3 ms·
HN Request: Creative Commons for comment text
Currently HN comments have no license, which means they can't be included in http://hackermonthly.com/ unless explicit permission is sought for every comment.
If HN applied the Creative Commons Attribution license to comment text (by adding a notice to the comment submission form) then comments could be republished in Hacker Monthly, and in general it just seems like the Right Thing. Any concerns or reasons why this isn't a good idea?
- cscotta 16y agoIt's an interesting idea, but honestly, I find any boilerplate claim to ownership of content posted on a site or imposition of a license, well, frustrating. The magazine is fantastic and I completely support it, but I do think this should be an opt-in. Perhaps it would be easier for commenters who wouldn't mind their work being published elsewhere to just drop a note like "All comments licensed CC/NC/SA" in their profile? (I've dropped this in mine).
- modeless 16y agoIANAL, but by posting here you necessarily give HN an implicit license to distribute your comment, roughly equivalent to the legal boilerplate you'd find on YouTube or similar ("worldwide, non-exclusive, royalty-free license to redistribute, perform," etc). I don't think making it explicit with Creative Commons would be an "imposition". Creative Commons wouldn't give HN or anyone else ownership of your comment. Opt-in wouldn't solve the problem for Hacker Monthly, as few people would bother. Opt-out would be fine. BTW, CC/NC precludes inclusion in Hacker Monthly as it is sold and contains advertisements.
- csmeder 16y agoI agree an opt out option would be best. Basically under each comment box a text that says: >> By posting here you are making your text available under the Creative Commons Attribution license. If you wish to not provide your text under the Attribution license please check here. To not see this message again check here. (you can change these settings in your profile at any time). >>
- DanielStraight 16y agoI am not a lawyer. HN cannot apply the Creative Commons Attribution license to our comments. HN does not own our comments. We do. We are implicitly granting a license to HN to store and display our comments, but we are not implicitly granting HN a right to re-license our comments. HN needs to specifically ask for our permission in order to license our comments under a CC license, just like Wikipedia does with its content. It's not enough to just say that the comments are licensed under CC. This is what StackOverflow does, and it's ridiculous. Let's not have the same thing here. I would be more than happy to license my comments under a CC license, but I would not be happy at all if someone else thought they had the right to do it for me. Conclusion: Be like Wikipedia, not StackOverflow.
- modeless 16y agoOf course HN can't retroactively relicense existing comments, and that's not what I'm suggesting.
- DanielStraight 16y agoWhat I said was not restricted to retroactively applying a license. HN cannot automatically apply a license to new content either. It was at first unclear to me how you meant for HN to apply the license. It seems clear now that the intention is that users would have to explicitly grant HN permission. This is good, and I'm all for it. It does need to be clear though that users are explicitly granting permission. And I agree with others that an opt-out is definitely a good idea.