4 ms·
I like MS equation editor. I think it does a pretty great job at being a WYSIWYG editor.
by paulddraper 10y ago
I like MS equation editor.
I think it does a pretty great job at being a WYSIWYG editor.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoI used to think it was about as good as could be expected for a graphical editor (which meant it was rubbish). And then I found LyX which was infinitely better. That was years ago and MS might have caught up by now. And yet, despite how much I like LyX, I keep using real LaTeX instead -- especially when there is complex maths. That's because the ability to create macros in maths eventually outweighs everything else readability-wise. And I'm afraid the same logic applies to AsciiMath. Is there some equivalent to \newcommand[1]{vr}{\mathbf{r_#1}} Or am I just going to have to use somethng `bb"r"_1` for every instance? That's a lot less readable than `\vr1`.
- acrefoot 10y agoI find TeXmac's equation editor to be an even faster WYSIWIG UI than LyX's. For example, a λ is just 'l'+tab. Simarly, you can cycle through other symbols. For b: b->β-> Sadly, TeXmacs hasn't gotten as much love as it deserves: I find it way better than jupyter at producing notebooks/papers that involve math, interactive code, and prose.
- jessaustin 10y agoTeXmacs hasn't gotten as much love as it deserves... Ouch, no Ubuntu package since Vivid? The screenshots look OK... is this worth building from source?
- mhei 10y agoLyX actually has support for math macros, or is that support just not ergonomic for you? Not certain what the best way would be to support macros in a graphical math editor.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoNever noticed them. I mean you can always use evil-red-text. But then what is the point LyX?
- iandioch 10y agoMy father opted to write his maths textbook with MS equation editor. There's always a strong need for tools that aren't just for the technically minded (or HN-reading) audience.
- jwmerrill 10y agoI wonder if it's gotten better since 2002-2004, which is when I used it a lot. I'd be curious to hear what you think about the equation editor in Desmos[1] (full disclosure, my employer). We use an open source WYSIWYG typesetting library called MathQuill[2]. The keystrokes you use are very similar to AsciiMath, but the result is direct editing of the typeset math. E.g. you type '_' to move into a subscript, '^' to move into a superscript, '/' to create a fraction, 'sqrt' to create a radical, etc. I believe that I can edit much faster with this interface than with Microsoft Equation Editor, and that it's approximately similar difficulty to learn. But I'm biased. [1] https://www.desmos.com/calculator https://www.desmos.com/calculator [2] http://mathquill.com/ http://mathquill.com/
- joatmon-snoo 10y agoDesmos is decent IME (am an u/g, so I've used it occasionally); I don't think I ever had serious issues with typesetting (backspacing between sub and superscripts is occasionally awkward, iirc), but navigating the site and using advanced features was always troublesome. I had to fallback to Googling for a specific Desmos calculator a lot.
- wenqin123 10y agoActually it's funny you say that your employer is Desmos. My friends and I use Desmos for all of our graphing assignments and let's say that it has saved us a lot of trouble!
- paulddraper 10y agoI've used mathquill. Thanks so so much for open-sourcing it. I think I remember MS being better in some edge cases. OTOH, I haven't used it in so long maybe that speaks for itself.
- jwmerrill 10y agoIt was open source before we started using it, but we're friends with the creators, so I can pass on the compliment.
- gjjrfcbugxbhf 10y ago
- Lxr 10y agoThe typesetting of MS equation editor is awful though. The spacing, fonts, font sizing etc all look wrong to me. LaTeX just looks beautiful. https://image.slidesharecdn.com/latexseminar-130324215215-phpapp01/95/introduction-to-latex-for-word-users-22-638.jpg?cb=1364162090 https://image.slidesharecdn.com/latexseminar-130324215215-ph...
- ygra 10y agoTL;DR: Actual output on Word 2010: http://hypftier.de/temp/2017-03-27_090308.png http://hypftier.de/temp/2017-03-27_090308.png That output is from the ancient equation editor (MathType Lite, effectively). It used a user-defined font (usuallly Times New Roman), so had no idea about what and where to kern. Output from Word 2007 onwards is significantly better as since then math typesetting is native to Word instead of an OLE object from another application. Also they have their own font (which I find okay for math but ugly for body text), which uses an OpenType table to define math-relevant spacing and kerning factors. The syntax is something between ASCIImath and LaTeX and IMHO quite readable and way more writable than the latter. The syntax is also described in a Unicode Technical Note (http://unicode.org/notes/tn28/ http://unicode.org/notes/tn28/), so there's no reason it couldn't be used elsewhere, either. What has been typed in Word (mostly; as it included cursor movement to get out of inner expressions again; thus can't be pasted right now): \iiint_G [u\nabla^2 v+(\nabla u,\nabla v)]\dd^3 V =\oiint_S (u \partial v/\partial n +v \partial u/\partial n)\dd^2 A This results in this monstrosity when converted back to linear format (which can be pasted): ∭_G〖[u∇^2 v+(∇u,∇v)] ⅆ^3 V〗=∯_S〖(u ∂v/∂n+v ∂u/∂n) ⅆ^2 A〗 Although the following still works just as well (spacing can eliminate the explicit \begin and \end brackets): ∭_G[u∇^2 v+(∇u,∇v)] ⅆ^3 V =∯_S(u ∂v/∂n+v ∂u/∂n) ⅆ^2 A It just seems to me that many people still decrying the old equation editor haven't used or seen Word in a decade. There was a time when publishers still enforced MathType since that's what their Word publishing toolchains were built around for math for over a decade, but I think that has passed by now as well.
- rtkwe 10y agoI tried using MS equation editor when we were supposed to type our proofs in undergrad. Without fail it would crash or start to lag horribly half way through. It seemed to be tied to the number of equations in a document. That's what finally pushed me into learning LaTeX.