3 ms·
Murderous?
by briandear 10y ago
Murderous?
- Mithaldu 10y agoPence particularly caused a HIV outbreak: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/mike-pence-indiana-hiv_us_57f53b9be4b002a7312022ef http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/mike-pence-indiana-hiv_u... And for the rest: Anyone who wants to remove Obamacare without having a more inclusive plan ready.
- BeetleB 10y ago>Pence particularly caused a HIV outbreak: I read the article, and I'm sorry, I do not think you know the meaning of the word "cause". He did not cause any outbreak. Not providing help is not going to cause anyone to suffer. What causes people to suffer are other factors (for HIV, it's usually unprotected sex, careless intermingling of blood, etc). Refusing assistance doesn't cause people to die. The disease kills them. Now if you make a case that Pence was directly involved in infecting them, then yes, he caused it. Assistance is exactly what it is: It is help. My refusing to help someone does not mean I caused his misery. Nor is it punishment, another word often used in these situations. While I disagree with Pence's actions, I can also point out false allegations made against him.
- Mithaldu 10y agoI said he caused an outbreak. Yes, he did not personally infect anybody, however he removed the testing, and he acted directly in delaying aid that would've kept it under control, thus allowing it to become an outbreak. Being responsible for one's inaction is a thing, especially so when one is in a position whose job description it is to be responsible for such things. If you're a chicken farmer and you fail to feed your chickens, then you did cause your chickens to starve. E: Thanks for the reply though. It was fascinatingly insightful for me.
- BeetleB 10y ago>I said he caused an outbreak. And I still disagree. He refused to prevent one. >Being responsible for one's inaction is a thing, Yes, he is responsible for his inactions. Nevertheless, he did not cause an outbreak. >If you're a chicken farmer and you fail to feed your chickens, then you did cause your chickens to starve. I'm afraid not. I can be held responsible for not feeding them, but I did not starve them (unless I prevented them from getting food by confining them). Sorry, but my goal is not to be obtuse or difficult. When this usage of the world causes problems with people sympathetic to your view, you can understand its ineffectiveness in convincing anyone of your perspective. If I were organizing a campaign to convince Indiana voters not to reelect him (assuming he were not the VP), I would exclude people with your rhetoric. It will cause people to side with him more.
- Mithaldu 10y agoThe reality of the matter is that as governor he has a moral obligation to keep all of his citizens as safe as possible. He, at one point, chose to reduce the safety of his citizens, and at another chose not to protect his citizens. These choices of his directly led to the outbreak. Whether you are unhappy about this reality being stated is no concern of mine, since, as stated elsewhere, nothing i can say will actually have an effect on the situation. I'm just a dude who's watching a country prepare to send multiple of his friends to the chopping block just because they had the misfortune of being born in a place where "socialist" is an insult.
- BeetleB 10y ago>The reality of the matter is that as governor he has a moral obligation to keep all of his citizens as safe as possible. And by that criterion, every governor has failed. >Whether you are unhappy about this reality being stated is no concern of mine, since, as stated elsewhere, nothing i can say will actually have an effect on the situation. So you are saying all this because...? >I'm just a dude who's watching a country prepare to send multiple of his friends to the chopping block just because they had the misfortune of being born in a place where "socialist" is an insult. I'm failing to understand your perspective. I'll ask the same question: You felt the need to write that because...?
- codesuela 10y agohumans have more agency than chickens