4 ms·
It also raises another good question: how big of a fool would you have to be to take the job Gurley and the board are trying to fill? How do you rein in a CEO w
by smacktoward 10y ago
It also raises another good question: how big of a fool would you have to be to take the job Gurley and the board are trying to fill? How do you rein in a CEO who has total, unchallengeable control of the company?
(Maybe if they offer enough money, it's worth it even if it's a suicide mission? Though "just cash the checks and wait for your inevitable dismissal" doesn't seem like an attractive offer for anyone who's good enough to have alternatives.)
- twblalock 10y agoIn situations like this, in which an executive is hired to reform a company and is set against entrenched management and culture, golden parachutes seem entirely justified to me.
- Arizhel 10y agoI'm not so sure. Wouldn't it be better for society overall if these companies were condemned to die by their own hand, instead of being able to be saved by an outsider? If they're saved, then all the people who participated in creating this toxic culture are rewarded. If the company goes belly-up, then any valuable assets can be bought by other firms for pennies on the dollar, and those and other competing, and hopefully better-run firms will have a shot at success, with this toxic company cleared out of the market and leaving a void.
- smallgovt 10y agoI'm not following. Are you proposing that companies should not be allowed to hire someone from the outside to fix severe culture issues? The problem with such a policy is the mechanism through which we'd determine which companies are condemned. From your comment, I gather that if it were up to you, you'd sentence Uber to death instead of giving them a shot at redemption. You wouldn't be alone in this perspective, but I think you're overlooking the thousands of GOOD people that would be adversely affected and punished by such a decision. All to punish a couple people you believe to be evil.
- Arizhel 10y ago>Are you proposing that companies should not be allowed to hire someone from the outside to fix severe culture issues? Not exactly, just that they shouldn't be able to offer them generous golden parachutes. Of course, I'm not so sure about the legality of this, but perhaps within corporate law a law could be made that companies aren't allowed to promise enormous sums of money to people when they fail to fix the problem, and the company is now in dire financial straits. When the company is having severe financial difficulty, the first dibs should go to anyone it owes money to, not someone they promised a big golden parachute to in case he couldn't turn it around. >I gather that if it were up to you, you'd sentence Uber to death instead of giving them a shot at redemption. Absolutely. The good people should have found new jobs by now; all accounts now show this company to be truly toxic, at many levels (not just "a couple people"). They should not be rewarded with a shot at redemption. Now, if they can find someone willing to take on this challenge of turning the company around, who is willing to assume a great deal of risk in doing so (at least risk not getting paid much for it), then that's fine. I just don't think they should be allowed to offer a golden parachute if that person fails. Then, such people can evaluate such offers based on the true risk of the situation, instead of knowing they'll be safely off with their golden parachute if they can't make it work.
- smallgovt 10y agoThanks for clarifying. The negative impact of such a decision wouldn't just be on Uber employees, but also the 500,000 drivers actively using their app; on average making $30K per year. A large fraction of these people are probably depending solely on this income to make ends meet. In an ideal world, there'd be an immediate replacement for Uber for all these drivers to switch over. However, we all know that's wishful thinking. At best, capacity would only be halved, which still means you'd effectively be letting go of 250K people tomorrow. Imo, even if your goal is to enact maximum punishment on Travis and Co, doing so THROUGH punishing the company is a really destructive way to accomplish said task.
- Arizhel 10y agoYou think Uber drivers can't just switch to the competition at the drop of a hat? Lots of them already work for both Uber and Lyft at the same time! They're the absolute last people I'm worried about hurting here. There are other "ride-sharing" companies out there, you know. And when Uber is clearly going down the drain, more competitors will pop up in anticipation of taking advantage of the situation.
- nebabyte 10y agoYeah, it sounds like nearly a nearly textbook definition of one of the problems capitalism (and a "free market" with low barriers to entry) are supposed to solve. You don't challenge someone's control of their company, you just challenge the company. "Good" employees and customers who object to their culture jump ship to yours; "bad" employees go down with the ship. Of course, because of the innumerable real-world confounds to the model (not least of which is the artificial-or-otherwise high barrier to entry that most industries seek to ensconce themselves in), this doesn't happen anywhere else, but at least here with novel companies competing in their early stages, I don't see why anyone would bother "saving" a company that will be dragging against you every step of the way you can just invest in one of its competitors and let that dragging force drag your competition down, to your advantage. If the "capitalism will save us" model can't succeed here of all places, I don't know why people still bother with it anymore.
- maxerickson 10y agoThere's practically a limitless supply of people that would do it for $10 million. The problem is finding someone worth paying that much (and the pretense that whether someone is worth paying that much can be determined ahead of time).