34 ms·
Evidence That Robots Are Winning the Race for American Jobs
- yardie 10y agoIt's interesting to note that with all this automation the cost of some products hasn't gone down at all. I was recently pricing out a new, mid-size car. Once all the options I wanted were priced in it was in the upper 20s. And this was your standard JA/KOR sedan. Consumer electronics, which has also increasingly automated, has gone down in price in some cases dramatically. People are losing their jobs in the name of efficiency through automation. But that isn't being passed onto the buyers.
- maxxxxx 10y agoCar manufacturers are not that profitable so the question is: Where do the gains from automation go?
- speeder 10y agoI am from Brazil... here car manufacturers are wildly profitable, it is not uncommon for some models be sold to final costumers with profit margins after taxes of around 30, 40%. EDIT: also in US in recent years, C-level people had income increases of around 1000%, and mid-level execs of 475%... so lots of money ended in their pockets, many companies that make no profits make no profits because most of what could been profits were used to pay outrageous amounts of money to a small handful of people.
- hellogoodbyeeee 10y agoThe car you are buying for $25k today is a lot nicer than the car you would've bought for $25k ten years ago. It is more fuel efficient, safer, and will last longer not to mention it likely comes with features that were completely unheard of a decade ago.
- treehau5 10y agoMaybe true with cars, but what about consumer electronics? HVAC systems? Wireless routers? Furniture even? Even clothes. It's all cheap garbage, inflated and marked up.
- pdelbarba 10y agoI can design a wireless router as a side project. I've built my own furniture for fun. I don't think I have the resources to start a car manufacturing line... When the barrier to entry is high, there's no reason to lower prices.
- cr0sh 10y agoActually, the barrier to entry to build a car isn't that high - it only appears that way. Most of the parts - if not all - are available. All one really needs is the knowledge (internet), the tools ($$$), and the space ($$$$) to build. I have a friend whose father is in his 70s, who builds custom VW vehicles; one of his last vehicles used a shortened chassis and the cab from an old electric truck (might've been a Cushman). He finished that one, and is moving on to another. Plenty of people fabricate rally cars and sand rails using tubular steel and fairly simple tools (tube bender, a notcher, mig welder, grinder, plasma cutter or torch, etc). In many cases one can do this all in their garage (but it is better to have a more dedicated space). Engines tend toward the VW end of things, but nothing says you have to use such an engine; there are plenty of new and used engines and sub-frames to work from. I've considered building something similar to this flatpack truck: http://oxgvt.com/the-ox-all-terrain-vehicle/ http://oxgvt.com/the-ox-all-terrain-vehicle/ I figure that the parts from an old VW Vanagon could provide most of it; that or use some front-wheel drive vehicle, then build the cab-over part. The only real compromise on all of this would be the safety aspect; pretty much any home-brew vehicle is going to be a likely death trap in a real accident, but that is outside the argument of being able build one. There's also the issue of registration and insurance, but this too can be overcome (at least here in the United States - other countries may be more or less lenient/easy to do this). The information is out there to build a vehicle, and fairly cheap too. You just have to be willing to get your hands dirty (and suffer some injuries - it seems any kind of automotive work requires a blood sacrifice, not unlike PC repair).
- pdq 10y agoNonsense. Cars are more efficient than ever, have more features than ever, and in general as reliable as ever. You cannot just look at the bottom line price and make conclusions that cars are getting more expensive and automation is just adding profits to the manufacturers.
- yardie 10y agoAnd why not? Most sensible people start with a budget and work their way from there. So yes, the price is absolutely a factor. All things being equal if the factory line is becoming more automated then where is the money being spent. It's not being spent in labor, it's not being passed back to consumers, the price of commodities has been relatively stable (steel, plastics, glass).
- lostlogin 10y ago> Cars are more efficient than ever. And a lot of that turned out to be crap. The efficiency seems to be improving, but it's not at a particularly impressive rate. Pretty match every other aspect of cars seems to have improved more. My personal favourite is the button that raises windows right up or right down at an extra hard press. I'm happy with that feature, so form opinions with that in mind.
