9 ms·
Bigger brains are not always better
- jlebrech 10y agofor example women have smaller but denser brains with closer neurons. so no bigger isn't always better.
- eganist 10y agoOh this is interesting. I'd like to read more about this if you've got sources handy.
- jlebrech 10y agohttp://www.jneurosci.org/content/jneuro/15/5/3418.full.pdf http://www.jneurosci.org/content/jneuro/15/5/3418.full.pdf http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/men-have-bigger-brains-than-women-research-reveals-9124103.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/men-have-bigger-br... a few more result in a google search confirm this, but I don't think it's a contributing factor to intelligence.
- andrepd 10y agoIIRC the difference in volume is small (<10%) and no link has been found between that and any measures of intelligence.
- rlanday 10y agoAre you arguing that no gender gaps have been found in any measures of intelligence, or only that none have been linked to brain volume? There's a fairly persistent gender gap in average math ability: https://www.aei.org/publication/2016-sat-test-results-confirm-pattern-thats-persisted-for-45-years-high-school-boys-are-better-at-math-than-girls/ https://www.aei.org/publication/2016-sat-test-results-confir... I don't know if this has anything to do with average brain volume or not though.
- mikejmoffitt 10y agoThe amount of potentially different experiences male and female adolescents have had by the time they take the SAT make me believe SAT results are not good references for this subject.
- rlanday 10y agoHow about kindergarten? https://qz.com/826748/the-math-gender-gap-between-girls-and-boys-starts-in-kindergarten-and-is-largely-driven-by-teachers-biases/ https://qz.com/826748/the-math-gender-gap-between-girls-and-... There are people who hear "gap X starts in kindergarten" and think "oh, well it must be because of unequal access to preschool, lack of nutrition, etc," basically trying to look earlier and earlier for where the problem starts until they end up trying to blame stuff like maternal nutrition during pregnancy. Well, there may be factors like that at play, but if you start with such a strong preconceived notion that everyone's brains are wired the same way, no amount of evidence is going to convince you of the contrary.
- ralusek 10y agoIs your implication that women are smarter than men, or that they are not notably distinguishable in cognitive capabilities?
- jlebrech 10y agoi'm just saying there may be tradeoffs technically, smaller or longer connections be have pros and cons.
- hectorperez 10y agoNeanderthals had bigger brains than us
- mej10 10y agoThis is orthogonal to the claim. There are hypotheses that Neanderthals were actually smarter than our other ancestors, and that they were wiped out for various reasons unrelated to intelligence. They may have been less violent than homo sapiens or seriously weakened by pathogens that didn't affect homo sapiens.
- Mikeb85 10y agoOr simply less numerous. We do know that many of us (Europeans and Asians) have some Neanderthal DNA, it's entirely possible they were just bred out of existence.
- temp246810 10y agoAccording to 21andMe, I am a whopping 3% neanderthal. Don't know why I felt compelled to share this here, alas, there you go.
- magic_beans 10y agoMost Asian and European people have neanderthal DNA.
- emmelaich 10y agoThat's 23andme. I also have a high Neanderthal percentage. Wikipedia says modern humans have somewhere between 1% and 4%. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neanderthal#Genome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neanderthal#Genome
- temp246810 10y agoRight on, something seemed off in the name but I just didn't look it up. Should have known too, 23x2=56.
- whatshisface 10y ago"Eberhard used these web-making mistakes as a proxy for cognitive capacity." That line seems kind of suspect from my armchair. Web-making isn't a general behavior, and could probably be assigned a certain optimal ammount of brain space as sight and other tasks were compromised to make room in smaller brains. How did the researchers deal with this?
- cgriswald 10y agoI agree. When I got to that part of the article, it just seemed to me he was expecting the same CPU to perform better at a specific, more-or-less optimized task just because it was larger, regardless of architecture or the amount of components within the CPU.
