4 ms·
Because ISPs can't read your traffic
by pier25 10y ago
Because ISPs can't read your traffic
- nosuchthing 10y agoYes, but every website you visit can potentially ID you with cookies or browser finger prints.
- mirimir 10y agoWell, you compartmentalize in multiple VMs. Using different VPNs, Tor, and nested chains of them.
- brokenmachine 10y agoThings are getting very inconvenient at that point, all to avoid being snooped on by the people who are supposed to be representing us. What a sorry state of affairs.
- mirimir 10y agoYes, it is unfortunate. But hey, you gotta deal with what's so. There is a learning curve, and extra steps in configuring a working environment. But once the host and VMs are configured, uptime is no worse than with typical LANs.
- erentz 10y agoBut now the VPN provider can just track you and sell all your browsing history instead of the ISP, so how is this better?
- Mahn 10y agoIt's not. There's no way to verify the VPN provider is not keeping logs and tracking you.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThis is the principle-agent problem, generally. Audits and reputation may help.
- mirimir 10y agoBecause you have much more choice for VPN providers than for ISPs. And you can change VPN periodically, far more easily than changing ISP. Also, you can use nested chains of VPNs, much like Tor, to distribute trust. So adversaries must compromise multiple providers, quickly enough that logs will be available. Edit: Also, you can pick VPN providers outside your adversary's sphere of influence. That's standard advice for users in China, for example.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoAlso, you can pay for a VPN without revealing your identity. Not so with ISPs. I use a VPN, for instance, to mask my Tor usage from my ISP. (I'm an American using the Internet in the United States.)
- mirimir 10y agoTrue. But the VPN provider effectively knows who you are, because they see your IP address. Or rather, a resourceful adversary can get your IP address from the VPN provider, and then get your identity from your ISP. If you chain VPNs, however, it certainly makes sense to lease the second/indirect VPN anonymously.
- angry-hacker 10y agoAnd now both of your vpn owners have your data connected to your ips. You do have more choice but if both of them sell the data, it doesn't make any difference.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- peteretep 10y ago> But now the VPN provider can > just track you Find one based in a less offensive jurisdiction?
- Bartweiss 10y agoI've lived places where my only ISP choice was Comcast. I trust them as little as the worst VPNs, and having a choice of VPN lets you choose one which is trustworthy and in a convenient jurisdiction. That matters some in the States (no NSL to Canada, for instance) and a great deal in China or other countries.