5 ms·
> Scotland voted strongly to remain in the EU, and despite this it will be leaving. That's obviously part and parcel of being in a union I don't know why it ha
by skissane 10y ago
> Scotland voted strongly to remain in the EU, and despite this it will be leaving. That's obviously part and parcel of being in a union
I don't know why it has to be part and parcel of being in a union. Let me make a comparison to Australia–in Australia, constitutional amendment referendums must be passed by both a majority of voters nationally and also a majority of states. So even if 52% of Australians nationally vote in favour of a constitutional amendment, if it fails to also get a majority in at least four of the six states, the amendment fails.
If the UK applied the same rule as Australia does–the UK doesn't have a written constitution like Australia does, but Brexit no doubt is an issue of constitutional level importance–then the Brexit referendum would have failed, since even though it got a national majority, it only passed in 2 of the 4 constituent countries.
Or, similarly, look at the US–constitutional amendments aren't passed by national referenda, rather by votes of states legislatures, but still 75% of states must approve, so a bare national majority in favour of a constitutional amendment is unlikely to be enough for its ratification.
So, David Cameron could have designed the Brexit referendum to require a double majority of national voters and constitutent countries, very similar to the Australian model, and somewhat similar to the US model, but he chose not to do that–and had he done that, Brexit would have failed. Healthy political unions tend to have strong mechanisms for protecting the rights of their smaller members, but the UK has basically non-existent mechanisms for doing this, and while the Brexit referendum could have been a good opportunity to start doing that, it didn't happen. So this isn't "part and parcel of being in a union" at all.
- Nursie 10y agoThe constituent countries don't have equal weighting though - there would be outrage if the popular vote had carried but the vast majority of the population ,who live in England, were overridden by small minorities. One person, one vote.
- matthewmacleod 10y agoOne person, one vote. I think the parent eloquently summed up why this isn't the ideal, though. Tyranny of the majority is still tyranny.
- Silhouette 10y agoThe trouble with that argument is that in a case of a straightforward binary decision, which is what was on offer, the only logical alternative to tyranny of the majority is some form of "tyranny of the minority", against which all the same criticisms would apply but stronger. This is a reasonable argument against having a simple binary decision in the first place, but of course that opens up plenty more scope for distorting the outcome. In an ideal world you'd find a consensus favoured by most and tolerable to all, but with such a complicated and divisive issue as the EU, that was always unlikely.
- Nursie 10y agoAre all democratic decision tyranny in your book? You're effectively arguing for votes in Scotland or NI to count for far, far more than those in England. You're also effectively arguing for tyranny of the minority and a recipe for stasis.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> So, David Cameron could have designed the Brexit referendum to require a double majority of national voters and constitutent countries I'm not sure he could have designed it to "require" anything, since after all it was a non-binding referendum, with which the government was free to do whatever it chose, and it's not clear that there is any basis for a binding referendum. The decision after the fact to treat the referendum as if it were a binding, simple-majority-rule, measure, OTOH, is ceetainly questionable.
- matthewmacleod 10y agoQuestionable, but it's hard to see how it would have been politically feasible to do otherwise. There is no such thing as a binding vote on parliament anyway, practically speaking.
- skissane 10y agoThe referendum legislation could have been drafted to contain a clause specifying in which situations it would have been "deemed to have passed". That clause could have contained the requirement for a double majority. Of course, being a non-binding referendum, such a clause could not have had any direct legal effect, but it would have been politically near-impossible to disregard. There is no logical contradiction between the idea of a referendum being legally non-binding and the idea of a referendum with a higher threshold for passing than "50%+1 nationally".
- Silhouette 10y agoThe decision after the fact to treat the referendum as if it were a binding, simple-majority-rule, measure, OTOH, is ceetainly questionable. There were plenty of questionable things about the referendum, but I really don't think this was one of them. If you look at Hansard during the debates on the enabling legislation, one MP after another spoke in terms of giving the people the final say, or words clearly to that effect. If you look at the official booklet, sent to every household in the UK by the government at taxpayers' expense, it too contained wording that clearly implied the people would decide. Personally I'm of the view that we need more direct democracy to fix our political systems rather than less, and I see little democratic legitimacy in arguments about Parliamentary sovereignty given the alternatives available to us today. So for me, whether or not I agree with the result, as a matter of principle I would have preferred the referendum to be absolutely legally binding anyway. But even if our most senior lawyers held that it was not, it seems quite clear that even before the vote the expectation both of Parliament and of the general public was that the referendum result should decide the matter.
- matthewmacleod 10y agoPoint taken - you are of course correct. I actually very much expected this to be part of the process, but it seems that overconfidence on the part of the Cameron government resulted in this decision not being taken. A move like this does tend to reinforce the perception that Westminster is "more important" than devolved administrations. I meant this more in the sense that I don't think the legitimacy of the outcome can be questioned constitutionally. Can you imagine the chaos in the U.K. had England voted to leave and Scotland and NI had prevented it, though? That would probably fracture the union faster!