3 ms·
This makes me wonder: is there a specific advantage in us being able to see the specific wavelengths we see or is it just a random thing and we would be fine if
by maxxxxx 10y ago
This makes me wonder: is there a specific advantage in us being able to see the specific wavelengths we see or is it just a random thing and we would be fine if we could see only other wavelengths like UV or infrared?
- Robotbeat 10y agoVisible is pretty smack dab in the middle of the Sun's peak spectrum: http://plantphys.info/plant_physiology/images/solarlight.gif http://plantphys.info/plant_physiology/images/solarlight.gif And there are other constraints, too. UV is blocked by water (and our lens material) and can induce chemical changes (read: damage) easier than visible light. Damaging sensitive retina. Not that this is an unsolvable problem (bees see UV), but it is a biochemical constraint. Infrared, especially far infrared, doesn't work too well without a cooled sensor. And the energy per quanta is less, which reduces your options for good, high-sensitivity biomolecules that can detect them, kind of the opposite problem of UV. So yeah, there are a few reasons why visible light is visible light and why we can't see UV or infrared. It's not entirely arbitrary or random. But "seeing" with sound is also a viable evolutionary approach, but less effective in a low-density medium like air and more effective (even than light) in a medium like water.
- yourapostasy 10y ago> Visible is pretty smack dab in the middle of the Sun's peak spectrum... Does this mean that our vision system evolved to pick up the most energetic part of the Sun's spectrum that ends up at the surface? Did it evolve this way so our vision systems' cellular agglomerate don't have to expend as much energy gathering that part of the spectrum as opposed to other parts of the spectrum? If so, then is there any linkage via evolutionary theory that imply our vision system might be among the first vision systems to evolve on the planet, because it filled the most-favored evolutionary niche associated with the lowest energy expenditure to gain a evolutionarily competitive advantage over other pre-human species?
- jcranmer 10y agoI would point out that the crystal field splitting energies happen to correspond to the region around visible light, which means that being able to finely distinguish gradations of visible light would lead you to be able to visually distinguish between many different organometallic ions. I suspect that matters more than the flux of visible light in the solar spectrum.
- Florin_Andrei 10y ago> UV is blocked by water (and our lens material) and can induce chemical changes (read: damage) easier than visible light. Damaging sensitive retina. Perhaps in an environment where UV provides the best illumination (due to the star being hotter, etc) creatures would evolve disposable eyes.
- adrianN 10y agoThe atmosphere and water are both reasonably transparent to visible light but a lot less transparent to other parts of the spectrum.
- gliese1337 10y agoIt's not entirely "random", but it is contingent. I.e., yes, we would be fine if we could see other wavelengths. Indeed, there are creatures than can see other wavelengths. Lots of insects and birds can see UV, and lots of snakes (specifically pit vipers) can see IR. Seeing IR difficult because it is blocked by water and our own bodies radiate it, so it would be useless for our retinas to be able to detect it. You need completely different kinds of eyes (hence pit vipers' eponymous pit organs). IR aside, the visual spectrum is centered where it is because that's where the sunlight that can make it through our atmosphere is brightest. We're adapted to see the light that's actually there, in nature. The range of light that's available actually does include some UV, and the ancestral tetrapod presumably could see that, which is why birds still can; mammals, however, went through a period in our evolution where our primarily-nocturnal ancestors had no need for four-color vision (because there wasn't enough light to support it) and not much UV was available to them, so we lost the UV sensitivity entirely and went down to only 2 kinds of receptors. This is why, e.g., dogs (and most other mammals) are colorblind. Apes eventually independently re-evolved a third color receptor because that was advantageous in things like identifying edible fruit which were important to their lifestyle, but there was never a strong evolutionary pressure to regain UV sensitivity.