6 ms·

The first and fundamental question you want to ask yourself is not how, but why: when your reasons are clear, the path naturally follows. I can see three stran

by manlio 10y ago

The first and fundamental question you want to ask yourself is not how, but why: when your reasons are clear, the path naturally follows. I can see three strands: 1. For health reasons. This is IMO the weakest reason. I'm not interested (nor qualified) in starting an endless debate about the health risk/benefits of meat; but if you only want to eat healthier is best to start with the obvious: cut sugar, snacks, sodas, sweets, junk food and deep fried; eat more low-GI and greens, etc. 2. For Ahimsa [0]. Ahimsa is a beautiful and subtle topic, but broadly speaking it means that you try to minimize the amount of suffering caused by your actions. Buddhists (as well as Socrates) believe we constantly fail to understand that our actions have consequences. Ahimsa is about getting in touch as best as we can with these consequences, and act accordingly to our insights. 3. For environmental reasons, i.e. reducing your ecological footprint. This has some overlap with Ahimsa, but the reasons are practical rather than ethical and there are exceptions: in terms of sheer sustainability, battery farmed chicken might be OK (maybe, I don't know). Whatever your reasons are, it's something I believe is worth thinking about. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahimsa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahimsa

samblr 10y ago
How did u stumble on ahimsa ? edit: rephrased
asidiali 10y ago
You start by saying Reason 1 is the weakest then go on to admit you aren't qualified to be making that statement? Good breakdown regardless. I'd recommend checking out The China Study [1] [1] https://www.amazon.com/China-Study-Comprehensive-Nutrition-Implications/dp/1932100660 https://www.amazon.com/China-Study-Comprehensive-Nutrition-I...
- inieves 10y ago
  He is saying he is not qualified to talk risk/benefit of eating meat BUT REGARDLESS food/diet is the worst reason(in his opinion) to go vegan. And I agree. I found no contradiction in his statement. There are better reasons to go vegan, and as repeatedly stated in thread, reason is important to sustaining the (any) path.
  - asidiali 10y ago
    Care to explain why you believe it's the worst reason?
inieves 10y ago
I think people may be more familiar with the word "compassion" than "Ahimsa" but I am not sure, and definitions of compassion range broadly. I do believe there is a strong link between reducing suffering, compassion, and veganism. It is VERY hard for me to listen to people try to promote messages of peace, love, freedom, compassion... if they are not vegan.
- unprepare 10y ago
  edit: i dont mean any of this to be combative or insulting, figured i would throw this in at the top in case someone doesnt make it to the end thinking i am trying to attack their ideology, just trying to get feedback on an argument i read long ago what do you think about the argument that by removing yourself from the market of meat entirely, you do nothing to promote better lives for livestock. By abstaining from meat, you do nothing to push the meat industry towards more sustainable and compassionate treatment of animals. You, being someone who is conscious of these abuses are in a position to push for change, but instead you remove yourself from the market entirely. Ultimately, isnt refusing to vote with your wallet worse than voting for compassionate and sustainable production of livestock? Wouldnt eating lab grown meat do more to end the suffering of these animals than not eating meat at all? since it would push an entire industry toward your preference of eating only that which was produced to your standards. would the entire population of vegetarians and vegans combined buying only the most sustainable and compassionately raised meats be enough to effect the processes of major producers? Would this be a greater good than not eating meat at all? of course, this likely doesnt effect the decision on a personal level, but at scale does veganism help or hurt the progress towards more sustainably and compassionately raised livestock? (though of course if that scale were to include everyone, it would be no longer an issue i suppose) of course this moreso assumes your overall goal is to reduce the suffering of these animals, or the suffering of all things as much as you possibly can- if your goal is to instead reduce the amount of suffering you directly cause, then this argument is meaningless. I'm honestly asking this, as its the only argument that i have found that sounds reasonable against becoming vegan, im not really trying to start a debate, i dont really have more to say than this, but its an argument that stuck with me the first time i read it and i very rarely have a chance to have a level headed discussion about such a topic (reddit isnt really the place for level headed discussion, and i am not aware of a nutrition or dietary equivalent to hackernews)
gotrythis 10y ago
Here's reason #4. You'll look younger, have better skin, and live longer. Vegans typically live 15 years longer and don't have many of the degenerative diseases which are caused by meat and dairy. I was pushing my parents to let me become vegan when I turned a teenager. I stopped eating meat on my 16th birthday despite their assertions that I would die. Gave up dairy a few years later, which I only ate because the dairy industry's advertising is so damn strong. I'll turn 46 this summer, so it's been almost 30 years, and people think I'm 10-15 years younger. Teenage girls still try to pick me up. My fiance has been vegan for something like 20 years and is 40 this summer. Last year, two high school kids invited her to the prom. And reason #5, which was the primary reason I went vegan, followed by having a sense of ethics and feeling it was wrong to enslave, torture, and murder animals, because meat is yummy: Eating rotting corpses is pretty gross when you think about it.
- mod 10y ago
  > Eating rotting corpses is pretty gross when you think about it. I tend not to let them rot before I eat them, personally. I don't understand why you had to turn your otherwise-upbeat argument into a pretty overt attack in the last sentence.
  - gotrythis 10y ago
    I'm telling you the reason that I went vegan at 16. And those were the main reasons. Though at the time, I called it grody, but I'm not sure of the correct spelling. Animals start to decompose at the moment of death. The meat at the supermarket has been dead for how long? Days, weeks? It is in the process of rotting, just not visibly so. Much of it is actually spoiled, but I've read 70% of meat in supermarkets is treated with carbon monoxide to keep it from going brown or grey. You might not like it, but it's a very valid and important argument. And as for feeling that it's unethical. We (people) enslave entire species, remove their body parts without anaesthesia, cage them in cells so small they can't move, force them to have babies over and over and then kidnap their children and eat them, grind them up, or enslave them as well. It's horrible. I think that anyone who knows what is done and argues, but meat is yummy or delicious as someone else did in here, is a sociopath. Can anyone who is connected to their sense of empathy be okay causing that much pain to other feeling beings?

