6 ms·
If I don't work I won't starve. I have reached the point where my investments could sustain a very modest lifestyle, if I moved away from coastal California, i
by aidenn0 10y ago
If I don't work I won't starve. I have reached the point where my investments could sustain a very modest lifestyle, if I moved away from coastal California, indefinitely.
Some of this is due to my job. A lot of it is due to the fact that my family could afford tuition, so I graduated debt free, and when my grandfather passed away, the inheritence allowed me to buy a house at the bottom of the market.
The reality is that the overwhelming majority of wealth exists in the hands of people who did not create equitable value for society.
Actually there are many cases in which people accrue wealth by generating negative value for society, because they are allowed to (or used their exiting influence to lobby for laws that) externalize many of their costs.
I can see how a reasonable person could find taxation (and in particular progressive taxation) morally wrong.
Can you really not see how a reasonable person could find it morally worse to create a world in which some people to have a high chance of starving due to being born into poverty, while others born into wealthy families have a near zero chance of that happening?
- ctdonath 10y agoProduce more value, enjoy the fruits thereof. Yes, one has a moral duty to help those unable, by circumstance, to reach up to that bottom line; provide food, shelter, and education until a minimum is reached and they can provide - so long as the individual is making a fair effort to get there, and not just enjoying a free ride. Compelling others to provide, and giving what's taken to the wantonly idle, is immoral. My thought experiment addresses those who seem to think no effort should be required for survival. If you are at all capable of that minimum level of productivity, it is expected of you; if you truly aren't capable, I'll choose to help you out.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>the wantonly idle This is a really silly phrase: achieving idleness and ease is the very purpose of work.
- ctdonath 10y agoThere is a vast difference between "idle" in terms of enjoying the fruits of your labors, vs "idle" in terms of enjoying the confiscated fruits of the labors of others. It's the difference between retiring early vs living on welfare checks.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoThere's a vast ideological difference to you.
- ctdonath 10y agoThe difference is between "I did the work and am living off my own productivity" vs "I didn't do the work and expect other producers to feed me". Huge difference, unless you reject the notion of ownership - which has repeatedly been proven an unsustainable ideology.