- Glyptodon 10y agoI agree that there seems to be a definite gap in car pricing: things such as the divide of bulb vs. LED brake lights within a single model between trim levels seem less like actual cost adjustment and more like putting crappy stuff in the down-segment trims for the sake of upselling. I'm not sure what margins are "supposed" to be on cars, but I do think there's something weird going on with the models, features, and market segmenting.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoI'm fairly certain cars, like the iPhone, are in large part about signalling status, and this accounts for some weirdness in the market. It might be worth looking at delivery vans instead though even there I've noticed a weird thing recently where traditional auto makers have outright refused to build hybrid or EV trucks, and large organisations have just built their own instead and managed to do so cheaper and better than dedicated manufacturers just by putting together off-the-shelf parts. That seems odd to me, maybe the automakers are distorted by their consumer market?
- newyankee 10y agoSteve Mnuchin said that this is not even on the radar for the US govt.
- benevol 10y agoWell, it's pretty obvious to most people by now that the US is currently on a sinking path (the threat coming from within).
- Animats 10y agoThat says a lot about Steve Mnuchin. He should know better. He used to be a hedge fund manager. There are now hedge funds run by AI programs. They're doing better than the average hedge fund.[1] By the time his term at Treasury is over, his job may be obsolete. [1] http://www.valuewalk.com/2017/01/ai-hedge-fund-returns/ http://www.valuewalk.com/2017/01/ai-hedge-fund-returns/
- Glyptodon 10y agoOne aspect I don't ever see discussed is whether it's moral or abusive for people to perform jobs that don't respect their capacities as a human being. If your job is to follow a script 60 times an hour without deviation is your job one that humans should be permitted to do? Or is it an abuse? If your job is to ignore circumstances and human empathy is it a job humans should be permitted to do? Or is it an abuse? If an abuse is what permits survival should it be embraced or scorned? I'm not sure what the answer is, but I think at the very least there's a clear way to look on things with human eyes and a human perspective.
- flippyhead 10y ago> Or is it an abuse? It's not like slave labor or something, in theory they could quit, get more education or whatever, and find a different job. Hard to see at-will employment as an abuse by the employer.
- clock_tower 10y agoIn theory they could quit and educate up, but in practice they often can't -- especially if they're tied (primarily by family) to some languishing/backwards part of the country.
- dvtv75 10y agoSome of us are highly educated, and are still forced to take the bottom line work-or-starve jobs.
- hutzlibu 10y agoBut not in IT, right? The cases of high education/low pay I know of, are in liberal arts.
- ctdonath 10y agoI have grave doubts about "can't" in most cases. I've picked up & moved 1000 miles on a whim with no job lined up on arrival, and wasn't keen on severing ties in the process - so yes I've a clue about it. You'd be hard-pressed to find such "can't" cases. Turning on a TV (colloquially speaking) at all is a disqualifying factor. There's a free lending library, there's free Internet access, there's free job-placement services. Suck it up & make it happen, or quit complaining. Never before in history has so much job opportunity been so available to so many so easily; it's not trivial mind you, but the alternative for most who ever lived was to start digging & planting. I've been following David Hines on Twitter as he documents people & regions you're referring to. A recurring takeaway (which he doesn't intend) is your assertion, which is people choosing to stay in such circumstances because they choose family & familiarity over prosperity. The USA was founded & settled by people who took the "move" imperative seriously; when doing so now takes just a few days' pay and a few hours comfortable transport instead of months of hard covered-wagon travel which was long the norm, I find it hard to sympathize. Cultures which value status quo over productivity improvement can't thrive.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- meri_dian 10y agoPeople don't need to work at 9-5 jobs to be happy, so I don't worry about automation from an existential point of view. There are numerous retired people who can attest to this. Now, many of them say they value their retirements precisely because they worked for decades in pursuit of retirement, but this idea is contradicted by the Ancient Greeks. Athens had an extremely high slave to citizen ratio. I've read that the average citizen (a more exclusive category then than now but still) owned 7 slaves. The result of this was that most privileged Athenians didn't really have to work. Their days consisted of haggling and gossiping in the market, working out in the gymnasium, attending lectures and getting drunk with friends at symposiums (house parties). It's what they were used to. Now, will the average citizen enjoy such a life in a fully automated world or will they just live in perpetual poverty buffered only by barely sufficient handouts of food and other basic goods needed for survival? That's a more pressing question.
