3 ms·
On a facsimile reading of the text, it's pretty clear that Kraft has the upper hand. However, there are two wrinkles. First, the elephant in the room is patent
by jcranmer 10y ago
On a facsimile reading of the text, it's pretty clear that Kraft has the upper hand. However, there are two wrinkles.
First, the elephant in the room is patent trolls and East Texas. It's pretty much the only reason that anyone cares about the case, and SCOTUS did explicitly ask Kraft if it should matter. The response was that Congress can do a better job.
The more important wrinkle, though, is that the law was amended and an intervening case (VE Holding), not held by the SCOTUS (and thus not binding precedent to SCOTUS) more or less overturns Fourco in its interpretation of the relevant text. This opens up room for unclear interpretation of the text, at which point legislative intent comes into play--and the legislative intent isn't exactly helpful. Kraft argues that the changes to the law in 2011 were meant to clarify the definitions of residency based on the ALI report--but the ALI report also recommended deleting 1400(b) (which is causing the confusion), which Congress did not do.
In the oral arguments, TC Heartland doesn't seem to me to have defended its interpretation well. It basically requires holding that VE Holding was bad case law and overturning 30 years of assumed precedent--which SCOTUS tends to be reluctant to do. On the other hand, TC Heartland did make a fairly compelling case that adopting its interpretation wouldn't bring down the end of the world for the judicial system. Kraft also seems to have slipped up in their defense--but, having the better prior case, it's not so problematic.
Basically, what it comes down to is if East Texas is worth influencing the decision process. There is ample judicial cover for deciding the case in either direction, although the narrow-venue case is somewhat more tortured.