- mcherm 10y agoAnd yet we do that! How fast is that CPU? You'll hear people quoting clock speed. You'll hear people quoting FPOS (floating point operations per second -- at least we USED to quote that). Both of which are single tasks. It's not that we don't realize that the performance of a CPU varies depending on lots of things like instruction set design and (especially) memory pipelines and caching. It's just that there is not a general "does the stuff you want quickly" benchmark to measure (or rather, there ARE several such benchmarks, but each is skewed in its own way and not subtly, so that things like clock speed and FPOS are at least flawed in OBVIOUS ways). And there is some sort of very rough correlation: CPUs with greater clock speed do tend, as a general rule, to run most applications faster. I think rating the spider's intelligence by giving them a web-making challenge was a really BRILLIANT idea, and provided a better assessment of intelligence than any other test I can imagine giving to a spider. Can you do better?
- cgriswald 10y agoI wasn't questioning the methodology. I think this was a good experiment and really interesting result. I was questioning the shocking surprise at the result as expressed by the article. A spider's brain is not a general purpose computing device. It has specific evolved functions. Performing that function well is necessary for the continuation of the species; both species have continued to survive, so both species probably perform the function well; no surprise.
- Arizhel 10y agoWe'd be better off with much smaller brains, so that we can have smaller heads optimized for an aquatic life. We're failing pretty miserably at this civilization stuff anyway.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- known 10y agoI read somewhere that ants design better algorithms than humans;
- Verdex_2 10y agoI would be interested in some sort of elaboration or source citing here. For example what do you mean by "design". Ants aren't exactly encoding anything into silicon or filling books with mathematics. Can you qualify what you're trying to say?
- sandworm101 10y agoAnts and bees are good at things like filling a space with a structured construction, or growing a structure while using the least amount of material. I wouldnt call it smarts, rather very-evolved patterns coded as instinct. The ant, as a group or species, can do a few things better than humans.
- et2o 10y agoThere is a great statistic called the encephalization quotient that is simply log brain mass divided by log body mass. There is a fairly strong correlation (https://universe-review.ca/I10-83-brainmass.jpg https://universe-review.ca/I10-83-brainmass.jpg), but you find that species which deviate from the best fit line (biggest residuals) tend to be the species we associate as intelligent or not intelligent. Humans have the largest magnitude residual.
- pennaMan 10y agoWhat species is the point right next to humans? It's not a primate, interestingly.
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoIt's probably a dolphin or porpoise. Not only do they have some of the highest EQ of non-primates, they're also the right weight range: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cetacean_species#Family_Delphinidae:_oceanic_dolphins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cetacean_species#Famil... You may think of bottlenose dolphins as representative of the whole family, but they actually are much larger than most of their brethren.
- neonnoodle 10y agoSome kind of cetacean.
- scandox 10y agoI remember seeing a photograph of Quentin Tarantino shaking hands with his producer and thinking: the craniums on these guys are enormous. It was the first time I realized consciously that when I look at people with large craniums I do automatically assume they are smarter. Since I realized that, I reserve judgement until they start talking.
- magic_beans 10y agoTo be honest he looks more like he has some sort of pituitary disorder...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- akuma73 10y agoWhale brains are absolutely enormous but I don't see them doing quantum field theory.
- sharkweek 10y ago“For instance, on the planet Earth, man had always assumed that he was more intelligent than dolphins because he had achieved so much—the wheel, New York, wars and so on—whilst all the dolphins had ever done was muck about in the water having a good time. But conversely, the dolphins had always believed that they were far more intelligent than man—for precisely the same reasons.” - Douglas Adams
- greenhatman 10y agoThat's because they know it's a waste of time.
- dorfsmay 10y agoMaybe they were quick to figure out it was a dead end? Seriously though, isn't one of the issue that regardless of how intelligent an animal is, if they are not able to communicate abstract concept from one generation to the next, they have to reinvent everything from scratch each generation?
