38 ms·
Old magnetic cassette and VHS tapes didn't keep time accurately enough to extract reliable data, but now we can analyse even cheap voice recorders. Hmm... It'
by nitrogen 16y ago
Old magnetic cassette and VHS tapes didn't keep time accurately enough to extract reliable data, but now we can analyse even cheap voice recorders.
Hmm... It's been my experience that even miniDV cameras and digital audio recorders can have significant variations in their recording speed over time, which would have to be detected and corrected in order for this technique to work. I once tried to use a laptop with a USB audio interface to record audio and a DV camera for video, but could never sync up the audio and video because the video rate was fluctuating up and down. If I synced up the beginning and end of a clip, the middle would be off by up to half a second.
Though there are techniques to detect and compensate for these variations (some of which were used to restore the wire recordings of Woody Guthrie released as The Live Wire), I'm not convinced the minute variations in the mains supply would survive.
Possible countermeasure: narrow notch filters on every harmonic of the mains frequency plus a high-pass filter, or adaptive noise filtering (such as used by noise reduction audio plugins). Get those hums down into the single-bit levels and you'd need a huge sample size to extract any useful signal.
Any statisticians want to comment on how much data would be required to conclusively identify time, place, and edits?
Edit: another question: could it be possible to detect sample rate jitter caused by periodic variations in the voltage supplied to the sample rate clock generator, even after the noise is filtered out? Could it be counteracted by randomly resampling sections of the audio up or down by a few Hz?