3 ms·
Just tell politicians to submit to surveillance, after all, they should have nothing to hide.
by Razengan 10y ago
Just tell politicians to submit to surveillance, after all, they should have nothing to hide.
- gumby 10y agoIdeas like this sound sensible on the surface, but they have unfortunate side effects. For example if politicians must disclose a lot of private information, only those who don't care about that will become politicians. And then since they are comfortable with it, they won't see any reason to control dissemination of others' private info. (BTW I'm not criticizing you by saying this; I don't know a good fix). But you know how everyone gets a blast of schadenfreude when that anti-drink-driving politician is pulled over for driving dangerously after having a few too many? Of course I laugh too, but I wonder if they have been so vocal about the issue because they know how dangerous it is. Whereas I, who drink little and don't even like to drive, probably wouldn't pay much attention to the issue if I became a politician.
- Razengan 10y agoI agree with you. But forcing lawmakers to give up their privacy too would at least, hopefully, theoretically, level the playing field.. Same way as we now at least hold them subject to the same laws involving money, taxes, and can use those laws to indict them.
- gumby 10y ago> Same way as we now at least hold them subject to the same laws involving money, taxes, and can use those laws to indict them. Actually you can't really, and again for good reason, and again with unfortunate side effects as well. Legislators have legislative immunity for good reason: otherwise people would use the courts to attack legislators for making decisions the attackers don't like (the emolument suit against Trump is avowedly similar[1], although he has a slightly different immunity). You can, after all, attack them just as well via the ballot box. In the US the FBI can still investigate crimes they suspect were committed by sitting legislators, and the house or senate can waive one of their members' immunity, so it kind of works. At the opposite extreme, criminals run for office in India in order to take advantage of the legislative immunity from prosecution. All this goes in the "some problems are simple to characterize but not simple to resolve" bucket. When people hear famous quotes from very smart people along the line of "if your explanation of your problem is complex, perhaps you don't really understand it" they often confuse that with "your solution must be simple too." [1] I just heard an interview with one of the law professors bringing suit, Zephyr Teachout, who said she thought it would likely go nowhere but that it was worth making his life difficult. Even if you consider Trump an irredeemably corrupt mastermind, it is abuse of the legal system to use it when you know you'll fail. Not that this is the first time someone filed suit just to annoy someone else.