- SubiculumCode 10y agoThat complex behaviors can arise from simple processes is understood. Moreover in the species mentioned in the article, the problem spaces relevant to survival may have been relatively stable for untold amounts of time. The stable problem spaces increase the evolutionary fitness of efficient algorithms that solve that problem space with min energy expenditure. But such efficiency usually has a cost: reduced flexibility to changes in the problem space. I submit to you that behavioral flexibility in new environments may well correlate with brain size, even excluding humans from the analysis.
- somerandomness 10y agoSure absolute size doesn't matter. But what about number of neurons or neural connections? I'd be curious what the actual studies say. The article hinted at this: "African gray parrots, which can identify shapes and even count, as well as corvids, which have an equivalent number of neurons to some primates and, it is suggested, may even be self-aware." Comparing brain size vs intelligence across species seems weird since neuron size/density differs so much.
- alextheparrot 10y agoShout-out to my account namesake's species. If anyone hasn't watched African grey parrots on YouTube, they are definitely in for a treat.
- programmarchy 10y agoAnother useful metric is degree of surface convolution, with larger surface areas correlating with higher intelligence. Dolphins and whales have a degree of surface convolution similar to humans, although the thickness of their neocortex is about half that of humans. But the biggest factor is likely structure and organization of the cortex, not just size, density, or surface area. A good representation of structure is the homunculus [1], which emphasizes the mouth and hands. Undoubtedly, verbal and written communication have contributed enormously to the explosion of human intelligence. [1] http://www.rci.rutgers.edu/~uzwiak/AnatPhys/APFallLect19_files/image010.jpg http://www.rci.rutgers.edu/~uzwiak/AnatPhys/APFallLect19_fil...
- 6stringmerc 10y agoWhen I learned that humans have genetic mutations resulting in an additional chromosome, my first reaction was to associate it with something like "X-Men" and a big time advantage, and then finding out that it's pretty much an undesirable development complication, I learned a lot about my assumptions + imagination versus finding out the real story.
- jondubois 10y agoI read an interesting article a while ago about a Russian scientist Dmitry Belyayev who did an experiment to try to domesticate wild foxes through selective breeding (by selecting the most docile specimens for reproduction) and the foxs' heads (and presumably brain) shrunk as their became more domesticated (source: https://www.pelicanbooks.com/the-domesticated-brain/preface https://www.pelicanbooks.com/the-domesticated-brain/preface). I have a theory that it's the same with people - It would be interesting to do studies. It's well documented that Neanderthals had larger heads/brains than Cro-Magnons.
- superioritycplx 10y agoTestosterone makes everything bigger.
- thelogos 10y agoIt is not about how big the brain is. It is about the number of neurons, latency, signal reliability and number of connections. Voltage-gated ion channels are non-deterministic. Meaning they don't always open (or not open) when they should. In order to stuff more neurons into the same volume of space, you have to shrink them. The problem is, those ion-channels become more and more unreliable as the size decreases. I would argue that they're already too unreliable in many humans. Second problem, as the size of the axon and myelin sheath decrease, signal reliability and latency will suffer. Yes, the current can die out part-way to its destination. As the brain is less globally connected due to the sheer lack of space, poor signal reliability and increased latency, it will begin to favor local connections over global ones. In other words, specialization and usage of signal superhighways to compensate, just like a crowded city. The problem with a crowded city is, even with great public transport, many people never leave their neighborhoods. So what to do about it? You can leave neurons the same size and make more room instead of trying to shrink them. First problem with this, difficulty of childbirth due to skull size. Second, increased development time, it's already too long as it is. Third, latency and signal reliability will still suffer due to increased distance. Fourth, increased use of resource. You also need to support those neurons and that support system will eat up more and more space. If you try to blow up the size of the axon and myelin sheath to fix the latency and reliability problems, it will eat up even more space. In other words, less room for neurons and you're back to square one. Another problem is, you need a bigger body to support that huge brain. More neurons will be dedicated to processing touch instead of higher-level abstract thoughts. One last thing you can try is, decrease body size, increase brain volume slightly. The lower level of violence, abundance of food, modern healthcare (c-section) and longer lifespan (more time to mature) in modern human societies allow us to do this already. Dedicate more resource to higher levels of the brain associated with abstract thoughts, planning, reasoning, etc. Over-myelinate those areas to increase signal speed and reliability. At the end of the day, there's not much more mother nature can do without deep structural and material change. Reengineer the myelin materials to increase their insulating property and decrease the size. Make the ion-channels more reliable so you can shrink neurons even more, although you still have to worry about quantum tunneling. Or better yet, do away with ions completely and switch to photonic computing.
