4 ms·
I'm a layman in this space but I've been thinking about the idea of numbers a lot, mainly for fictional world-building, how aliens may use them, and wondering i
by Razengan 10y ago
I'm a layman in this space but I've been thinking about the idea of numbers a lot, mainly for fictional world-building, how aliens may use them, and wondering if they really are universal..
One of the things that strikes me, is how we just started with integers and then tried to fit everything into them. I mean they're fine for counting, but kind of a hackjob for measuring. Like sure, integers may exist in reality insofar as there may be one tree, two trees... but what about weight, speed, gravitational acceleration?
An alien species may use entirely different systems for Counting vs. Measuring.
We even found out that numbers may be "complex", have multiple dimensions. Beings exitsting in 4+ spatial dimensions may "write" in 3D; using Platonic solids to represent integers and fractions, and spheres for measurements?
And just as how humans took a while to come up with the concept of zero, could such a hypothetical 4D being have a hard time thinking about the idea of 1?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 10y agoAh I meant 1D. My thought train at the time was occupied with our writing systems being 2D.
- thanatropism 10y agoSo, that's the whole thing about manifolds. A (hollow) circle lives in 2D space, but is actually one-dimensional. How so? I can continuously map it to two 1D structures, one straight line for the top part and one straight line for the bottom part. Now, there are moments (such as a cursive "e", for example) where our line crosses itself (so there's a point in two different "regions" of the line), so we can't say that all cursive writing is 1D. But it's darn close to being so. What's more: even though our characters are darn-close-to-being-1D, the text we write with them is 1-dimensional. Some concrete poetry has tried to be two-dimensional, to little effect, but we mostly have sequential thoughts and a sequential language -- and only 1D structures can be sequential.
- Razengan 10y ago> even though our characters are darn-close-to-being-1D I assume you meant 2D there. I kind of get what you're saying. What about Chinese/Japanese characters, surely they're not 1-dimensional? Our vision is still 2D though, with the sensation of depth being provided in the processing layer. What might actual 2-dimensional or 3-dimensional "text" be like? Say written by 4D beings with 3D eyes. [0] (the primary topic on this page being systems that we may not relate to, comprehend, or even imagine, after all.) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four-dimensional_space#Visual_scope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four-dimensional_space#Visual_...
- thanatropism 10y ago> I assume you meant 2D there. I kind of get what you're saying. If you were to remove the exact point of overlap in our cursive "e", we would have a 1D structure, even if a discontinuous one. And it would still be legible as an "e". This is what I mean by "darn close": infinitesimally so. I haven't thought this through, but probabily every character in a legible sans serif point can be subject to this removal-of-overlaps process and still remain legible. As for Japanese: katakana seems reducible to 1D by the same criteria; hiragana is certainly not, let alone ideograms (kanji/hanzi in chinese).
- thanatropism 10y agoRiemannian geometry is a geometry on differentiable structures (manifolds) equipped with a "metric tensor" that generalizes the idea of a length to curved shapes. Symplectic geometry is, similarly, a geometry on differentiable manifolds equipped with a "symplectic form" that generalizes the oriented area spanned by two vectors known in flat structures as the determinant. Now here's the fun part: Riemannian geometry may exist in 1, 2, 3... dimensions; but symplectic geometry exists in even dimensions only. For example: if you tried to think of a 3D sphere of radius 1, you couldn't pass a 4D sphere through its largest section (a bit like if you couldn't pass a 3D sphere through a circle-shaped hole of same radius. I forget what was my point initially.
- Razengan 10y ago> a bit like if you couldn't pass a 3D sphere through a circle-shaped hole of same radius. So a funny thing happened. When my eyes first skimmed over that part, I spotted the word "donut". When I read it a second later, it wasn't there. Something in my brain literally substituted "donut" for "circle-shaped hole" to the extent that it appeared in my vision, for a single processing cycle.
- shuzchen 10y agoWhat value is there in counting "one tree, two trees" given you have small trees, large trees, new trees, dead trees, and trees of different species? You can't substitute any given "two trees" with any other "two trees", much less practically substitute any individual person with another. I can easily imagine an alien culture that highly internalizes individuality and thus finds no need to apply an arbitrary value (count) to any group.
- Razengan 10y agoThat's very interesting; imagining beings that effortlessly "name" or label everything individually..if that's what you're saying. The idea still needs a bit of fleshing out to count for cases when you're working with hundreds of practically identical things, e.g. cells and atoms.