- 3pt14159 10y agoThere is a difference between existing without end and self-actualization. Greek citizens were the dominant class of the dominant civilization. They have more in common with software developers than with welfare or disability recipients. I don't think it's all gloom and doom ahead, but I do think we're going to need to substantially up the intelligence of the average human if we want to exist in a future that doesn't look like constant monster truck shows and house parties.
- IIIIIIIIIIII 10y ago> They have more in common with software developers than with welfare or disability recipients. That was the point of the argument: Will people be the winners and robots the "slaves", or will there be only a few capital owners owning (the fruits of the labors of) not a handful of slaves each, but millions of those modern "slaves" and most people none?
- ajmurmann 10y agoWell there also is the other aspect of personal fulfillment that I think the parent was trying to touch on. I personally have plenty of creative things I'd love to do if I wouldn't have to worry about money. For example I'd love to do significantly more ceramics work, build a video game, explore some glass blowing and maybe even get a economics degree for fun. Others might get depressed and just watch reality TV all day or even develop a drug dependency. Our society is currently very much coupling self worth to career success.
- abandonliberty 10y agoJust used a robot to mail a parcel at the post office. Automatically weighs and sizes the item, takes payment, prints a label, and accepts parcel drop off. A happy employee came to check if I needed any help with the new technology. Knowing the robot I just interacted with was going to replace their employment was sobering. I couldn't figure out what to say. The robots are coming to services.
- YZF 10y agoMany years later the self-checkout machines at Home Depot still have employees supervising them so not everyone is replaced. There are also still regular checkout lines. Possibly without automation the post office would lose business to FedEx. Maybe lower costs would increase business and add more jobs somewhere else in the pipeline. This isn't a zero sum game.
- abandonliberty 10y agoFunny that you would say that considering that the OP argues that it's a negative sum game, both for unemployment and earnings.
- thinkloop 10y agoPrices have little to do with costs. The iphone, for example, costs $800 every year because this is the optimal price to sell a premium phone at. They build the phone to be $800, not the other way around. If costs go down in a way that the competition can't replicate, that becomes more profit for apple, not a lower price. If automation reduces costs industry-wide, companies will often/likely add more features and services (i.e. better chip in the iphone) to compete at that optimal price that they previously discovered.
- lostlogin 10y agoThis isn't quite correct - the iPhone slips down a rung after a year and becomes less expensive. Same phone lower price. Sure, the top tier gets refilled, but it isn't the same item.
- ptero 10y agoSome jobs are always being automated away (looms taking away weaver's jobs, etc.). This can be very painful for the affected, but often benefits the society in the long term. We could use more teachers instead of conveyor belt workers and janitors (to train for new skills). And more custom builders, physical therapists and nurses (aging population), etc. IMO instead of lament automation taking jobs (at least those that we would not want our own kids to do) we should improve the learning and training options to make those affected employable elsewhere. Not BS 1-day clinics "how to write your resume", but longer full time technical or human skills classes and workshops to improve on skills in demand today. And maybe beef up the safety net, especially on the medical side. Do not fight progress, leverage it for good causes.
- TheAdamAndChe 10y agoTwo points: 1) Not everyone has the aptitude, desire, or willingness to get a highly technical job. Those people should not suffer. 2) The pay of all positions are based off of supply and demand. If everyone has a degree in radiology, the pay for being a radiologist would drop a lot. This can be seen in tech. Tech support positions in rural areas require bachelors degrees, yet pay less and less per year($12/hr in my city).
- lordCarbonFiber 10y agoYour first point rubs me the wrong way. The implicit assumption is "there exists some lesser class of humans incapable of doing the work we do". All of my experience, every success of outreach programs bringing new people to tech, everything we know about the distribution of IQ suggests that it's not the case. There is plenty of room in the future economy for more knowledge workers and we shouldn't be making the assumption that people should let their mind rot doing work better suited for machines.