- 10y ago
- scotty79 10y ago> The best chip out of Intel can’t fly, ... , can’t dogfight, It can https://www.google.pl/amp/www.popsci.com/amp/ai-pilot-beats-air-combat-expert-in-dogfight https://www.google.pl/amp/www.popsci.com/amp/ai-pilot-beats-...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tacon 10y agoHumans can also work fine with almost no brain tissue, as has been discovered throughout history. The canonical article is from 1980, "Is Your Brain Really Necessary?"[0] "There's a young student at this university," says Lorber, "who has an IQ of 126, has gained a first-class honors degree in mathematics, and is socially completely normal. And yet the boy has virtually no brain." The student's physician at the university noticed that the youth had a slightly larger than normal head, and so referred him to Lorber, simply out of interest. "When we did a brain scan on him," Lorber recalls, "we saw that instead of the normal 4.5-centimeter thickness of brain tissue between the ventricles and the cortical surface, there was just a thin layer of mantle measuring a millimeter or so. His cranium is filled mainly with cerebrospinal fluid." [0] http://www.rifters.com/real/articles/Science_No-Brain.pdf http://www.rifters.com/real/articles/Science_No-Brain.pdf
- fjarlq 10y agoIn 2007, John Hawks criticized[1] Lorber's claim. [1]: http://johnhawks.net/weblog/reviews/brain/development/ten_percent_brain_myth_2007.html http://johnhawks.net/weblog/reviews/brain/development/ten_pe...
- tacon 10y agoThanks for that update. That article was in my weird stuff file, and I had no idea the evidence presented was controversial.
- sandworm101 10y agoThere is another layer, and it is very political. "Studies" that show people can be functional without brain matter are championed by certain pro-life groups who want to describe "brain dead" people as potentially functional. It came to a head during the Terri Schiavo fiasco. Her scans were horrific, showing very little brain after her accident. People pointed to these studies as evidence that such a scan did not preclude recovery to a normal life, that she should be kept alive at all costs in hope of recovery. That's how these things stay around. Someone finds them useful for completely non-scientific arguments.
- soniido 10y agoNow that we have deep learning, we know that more layers don't always give better results. Perhaps intelligence and wit is obtained when associations allow our mind to develop neurons that are useful for modeling interesting features. For example, being good at math and having good reasoning skills are very useful features that can be acquired by education and practice. Also we now know that our brain in much more plastic that what was previously believed, for example taxi drivers brains have a bigger spatial area as a result of learning to around big cities. So the question to get better intelligence is how we make child brains develop neural systems related to useful features?, unfortunately teaching chess is not a solution, but perhaps is a step in the right direction, more research is needed.
- prestonpesek 10y agoI'd like to suggest a theory here, that a brain's primary function is to study and occasionally override the information processing algorithms contained in the "unconscious" DNA of the organism. Once the brain has discovered the optimal solution through innovative overrides, the best behavioral solutions are recorded and automated in the DNA as hard code, and no longer requires either supervision or further revisions. At that point in the evolutionary history of the species, it no longer needs to invest so much energy in maintaining such a large a brain, now that what amounts to optimal "muscle memory" in the DNA has been established through successful survival and selection of repeating behavior patterns. So what may appear to us be highly intelligent behavior, these functions are coming not from the brain, but from what has been captured in the DNA. This is a theory from a novice, I am not a scientist of any kind, but an entrepreneur. I don't have time or resources to research the validity of this theory, but perhaps someone else does? Thank you.