4 ms·
> able to copy perfect skin from a model onto everyone, making everything a little more fake and less genuine Everybody will do it for a couple of years, then
by golergka 10y ago
> able to copy perfect skin from a model onto everyone, making everything a little more fake and less genuine
Everybody will do it for a couple of years, then it will get old and people will have to think of something original. Just like autotune.
- coldtea 10y agoOnly we still have autotune everywhere. And 20+ years on, all cover shots etc are still photoshopped.
- rishabhparikh 10y agoYes but autotune is a style choice for artists. It's a not something every musician uses. It hasn't taken over music, and it's not like anyone can become a musician because autotune exists.
- coldtea 10y ago>Yes but autotune is a style choice for artists. It's a not something every musician uses. It hasn't taken over music, and it's not like anyone can become a musician because autotune exists. You'd be surprised on both fronts :-) On the first because autotune is prevalent regardless of genre and style choices (even in rock, country, etc). It's just the Cher/T-pain effect that has been toned done, but autotune is very much in use in the industry for vocal correction. On the second, because almost any crap singer pop idol with nice looks can pretend to be in tune and pass out bearable results because of autotune.
- golergka 10y agoAnd it's awesome. Music shouldn't be singing olympics; self-expression and original ideas are worth more than technical skill.
- phkahler 10y agoWe disagree on that, and that's OK. To me there is something special about a live performance. Even more so when it's challenging for the performer. When a signer demonstrates range, or a musician displays technical excellence or provides emotional depth through expression it adds a LOT in my opinion. Knowing this is all faked in recorded music takes something away from it. Ditto for photography. To take an image and retouch it, or to artificially saturate colors can make a great picture. But with a raw photo it's even more interesting to think that scene actually existed and someone captured it for us to look at. In either case, I can enjoy the work but will only be impressed if I know that it's authentic. This is more true than ever today. Holography, you can't currently fake that.
- algesten 10y agoBut then again, where do you draw this line for what is authentic and isn't? In music are you allowed to use amplifiers and speakers? They can add a lot of color and distortion. How about reverb? Rooms that aren't there. EQ to remove unwanted frequencies? Synthesizers? Digital effects? At what point is it not authentic anymore? Same for photography. Are you allowed to touch the aperture? ISO? Shutter speed? Flash? Digital camera? At what point is it not authentic?
- kazinator 10y agoThe thing is, the subject of a photo, the scene and its subjects, are usually not the artists. The photographer is the artist. Photography is processing from the get-go: how the film or CCD responds to light and so on. The grain from low-light on sensitive film can be part of the art and so on. If you mess with the colors of a scene, you're not taking away artistic control from that scene. You also don't put limitations on the post processing art; you're not doing it to fool anyone. There is post processing in music that is obvious art in an analogous way, like taking sampled sounds and re-mixing them to create new stuff. There are effects that are obviously effects. I'm not going to scoff at a great studio reverb, or some echo applied to a vocal or whatever. Nobody is saying that this was recorded in some fjord in Sweden with real echo bouncing off a distant ice wall; there is no lie.
- skrap 10y agoDisclaimer: I'm not a music producer, and my ear isn't that great, but I did write software for one of the major pitch-correction vendors for many years, and I think I have a better-than-average ear for it after listening to it for many years. Pitch correction is something which is used on many, many professionally-produced tracks, and often without the knowledge or consent of the performers. Whether you can hear it or not is a stylistic choice (provided adequate skill from the production team: see [1]). But just because the pitch correction isn't in your face, T-Pain- or Cher-style, doesn't mean it isn't there. The software is better than that, and in the right hands, it just makes people sound more skilled than they are, and you can't hear it. Producers generally are pretty quiet about where they use it to mask blemishes in the performance, probably because they don't want to embarrass anyone. But the producers we sold to would certainly say how much they used it, without naming artists or tracks. [1] http://productionadvice.co.uk/aretha-autotune/ http://productionadvice.co.uk/aretha-autotune/
- algesten 10y agoI believe I hear pitch correction whenever it's used. Do you have an example where it is used and I would struggle to hear it?
- philmcc 10y agoI was involved in the recording and production for a top 40 producer, and can confirm that there was autotune on every single vocal track that left the studio. Here are a few that I was in the room when the artist was recording, and can confirm pitch correction: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=450p7goxZqg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=450p7goxZqg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M8uPvX2te0I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M8uPvX2te0I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E0oyglKjbFQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E0oyglKjbFQ
- algesten 10y agoThe first one has that metallic sound that is a dead give away. First falsetto is quieter than the second one, and you can really hear as he increases the loudness of his voice, the metallic kicks in https://youtu.be/450p7goxZqg?t=1m27s https://youtu.be/450p7goxZqg?t=1m27s Second one has a "Cher moment" almost straight away, just after "wandering the desert a thousand days" the following "mmmm" has a glissando between two notes where we clearly hear the hard edge on what I assume is an auto tune lookahead. I don't actually know how they work, I just assume there's a lookahead for the next note approximation which makes glissandos sound funny. https://youtu.be/M8uPvX2te0I?t=31s https://youtu.be/M8uPvX2te0I?t=31s The last one I can't really fault for too much autotune, more a lack of it. The bridge is especially intense https://youtu.be/E0oyglKjbFQ?t=1m51s https://youtu.be/E0oyglKjbFQ?t=1m51s
- Kiro 10y agoI'm sure a lot of the music you hear is using autotune without you realizing it. It's not some fad.
- baq 10y agoI'm sure all of it is.