3 ms·
The problem with list of logical fallacies is that people quote them in discussion without understanding what they exactly mean. For example, slippery slope is
by nabla9 10y ago
The problem with list of logical fallacies is that people quote them in discussion without understanding what they exactly mean.
For example, slippery slope is only argumentative failure if the slope is implied without justification. If you can provide good argument that slippery slope exists, it's not a bad argument.
Good idea to name appeal to authority as appeal to irrelevant authority.
Appeal to relevant authority is often important shorthand. Some issues are too complex to or require too much domain knowledge to go trough. For example, I consider IPCC reports authoritative on the subject of climate change.
- denzil_correa 10y ago> The problem with list of logical fallacies is that people quote them in discussion without understanding what they exactly mean. Agreed. This is very very common unfortunately. Generally, I classify any argument in a discussion to consist of two parts - about the central topic and off topic (much like ratio decidendi and ober dictum in case judgments). It is important to ignore "ober dictum" and concentrate on "ratio decidendi" much like in law. Fallacies should be pointed out in on-topic part of the discussion while the fallacies in the off-topic part may be used to point out a general pattern or behavior of the person at the other end of the table. It should be made explicitly clear that off-topic sentence fallacies have no bearing on the content of the on-topic sentences. The best strategy however, is to quote the on-topic part and ignore the off-topic parts.
- benchaney 10y agoAgreed. Also, I think there is a more fundamental problem, which is that people don't know how to construct logical arguments. Discussing different types of fallacies is more targeted at getting people to identify flawed arguments, which isn't really helping the underlying problem. The key realization is that every argument is a fallacy unless in explicitly contains a logically valid argument. It doesn't really matter who in an argument is the first to point out one of the categories of argument if both sides of the argument are devoid of logical reasoning.
- innocentoldguy 10y agoIf the point of an argument is to arrive at the truth, then I don't see anything wrong with calling people out for employing logical fallacies in their arguments. If their position cannot stand up to scrutiny, including a discussion on logical fallacies, then it is certainly worth pointing that out, isn't it?