by manlio 10y ago

samblr 10y ago

How did u stumble on ahimsa ? edit: rephrased

asidiali 10y ago

You start by saying Reason 1 is the weakest then go on to admit you aren't qualified to be making that statement? Good breakdown regardless. I'd recommend checking out The China Study [1] [1] https://www.amazon.com/China-Study-Comprehensive-Nutrition-Implications/dp/1932100660 https://www.amazon.com/China-Study-Comprehensive-Nutrition-I...

inieves 10y ago
He is saying he is not qualified to talk risk/benefit of eating meat BUT REGARDLESS food/diet is the worst reason(in his opinion) to go vegan. And I agree. I found no contradiction in his statement. There are better reasons to go vegan, and as repeatedly stated in thread, reason is important to sustaining the (any) path.
- asidiali 10y ago
  Care to explain why you believe it's the worst reason?

inieves 10y ago

I think people may be more familiar with the word "compassion" than "Ahimsa" but I am not sure, and definitions of compassion range broadly. I do believe there is a strong link between reducing suffering, compassion, and veganism. It is VERY hard for me to listen to people try to promote messages of peace, love, freedom, compassion... if they are not vegan.

unprepare 10y ago
edit: i dont mean any of this to be combative or insulting, figured i would throw this in at the top in case someone doesnt make it to the end thinking i am trying to attack their ideology, just trying to get feedback on an argument i read long ago what do you think about the argument that by removing yourself from the market of meat entirely, you do nothing to promote better lives for livestock. By abstaining from meat, you do nothing to push the meat industry towards more sustainable and compassionate treatment of animals. You, being someone who is conscious of these abuses are in a position to push for change, but instead you remove yourself from the market entirely. Ultimately, isnt refusing to vote with your wallet worse than voting for compassionate and sustainable production of livestock? Wouldnt eating lab grown meat do more to end the suffering of these animals than not eating meat at all? since it would push an entire industry toward your preference of eating only that which was produced to your standards. would the entire population of vegetarians and vegans combined buying only the most sustainable and compassionately raised meats be enough to effect the processes of major producers? Would this be a greater good than not eating meat at all? of course, this likely doesnt effect the decision on a personal level, but at scale does veganism help or hurt the progress towards more sustainably and compassionately raised livestock? (though of course if that scale were to include everyone, it would be no longer an issue i suppose) of course this moreso assumes your overall goal is to reduce the suffering of these animals, or the suffering of all things as much as you possibly can- if your goal is to instead reduce the amount of suffering you directly cause, then this argument is meaningless. I'm honestly asking this, as its the only argument that i have found that sounds reasonable against becoming vegan, im not really trying to start a debate, i dont really have more to say than this, but its an argument that stuck with me the first time i read it and i very rarely have a chance to have a level headed discussion about such a topic (reddit isnt really the place for level headed discussion, and i am not aware of a nutrition or dietary equivalent to hackernews)

gotrythis 10y ago

Here's reason #4. You'll look younger, have better skin, and live longer. Vegans typically live 15 years longer and don't have many of the degenerative diseases which are caused by meat and dairy. I was pushing my parents to let me become vegan when I turned a teenager. I stopped eating meat on my 16th birthday despite their assertions that I would die. Gave up dairy a few years later, which I only ate because the dairy industry's advertising is so damn strong. I'll turn 46 this summer, so it's been almost 30 years, and people think I'm 10-15 years younger. Teenage girls still try to pick me up. My fiance has been vegan for something like 20 years and is 40 this summer. Last year, two high school kids invited her to the prom. And reason #5, which was the primary reason I went vegan, followed by having a sense of ethics and feeling it was wrong to enslave, torture, and murder animals, because meat is yummy: Eating rotting corpses is pretty gross when you think about it.

mod 10y ago
> Eating rotting corpses is pretty gross when you think about it. I tend not to let them rot before I eat them, personally. I don't understand why you had to turn your otherwise-upbeat argument into a pretty overt attack in the last sentence.
- gotrythis 10y ago
  I'm telling you the reason that I went vegan at 16. And those were the main reasons. Though at the time, I called it grody, but I'm not sure of the correct spelling. Animals start to decompose at the moment of death. The meat at the supermarket has been dead for how long? Days, weeks? It is in the process of rotting, just not visibly so. Much of it is actually spoiled, but I've read 70% of meat in supermarkets is treated with carbon monoxide to keep it from going brown or grey. You might not like it, but it's a very valid and important argument. And as for feeling that it's unethical. We (people) enslave entire species, remove their body parts without anaesthesia, cage them in cells so small they can't move, force them to have babies over and over and then kidnap their children and eat them, grind them up, or enslave them as well. It's horrible. I think that anyone who knows what is done and argues, but meat is yummy or delicious as someone else did in here, is a sociopath. Can anyone who is connected to their sense of empathy be okay causing that much pain to other feeling beings?