5 ms·
Is it me or unions on Germany are a species of their own kind? I mean I'm expected the union to do strikes to raise salaries, protect laziness and unproductive
by csomar 10y ago
Is it me or unions on Germany are a species of their own kind? I mean I'm expected the union to do strikes to raise salaries, protect laziness and unproductive workers, counter automation and firing of current workers...
Edit: I'm not sure why I'm getting down-voted over this.
- bluGill 10y agoA "smart" union needs to consider the health of the company. If they get a salary of $1million per yer for each employee it is obvious that no company cannot afford the salary and will go out of business in a few months and all employees get 0 after that until they find a new job. (This is a strawman argument, but it makes the point clear) A union that is smart should force the company to do things that will keep the company in business. Note that unions, management, and investors are often not smart. This is often to their long term harm.
- masklinn 10y ago> Note that unions, management, and investors are often not smart. And that's an important point, because a "smart union" only works if management doesn't try to railroad them at every turn. It's not exactly surprising that e.g. US Unions had to be hard rather than smart, given management or investors would call the army on them. In the nordic model, unions are part of corporate governance and thus can have significant stake in and impact on corporate policy, in the US unions are considered pests to be squashed and only listened to when there's literally no other way.
- kuschku 10y agoGerman unions are entirely different because in German companies 50% of the board are elected by employees (and the other 50% by the investors). This obviously changes power dynamics quite a bit.
- Ericson2314 10y agoWoah, that's incredible
- anigbrowl 10y agoI would love to see this in the US. The german economy doesn't seem to be suffering the same sort of financialization problems as the US/UK, perhaps due to historical memory.
- imglorp 10y agoSomeone downvoted this anti-union sentiment but I think the real question addresses the balance of interests of the workers (continued jobs) versus the company (profitability). In fact, in modern times, according to Greenspan, there is also a third party: the corporate leadership's interest is at odds with both the employees and the sharedholders, forming a triangle of interest. Perhaps this third only applies to US public corps.
- Retric 10y agoMany people and organizations with a lot of power have spent a lot of time and money giving you that impression. Unions have done a great deal of good worldwide, but no 'it's Henry Ford that's responsible for the 40 hour week' etc. PS: Remember, the best way to keep power long term is to convince everyone else to hand it to you.
- epistasis 10y ago>it's Henry Ford that's responsible for the 40 hour week etc. Your comment is pretty hard to parse, but that's not a thing that I've ever hard anybody say. >PS: Remember, the best way to keep power long term is to convince everyone else to hand it to you. Your phrasing makes me think that you're trying to be sarcastic, but that's exactly how every long term transition of power has ever worked. If people are not convinced that you should have the power, they will take it away on a whim. See, for example, the US civil rights movement vs. the emancipation proclamation and civil war. The South was not in general convinced by the emancipation proclamation, and so the oppression continued in the extreme. The civil rights movement did an awful lot of convincing, and though there are still those that are unconvinced, the power transition was far more lasting and complete. Force only works as long as you have the upper hand. Convincing works as long as the other person is convinced.
- Retric 10y ago> that's not a thing that I've ever hard anybody say. Google search "40 hour work week Henry Ford" and it auto suggests "henry ford started 40 hour work week" "henry ford invented the 40 hour work week" Which takes you to "Does the 8-hour day and the 40-hour week come from Henry Ford, or labor unions?" http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/sep/09/viral-image/does-8-hour-day-and-40-hour-come-henry-ford-or-lab/ http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/sep/... "In 1914, at a time when most workers still lacked a guarantee of eight-hour days, the Ford Motor Co. attracted notice for instituting eight-hour shifts and raising wages in the manner the graphic indicates. (For many Ford workers, the work week remained six days.)" Of note, you can get 24 hours from 4 * 6, 3 x 8, or 2 x 12 hour shifts. But, 8 * 6 is not 40. And closes with "The claim contains some element of truth but ignores critical facts that would give a different impression, so we rate it Mostly False."
- pmyteh 10y agoThe German model of trades unionism is built on co-operation between union and management; the history runs deep. One consequence is that workers are screwed over less. Another consequence is that industrial action is rarely necessary.
- ptaipale 10y agoPerhaps rarely "necessary", but happens quite a lot recently. http://www.dw.com/en/germany-to-mark-record-year-for-strikes/a-18450024 http://www.dw.com/en/germany-to-mark-record-year-for-strikes...
- Joeri 10y agoThere's a mindset in much of europe that labor and capital are partners in determining a company's or even industry's future. In fact, the unions often sit down to negotiate with the government and industry leaders as equals to set industry policies.
- maxxxxx 10y agoThis collaboration is a very good thing. All participants in the economy should have a stake. It kind of scares me that although Trump got elected by a lot of workers in his administration only business people get heard. They will shape policy for themselves but I don't think workers will get any benefit.
- masklinn 10y ago"Much of europe" is a bit too generalising, that's more specifically the german and nordic model, labour relations in e.g. France have historically been much more combative and closer to the US's.
- alkonaut 10y ago> I'm not sure why I'm getting down-voted over this. Because you first expressed a misunderstanding about what unions are and then expressed a misunderstanding about how this site works.
- Sharlin 10y ago> Edit: I'm not sure why I'm getting down-voted over this. Because your characterization of unions just sounds like blindly repeating the anti-union propaganda that has been so successful in the US starting from Reagan's time.
- csomar 10y agoNot really, I'm not from the US and I don't know the US history with unions. I'm speaking from practical experience in my country and several other countries where unions where responsible (or a cause) for the collapse of several companies and industries.
- wavefunction 10y agoWould you say the same things about executives as you did about unions? There have been a few failures of companies and industries at their hands as well.
- kalleboo 10y agoNo, it's American unions that are a species of their own kind.
- justin66 10y agoSeveral different species, really. The UAW is at least as dissimilar to the Screen Actors Guild as it is from Audi's union.
- anigbrowl 10y agoI'm not sure why you're getting downvoted either. Unions do operate a bit differently in Germany, which takes manufacturing capability seriously as a national goal and treats industry as a cooperative venture of labor and capital. It's a pragmatic approach that seems to consistently pay dividends. The Economist has some excellent coverage of the differences, look up one of their periodic special reports on manufacturing or Germany.