5 ms·
If I had to make an overly broad generalization of the HN readership, people reading links here are more willing than the average person to read an article that
by walrus01 10y ago
If I had to make an overly broad generalization of the HN readership, people reading links here are more willing than the average person to read an article that disagrees with their preconceived stereotypes and worldview. Whereas mass market media (the magazine Inc, etc) is going in the opposite direction from that.
- chickenfries 10y ago> If I had to make an overly broad generalization of the HN readership, people reading links here are more willing than the average person to read an article that disagrees with their preconceived stereotypes and worldview. You're right, that was an overly broad generalization about the readership of a public internet forum.
- kagamine 10y agoYeah, let's have a 2-sided conversation about EVs on HN and see. Tesla is God, Tesla is King, Musk will save our souls.
- therpe1 10y agoThis is the sort of self-serving belief that I always find so striking. It's not like HN is a diverse, dynamic community with a wide range of opinions. See all knew what sort of comments would be made the moment see saw the title, it wasn't even really necessary to read the story. Childish diatribes against the "media" based off a very one-sided description of the actions of a single magazine? Check. Invectives against the "liberal narrative" for minorites and Hillary Clinton? Check. At some point see just need the usual suspect to chime in and say something about feminism. Anyways I bring this up because it's very funny, at least to me, to hear all this talk of narratives and bubbles and how everybody claims its not them it's those other guys. Meanwhile the story itself is crap and wholly uninteresting in itself. It's pure gossip and speculation and unfounded assertions. I can think of a hundred reasons why a magazine might've decided not to run a story on this guy. And while I admire his ability to make lemonade -- after all this blog post is almost exactly what many people on the internet would want to hear and it will go viral getting him the publicity he so craves -- it's literally a non-event.
- theandrewbailey 10y ago> Meanwhile the story itself is crap and wholly uninteresting in itself. It's pure gossip and speculation and unfounded assertions. I can think of a hundred reasons why a magazine might've decided not to run a story on this guy. This story is unfounded? Really? We have one solid reason why they didn't run the story: > Subsequently, several months passed with no word from them. I reached out, and was told by the writer as politely as possible, that the editor killed the story — because I wasn’t the “… archetypal Black entrepreneur to hang the story around”.
- cooper12 10y agoIt only took 4 minutes for therpe1'a comment to be flagged. Sounds to me like HN isn't actually so inclined.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lkrubner 10y agoI'm confused why therpe1's comment was flagged. It makes a reasonable point. It doesn't seem outrageous. There are worse comments here on this page. I would upvote the comment if it was already dead. I am puzzled that this particular comment is the one that is flagged.
- hueving 10y agoI would guess it was flagged because it didn't have much substance and just wildly lashed around at things said here - claiming it was predictable HN would say those things. Yet every one of those points has been followed up with opposing opinions so the post is trying to paint the HN community as one-sided when it clearly isn't. So it seems therpe1 is mainly upset that critical commentary takes place here, which is the almost lamest possible thing to complain about. The only thing that would have made it worse is to put something in like "Edit: bring on the downvotes, you know I'm right".
- therpe1 10y agoActually, there's a reason that given all of the issues facing black people in technology HN chose to focus on this particular article and upvote it to the front page. As Noam Chomsky likes to point out, you can have all the debate you want as long as it happens inside this box. Which is why I found all these claims that we at HN don't have a narrative, we don't have a bubble, but that everybody else does -- to be a bit off. My complaint was that indeed (1) this article is gossip, literally one-sided gossip without any data or proof of anything, that informs nobody (2) the discussion it will produce is extremely predictable (and indeed it was) and (3) it's primary objective (for being here) is to confirm existing popular biases at HN. And this is why I found the thread on HN's "critical commentary" to be pretty funny. The idea that this article boldly challenges any narrative is, I think, kind of suspect given its predictable popularity and acceptance at HN.
- Larrikin 10y agoMaybe on which programming language or framework is best. Most articles regarding race/gender discrimination even if they directly involve major tech firms are flagged and downvoted by large portions of the community. If they survive the initial wave, the top comments are usually pretty dismissive
- aaron695 10y agoLarge businesses being evil is a very common narrative and a lame cliche really. So if HN is downvoting, it's probably because educated people are not liking being played by a tired narrative. Major tech firm is worse with race/gender discrimination than the community at large? Please, ever worked blue collar and seen their hiring practices? They are dismissive for a reason. If the tech community wants to set a good example, great. Being played to feel like they are worse than society... to smart for that narrative.
- hueving 10y agoIIRC the "strange year at uber" article was one of the most up-voted articles this year. People on here are always willing to read stories with substantiated claims or new information. However, yet another article pointing out how there is a general gender imbalance in the workforce that matches college CS graduation rates is likely to fall flat.