8 ms·
This is one of those situations where broad-strokes rules just don't help very much. >"There ought to be a new standard of care, said Ruffin, and it should inc
by hprotagonist 10y ago
This is one of those situations where broad-strokes rules just don't help very much.
>"There ought to be a new standard of care, said Ruffin, and it should include not just temporary involuntary psychiatric and physical treatment, but long-term case management."
This is the crux of it. Admitting people to a psych ward for an involuntary hold is ripe for abuse. You can respect someone's autonomy (even a homeless person with psychiatric problems' autonomy) and, at the same time, help them not freeze to death.
It usually starts with having enough caseworkers with enough bureaucratic leeway to build actual relationships with their clients. I don't think we're anywhere close to that.
- alexpatin 10y agoThis exactly. One needs to establish trust with these people, as they have almost always dealt with some form of trauma one way or another - either physically, emotionally, psychologically, etc. When this stuff is made into a process, it becomes robotic and the empathetic, human element of it is taken away from it. These people need someone to listen and understand, not necessarily someone to shove anti-psychotics and whatever else caretakers are told to do. I'm not saying drugs don't help, but it's best when trust is established, and one can help the patient see why the drug is necessary at the time. That has always been my problem when seeking help for my psychological issues. I'll see a GP or a specialist, get a prescription, they may go over the mechanism of action with me if I push them to, but otherwise I'm told to take 2 every day and report back in a month. I'm a lab rat. Not a patient. See why these people have trouble getting help? They don't feel like patients getting treatment.
- aglavine 10y agoA lot of people suffer of some kind of mental illness, and it is impossible to establish any kind of trust with them. The problem is to make a process to give the adecuate diagnosys to each person and the right treatment with proper funding and competent personnal. Hard, but not impossible.
- jdbernard 10y agoAgain I'm frustrated that people are just down-voting and not adding to the discussion. aglavine is right, for example in the case of paranoid schizophrenia. I have personally seen someone I am very close to descend into this madness. When they are not lucid it is literally impossible to establish any trust because the fundamental axioms with which they view the world are skewed. You can reason, but all the conclusions are fore-gone and the paranoid mind will only find more and more fantastical explanations to support the delusion. The delusion is the core reality. Those of you who down-voted, explain how to establish trust in this context?
- Nomentatus 10y agoYou're right, I think you're encountering a lot of black and white thinking on the other side - something like: "if any temporary progress can be made then love will always triumph"; whereas someone who's very seriously mentally ill is not predictable. Even if you take five years to establish trust, as I have in one case, it just takes one irrational conclusion on their part and that trust can be gone in an instant with no way back; that they can be fairly rational or appreciative some of the time doesn't tell you what comes next. When the brain isn't working right, love and respect can meet a wall.
- tcj_phx 10y ago> and it is impossible to establish any kind of trust with them. Once burned, twice shy. Mentally ill people are frequently harmed by the medications that they're told they have to take. Science now knows that these medications are palliative drugs that actually worsen the long-term prognosis for the patients, but these findings haven't made it to the hospitals yet. [1] [2] [1] https://www.nimh.nih.gov/about/directors/thomas-insel/blog/2013/antipsychotics-taking-the-long-view.shtml https://www.nimh.nih.gov/about/directors/thomas-insel/blog/2... [2] https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/psychiatrists-must-face-possibility-that-medications-hurt-more-than-they-help/?wt.mc=SA_Reddit-Share https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/psychiatris... I witnessed a mental health crisis team do some very good work in convincing my friend to go to the psychiatric hospital. It was unfortunate that the psychiatrists refused to address the cause of her condition [by that point it was nerve damage from neuroleptics], but at least that guy got her off the street.
- humanrebar 10y ago> You can respect someone's autonomy... and, at the same time, help them not freeze to death. How do you do this at scale? One of the challenges with poverty and mental illness is that it gets hard to provide comfort, safety, and opportunity when the homeless are afraid and distrustful of each other, and often justifiably so. The reason there are so many niche shelters (women with kids, youth, LGBTQ, etc.) is that there's some consensus that the general population shelters are not safe. Some of that is just vanilla crime, but a lot of it is a result of a high concentration of the homeless who are mentally ill. And it's not generally a mystery which people are refusing help, medical treatment, or mentorship. At what point does it stop being "respecting autonomy" and start being "enabling dysfunction and abuse"?
- hprotagonist 10y agoYou start small, and earn trust with the unhoused in your city over a long time of being a reliable presence. Then you teach other people to do the same, and they start small... Despite the fact that homelessness writ large is a Societal Issue, social work succeeds or fails two people at a time, and over the course of months and years.
- mabbo 10y ago> You can respect someone's autonomy (even a homeless person with psychiatric problems' autonomy) and, at the same time, help them not freeze to death. Can you? Look, the crux of mental illness is that the organ you use to understand the world and comprehend situations and consequences is broken. If I'm mentally ill, you can't convince me that I'm wrong or that I'm ill anymore than someone with liver disease can process alcohol. That organ doesn't do the job correctly anymore. Logic doesn't apply anymore. How can you respect my autonomy if I'm wrong about my own safety? If I say "I don't believe the cold can harm me, because I believe there is a fire inside me", your choices are to respect my autonomy and find me dead tomorrow morning after the blizzard, or to not respect my autonomy and I'll be alive tomorrow. Bring an army of caseworkers to tell me I'm wrong- it won't matter. They can all watch me die too. Edit: to be clear, I'm talking about the most extreme forms of mental illness, the absolute limit. Like a good unit test, always check the extreme examples to see if your solution works.
- dangerlibrary 10y agoYou are describing an extreme form of mental illness that is not as common as more treatable / manageable forms. If all "mentally ill" people were as incapable of cognition as you suggest, psychology and psychiatry would be very sad, hopeless professions.
- got2surf 10y agoTrue, but in the article, both Partovi and Ruffin cite examples of clients who "claim they own a house, or that a relative will show up any day now", despite being injured/homeless/exposed. To me at least, it seems logical that a reasonable person would choose shelter over being outdoors and injured for 15 years. Making that choice is their right, but let's address their mental health problems first to give them the autonomy to make that choice.
- csours 10y agoMentally healthy people lie to themselves all the time too. Homeless mentally ill people be lying to save face, or that me be at least a component of what they are saying. If you spend enough time with them, you may get a lucid moment where they can be honest with themselves and you; but it is very time consuming to get there.
- bradleyjg 10y agoIt's dangerous to try to solve a problem completely in isolation. If a polity puts together a really generous program for street homeless that involves a ton of resources and benefits but has a relative stingy programs for poor people that are living in shelters or doubled up -- what are the possible unintended consequences of that?