwave would disrupt cell-phone service for blocks. Your computer power supply might do the same thing. And Verizon phones would probably intentionally interfere with AT&T phones. Low-frequency spectrum is a public resource, full stop.
- hackeraccount 10y agoRegulations destroy competition. Sometimes that's a sacrifice you want to make - do you want an unregulated drug market or would you reduce the number participants with burdensome regulations? - but I don't think you can regulate your way to competition. Or to lower prices.
- AstralStorm 10y agoThat depends on whether said regulation actually increases barriers to entry or decreases them. Anti-cartel ones do the latter. Many properly made regulations are not easier to adhere to by big vs small agents.
- droopyEyelids 10y agoUS history is rife with examples that contradict you. (anti-trust regulation) Regulation is a tool, and it does more or less what the tool user intends it to.
- mtanski 10y agoI'm going to object to the "more or less what the tool user intends it to". Our economy and political system is chockfull with examples of unintended consequences. Both majority parties are guilting of this.
- therpe1 10y ago> Regulations destroy competition. It's worth pointing out that this is nonsense. In virtually every other developed country in the world regulation has actually increased competition between ISPs. The result has been internet service that is dramatically better, faster and cheaper than what is available to most Americans. It's worth taking a very close look at France[1] and South Korea[2] in particular. Or you can continue to believe complete fucking nonsense like "regulations destroy competition" and plod ahead with crappy internet while the few monopoly ISPs that exist hoover up virtually all your personal data. [1] http://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/we-need-real-competition-not-a-cable-internet-monopoly http://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/we-need-real-com... [2] http://www.idgconnect.com/abstract/8960/why-does-south-korea-have-fastest-internet http://www.idgconnect.com/abstract/8960/why-does-south-korea...
- theseatoms 10y agoThat's a double-edged sword. Regulations create monopolies as well.
- ams6110 10y agoIt is the regulation that created the monopolies. Local cable companies and telcos have legal monopolies in many areas by way of franchise agreements with municipalities. Monopolies don't last in a free market. Someone hungrier will eventually come in and undercut the incumbent.