3 ms·
I think this claim would be more credible if there were the any other characteristics of a religion present. Namely: Doctrine, rituals, totems, prayer, and abov
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
I think this claim would be more credible if there were the any other characteristics of a religion present. Namely: Doctrine, rituals, totems, prayer, and above all it would require that there is some credulity to a higher power/state such as heaven/nirvana that will never be seen by humans.
I'd be interested to see some of those as I haven't yet and I've been in the community for a while.
What I will grant is that, there are those who speak in the same structure as religious people. "In the future there will be no poverty because machines will make everything we need for free" sounds a little too close to "In heaven, you can eat all you want and never get full!"
However similar they sound though, they have radically different theoretical roots.
In fact though there is plenty of hard evidence for progress on all of the accounts you mentioned:
AGI: https://arxiv.org/abs/1701.08734 https://arxiv.org/abs/1701.08734
Immortality: http://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-have-successfully-reversed-dna-ageing-in-mice#.WNYB21wBK5I.facebook http://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-have-successfully-rev...
mind uploading: Not sure about Whole Brain Emulation progress right off the top of my head.
genetic enhancement: http://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-reverse-sickle-cell-disease-for-the-first-time-using-gene-therapy http://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-reverse-sickle-cell-d...
Are they solved? Not by a long shot. Do we know when they will be? Of course not. There is progress though.
As far as I know, nobody is making hard progress on when Jesus is coming back.
- throwanem 10y ago> I'd be interested to see some of those as I haven't yet and I've been in the community for a while. Never been to Less Wrong, eh?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI've been to Less Wrong though, and this is not the place to look for transhumanist-as-a-religion believers. Calling LW a cult is a stupid meme based on ingroup/outgroup thinking and a few cases where they may have got carried away too far with considering logical implications of the theories they were developing.
- lawless123 10y ago>I think this claim would be more credible if there were the any other characteristics of a religion present. Namely: Doctrine, rituals, totems, prayer, and above all it would require that there is some credulity to a higher power/state such as heaven/nirvana that will never be seen by humans. It doesn't have those, but it does need lots of money, just like religion. Not that i'm against the idea
- Ygg2 10y ago> Namely: Doctrine, rituals, totems, prayer, and above all it would require that there is some credulity to a higher power/state such as heaven/nirvana that will never be seen by humans. The Doctrine: Belief in the Singularity. The Rituals: Writing talks about Singularity. Totems: Arguably this is the lacking part. The Prayers: Their talks about Singularity.
- marvin 10y agoThis is a pretty strained analogy. I consider it likely that smarter-than-human (*more capable of achieving goals) AI will at some point become possible and cause very unpredictable but hopefully directable results. So presumably that makes me a secular-religious nut by your estimation, but I don't observe any of the religious customs you specify above. Perhaps the first, if you use a wide definition. It would be more interesting if the criticism of transhumanist ideas explained why these ideas are unlikely or impossible, rather than dismiss them with the quasi-ad hominem of comparing them to religious ideas that are either outright wrong, or completely outdated in their real-world impact.