- cblock811 10y agoTo his point, if they don't have the desire or willingness...that's an issue. Just because he called out that some people aren't going to work out in tech doesnt mean he is assigning them to a lesser class. I certainly dont have the aptitude, desire, or willingness to be many things. Doesnt mean I think I'm less of a person for it.
- d--b 10y agoOk, so now that it's clear that robots are taking over the low-skill jobs. Can we talk about inequality in the US?
- balozi 10y agoAre there jobs at any skill level that are immune to automation?
- lacampbell 10y agoWho started this Robots are Stealing our Jobs narrative? I feel like it's not a coincidence that in the past few years everyone has been talking about it, despite automation increasing apace for the past century or so. Who's behind it, and who benefits? UBI proponents?
- Namrog84 10y agoBecause it's while it has been happening and even accelerating for the last century(and longer), it is only now hitting a threshold/momentum in the past few years. We are now standing at a precipice of a substantial amount of people being automated with unlikelihood of them going somewhere else. Although predictions are unreliable, there is strong evidence that there isn't just going to be "more jobs somewhere else", like has happened in the past when things were automated or optimized (e.g. farming) UBI discussions and increasing proponents are an outcome of this, not the other way around.
- jhallenworld 10y agoI would think that robots are stealing Mexican/Chinese/Vietnamese jobs provided by American companies or contractors. This is not good: these jobs help raise the standard of living in these countries.
- onmobiletemp 10y agoThe whole discussion we have is silly. Robots and ai will kill jobs. Sorry but the concept of everyone becoming a programmer or roboticist is a fucking pipe dream. Some people are simply not cut out for it. Even if everyone was perfectly educated, there is no demand for that many people in those kinds of positions and there never will be. Weve already gotton a taste of automation from people doing any work at all for cheaper overseas. The result has been for people to get psychology degrees and other easy degrees and go on to get bullshit jobs in the swelling, fractured and broken systems of beurocracy that are now so common in the west. Why do schools need such huge adminiatrations? They dont. They got huge because people need work and not everyone can be a stem major. So the answer is obvious in my eyes. Sooner or later we will have universal basic income. It depends on how long the overburdened sources of business and psychology degree jobs can hold out before collapsing i suppose.
- Jabanga 10y agoYou will not need to become a programmer or roboticist to have a job, anymore than you have to be a mechanic or factory worker to have a job today. Assuming we don't have human-like AI, there will be vast numbers of tasks that only humans will be able to do.
- BrandonMarc 10y agoVast numbers? Will? What job category is increasing in demand today, and with no foreseeable threat from robots in the near future? Tell me about today, and I'll believe your prediction for the future.
- drvdevd 10y agoPerhaps we at Hacker News are prone to acceptance of the idea that our own skill sets are the ones that will remain when automation burns everyone else's. Personally, I doubt it. If I'm being honest with myself, I'd have to say there is nothing I can do that a machine couldn't do better.
- 10y ago
- nubbins 10y agoPeople ask me why are you learning programming when you already have another career, and I feel like I'm Noah building an ark
- known 10y agoWho'll decide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Work%E2%80%93life_balance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Work%E2%80%93life_balance
- Mendenhall 10y agoI see lots of posts about running out of jobs because of automation in the future. Dont worry you know whats coming that always gives people something to work on? war.
- demonshalo 10y agopretty much!
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoSorry to tell you that they'll automate that too. Which has some chilling implications when the unemployed riot. Historically this has led to soldiers shooting down their fellow countrymen. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peterloo_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peterloo_Massacre But I guess once it's automated that's going to increase the likelihood.
- mehaveaccount 10y agoThe 800 pound gorilla that we never see discussed when talking about AI taking American jobs is how much immigration is exacerbating the problem. Whether we are trying to distribute the jobs available or whether we are distributing govt handouts/ basic income, immigration always and only increases the difficulty of both the jobs and the govt benefits sides of that discussion.