9 ms·
Of course brexit arguments work for the SNP: the separatist language is universal, from Yugoslavia to Slovakia, from Sardinia to Catalonia, from Texas to Libya.
by toyg 10y ago
Of course brexit arguments work for the SNP: the separatist language is universal, from Yugoslavia to Slovakia, from Sardinia to Catalonia, from Texas to Libya... the big bad government far away is the root of all evil, "we" have to take back control, "they" oppress us, our tribe is different from their tribe...
It's always the same story: when you start talking about drawing lines, you give an excuse to anyone to look for differences, and because we're all different at some level, you don't know where it's going to end. Do we think people in Aberdeen and Glasgow are happy to be ruled by Edinburgh? That people in Manchester are happy to be taxed to build railways in London? Of course not. Egoistic tribalism is natural, and it scales down terribly well. You legitimise one level and soon enough you're fighting the same arguments three levels down: my town won't be ruled by your town! My district won't be ruled by your district! My street won't be ruled by your street!
This is what the British elites of all stripes have unleashed upon us, with their intolerance for progressive rules agreed in Bruxelles. We are running towards the ethnic conflicts of yore. Sad days.
- matthewmacleod 10y agoThat's a bit of a shallow argument. So long as one accepts the existence of nation states, one must accept that there are lines between them. The lines, then, are subject to change by political consent. Scotland voted strongly to remain in the EU, and despite this it will be leaving. That's obviously part and parcel of being in a union, but coming so soon after an independence referendum in which one of the key arguments was "voting for independence means leaving the EU" it seems pretty obvious why there would be disquiet. It's demonstrative of how difficult it is to have a political union where there is such wildly disproportionate power wielded by one member through the weight of population. I'm an absolute card-carrying supporter of Scottish independence. But honestly, I'd rather see genuine federalism in the UK to deal with the structural constitutional problems. However, there is no political will to make that happen, so it seems like a lost cause.
- skissane 10y ago> Scotland voted strongly to remain in the EU, and despite this it will be leaving. That's obviously part and parcel of being in a union I don't know why it has to be part and parcel of being in a union. Let me make a comparison to Australia–in Australia, constitutional amendment referendums must be passed by both a majority of voters nationally and also a majority of states. So even if 52% of Australians nationally vote in favour of a constitutional amendment, if it fails to also get a majority in at least four of the six states, the amendment fails. If the UK applied the same rule as Australia does–the UK doesn't have a written constitution like Australia does, but Brexit no doubt is an issue of constitutional level importance–then the Brexit referendum would have failed, since even though it got a national majority, it only passed in 2 of the 4 constituent countries. Or, similarly, look at the US–constitutional amendments aren't passed by national referenda, rather by votes of states legislatures, but still 75% of states must approve, so a bare national majority in favour of a constitutional amendment is unlikely to be enough for its ratification. So, David Cameron could have designed the Brexit referendum to require a double majority of national voters and constitutent countries, very similar to the Australian model, and somewhat similar to the US model, but he chose not to do that–and had he done that, Brexit would have failed. Healthy political unions tend to have strong mechanisms for protecting the rights of their smaller members, but the UK has basically non-existent mechanisms for doing this, and while the Brexit referendum could have been a good opportunity to start doing that, it didn't happen. So this isn't "part and parcel of being in a union" at all.
- Nursie 10y agoThe constituent countries don't have equal weighting though - there would be outrage if the popular vote had carried but the vast majority of the population ,who live in England, were overridden by small minorities. One person, one vote.
- matthewmacleod 10y agoOne person, one vote. I think the parent eloquently summed up why this isn't the ideal, though. Tyranny of the majority is still tyranny.
- flukus 10y ago> but coming so soon after an independence referendum in which one of the key arguments was "voting for independence means leaving the EU" it seems pretty obvious why there would be disquiet. I wonder how many people voted to leave the union on the basis that they would it mean leaving the EU as well?
- matthewmacleod 10y agoI can't find any numbers on that right now but I'm sure there's a YouGov poll that asks that question. I don't doubt that there are some, but I've yet to come across anybody with those views personally.
- toyg 10y ago> So long as one accepts the existence of nation states, one must accept that there are lines between them. But that is the point - we can not accept the existence of these lines anymore. The XX century brought nation-state principles to their logical ends - WWII, the atom bomb and the Iron Curtain. We are supposed to have moved on to a world of international cooperation, of supranational coordination, which is the only way we can tackle systemic issues like economic inequality and climate change. The commercial world is already there, industrial globalisation is a fact of life, but the political structures are lagging. The answer cannot be a nationalist backlash, there lies balkanization and a return to the bad old days of tribal wars. Note that this is not an attack on Scottish independence - there is an argument for "national" rule to be on a smaller scale than what we inherited from the XIX/XX century, especially in the internet age where industrial scale is relatively less important than it was. And absolutely the UK should be reorganised (the North of England has similar grievances - heck, anyone outside of London has). But the language of separatism is a dangerous djinni and it's really hard to put it back in the bottle without significant casualties.
- analog31 10y agoIt's my impression, from a distance, that the sentiment in Scotland is anti-Brexit, and is in favor of remaining with the EU. That would seem to cloud the issue of whether this is a "separatist" movement.
- matthewmacleod 10y agoIt's definitely a separatist movement, although it does come across as a loaded term. Scotland was resoundingly anti-brexit. This situation is worsened given the 2014 vote against independence was decided at least in part around arguments that leaving the U.K. would mean leaving the EU - for a subsequent vote to remain to be essentially ignored as a result of a UK wide referendum has likely done little to reassure Scotland that Westminster takes it seriously.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> Of course brexit arguments work for the SNP: the separatist language is universal The thing to keep in mind is that the SNP wants to take the country out of the Union, but not out of the European Union. In fact, that's the entire justification behind the second referendum- that they stayed in the UK because they wanted to remain within the EU, but, now that the UK is exiting anyway there's nothing keeping them back from leaving the UK and trying to re-negotiate their relationship with the EU on their own. I mean, for separatists they seem to be very keen on remaining in a union and they seem to have a very different idea of "independence" than the kind of "independence" the Leave campaign propounded during the runup to the Brexit referendum. There's something else going on here and not just a reactionary isolationism and nationalism. I'm thinking that the Scots are just fed up with the way the English have been running the UK in the last couple of decades and if that's the case I can't really blame them. There's something truly rotten in Westminster.